British Columbia

Auditor general slams B.C.'s management of program designed to protect at-risk species and habitat

British Columbia failed to adequately manage a conservation lands program aimed at protecting habitats for fish and wildlife species that are some of the most diverse in Canada, the auditor general says.

Watchdog concludes program lacks strategic direction and most of its plans are not current or approved

Graham Island, Haida Gwaii, B.C. B.C.'s auditor general has released a scathing report on the province's management of the Conservation Lands Program set up 50 years ago to protect sensitive habitats and at-risk species. (Shutterstock / Keith Levit)

British Columbia failed to adequately manage a conservation lands program aimed at protecting habitats for fish and wildlife species that are some of the most diverse in Canada, the auditor general says.

Michael Pickup said Tuesday the program conserves biologically productive estuaries and grasslands in B.C., as well as wildlife management areas including internationally recognized wetlands and important migratory bird habitat.

"We found that the program, in fact, lacked strategic direction and most plans for wildlife management areas were not current, nor approved," he said, referring to the Ministry of Forests, Lands, Natural Resource Operations and Rural Development.

"We also found that the regional staff had limited strategies to resolve unauthorized use of conservation lands and had not assessed which lands were most at risk from this use," Pickup told a news conference.

Analysis of data between 2009 and 2020 showed hundreds of unauthorized activities occurred on conservation lands, he said of people using motor vehicles in those areas as well as dumping and having dogs off leash.

Lands conserved through the program are located throughout B.C. and include two internationally designated wetlands and habitat critical for migratory birds that fly from the Arctic to the west coast of Mexico and the Rocky Mountains to the Pacific Ocean.

The conservation program was established over 50 years ago. The ministry has been responsible for it since 2011, but it has not monitored it or reported publicly on it, says the auditor's report.

The report covers management of the program from 2016 to 2020, but also assessed older data that still applied to the ministry's current work. The report says goals have not been renewed for over three decades.

Conservation areas include private lands that the ministry has acquired or leased, Crown lands that have been transferred to it, and lands that have been designated as wildlife management areas.

The ministry's conservation partners include Ducks Unlimited Canada, the Nature Trust of B.C., the Habitat Conservation Trust Foundation, the Nature Conservancy of Canada and Climate Change Canada.

A B.C. auditor general's report on the management of the Conservation Land Program found hundreds of unauthorized activities, including illegal dumping. A large illegal tire dump in deep woods south of Vernon, B.C. was discovered in February 2021. (Rudi van Zwaaij)

The report concludes conservation partners, not the ministry, ranked habitats by priority and only one of eight regions, the Omineca, had ranked important habitats for the program.

Three other regions, the West Coast, South Coast and Thompson Okanagan, completed some initial work for the program.

First Nations governments and municipal and regional governments are among the local partners of the program but the report says only three of eight regions provided staff with specific direction to collaborate with Indigenous Peoples.

Pickup made 11 recommendations, with the goal of resolving threats to the most at-risk lands and improving tracking of
inventory on habitats.

They include provincial and regional staff working with conservation partners to establish a shared list of priority habitats and partnering with Indigenous Peoples to develop and implement a strategic plan with measurable targets.

Pickup said the ministry has accepted all the recommendations and while some work is already underway, there is no timeline for when it would be completed.

The ministry said in a statement that it began taking some initiatives in 2020 and staff are working on a strategic plan to
fully address the auditor general's recommendations.

"Additionally, as recommended by the auditor general, we will explore the development of new partnerships with Indigenous Peoples, as well as building on existing ones to advance shared conservation goals."

The ministry could not provide any details on whether work has started on enforcement to deter unauthorized human activities, for example.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?