British Columbia

B.C. scraps controversial plan to involuntarily treat youth who overdose

British Columbia has ditched a controversial plan forcing youth to undergo treatment for up to seven days after an overdose and will now develop a new strategy that will include First Nations groups.

Conversations around trauma associated with holding youth against their will informed decision: minister

Mental Health and Addictions Minister Sheila Malcolmson is pictured on Nov. 30, 2017. Malcolmson said the province has decided 'not to bring back the youth stabilization legislation known as Bill 22.' (Adrian Wyld/Canadian Press)

British Columbia has ditched a controversial plan forcing youth to undergo treatment for up to seven days after an overdose and will now develop a new strategy that will include First Nations groups.

Mental Health and Addictions Minister Sheila Malcolmson said concerns about the potential negative impact of the proposed legislation put forward in July 2020 led the province to consult further with First Nations, families, health-care experts and drug users.

"Those conversations have reaffirmed the trauma associated with holding youth against their will, Indigenous youth especially, and that led to our decision to not bring back the youth stabilization legislation known as Bill 22,'' she said in an interview.

Malcolmson's predecessor, Judy Darcy, touted the proposed law as a vital emergency measure to ensure the immediate safety of young people in crisis and said it was based on the advice of multiple experts. She also said youth would leave a hospital with a clear plan to access voluntary services in the community.

However, critics of the proposed legislation said a lack of support and treatment outside a hospital could put youth at greater risk of overdose after their tolerance to toxic street drugs would be lowered during the treatment, usually after they'd ended up in an emergency room.

Some families have steadfastly supported Bill 22, saying the change involving those under 19 would provide a critical window of opportunity to intervene as supports were being built for those struggling with substance-use disorder.

Rachel Staples, who found her 15-year-old son Elliot Eurchuk dead of an overdose in his bedroom in April 2018, said she understands why First Nations, with their history of trauma in the residential school system, would be fearful of having youth detained in hospital.

"I think it would look really bad, from a government standpoint, to force any child from an Indigenous background into care,'' she said in an interview Friday.

Rachel Staples, left, and Brock Eurchuk, right, are pictured in a file photo. The Eurchuk's son, Elliot, was 15 years old when he died in 2018. (Mike McArthur/CBC)

However, youth like her son, who became addicted to a prescription pain medication after several sports injuries, can't think rationally about what's best for them when they refuse treatment, Staples said.

"A kid whose brain is doused in opioids cannot have the capacity to make reasonable decisions for themselves. In the instance of an overdose, their brain is in shock, essentially.''

"I do believe that there's a place for it,'' she said of involuntary treatment. "I would have done anything to try and save my son.''

Dr. Tom Warshawski, former medical director for children and youth for the Interior Health Authority, supported the proposed legislation, saying it recognized the vulnerability of youth and provided a legal tool for clinicians to help them pause drug use while their medical and mental health needs were met.

Warshawski, who testified at an inquest addressing issues related to Eurchuk's death, also said residential treatment beds for youth are key to addressing addiction that may involve mental health issues.

He called on the government to create a central registry for those needing treatment and noted other provinces, including Alberta, have provisions for involuntary treatment of youth addiction.

Government to consult with Indigenous leadership

Indigenous groups already reeling from the discovery of potential human burial sites at residential schools and racism in the health-care system are wary of further traumatizing youth who may be detained involuntarily, Malcolmson said, adding they have asked the province for a model that would be developed with their input.

"We'll design that more comprehensive, culturally safe, trauma-informed system with substance-use care,'' she said.

She could not provide details about what the new model may include or when it would be implemented.

"We're going to have more detailed, targeted conversations with our partners throughout the spring,'' she said.

Malcolmson said all sides recognize the urgency of dealing with youth overdoses.

A woman walks down East Hastings Street in Vancouver during an event to commemorate the International Overdose Awareness Day on Aug. 31, 2020. (Ben Nelms/CBC)

The province is working with groups, including the First Nations Health Authority, the First Nations Health Council and the First Nations Leadership Council, which includes the B.C. Assembly of First Nations, the First Nations Summit and the Union of BC Indian Chiefs.

Figures from the B.C. Coroners Service show at least 115 youth under age 19 have died of an overdose since April 2016, when the province declared a public health emergency. Over 9,400 people in the province have died of an overdose from toxic illicit drugs since then.

Grand Chief Stewart Phillip, president of the Union of B.C. Indian Chiefs, said he and his colleagues were discussing involuntary treatment of youth on Friday but he could not immediately provide comment on partnering with the government on a new policy to replace Bill 22.

"Clearly, the matter is of deep concern for us,'' Phillip said.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?