British Columbia

B.C.'s clear-cut forests are 'dead zones,' emitting more greenhouse gases than fossil fuels, report finds

More greenhouse gases are being emitted from clear-cut logging in British Columbia’s forests than the replanted trees are able to absorb, according to a new report by a local environmental group.

Old-growth forests are particularly adept at capturing carbon

An aerial shot of extensive clearcuts near Cowichan Lake on Vancouver Island. (Jens Wieting/Sierra Club BC)

The clear-cutting of B.C.'s forests is contributing more to greenhouse gases than the burning of fossil fuels, according to a new report from the Sierra Club of B.C.

The report found that 3.6 million hectares of old-growth and second-growth forests were clear-cut in the province between 2005 and 2017 — creating "dead zones" that, combined, are larger than Vancouver Island.

It says the clear-cuts create carbon sequestration dead zones that put more carbon into the atmosphere from decomposing matter and soil than newly replanted trees can absorb.

"That's a very significant portion of B.C.'s forest," said Jens Wieting, the author of the report. "And that's also the combined area of clearcuts that will not help in the fight against climate change." 

According to the environmental group's analysis of provincial data,  logging puts 42 million tonnes of carbon emissions into the atmosphere per year, as well as another 26 million tonnes that can't be recaptured for at least 13 years, while newly planted trees mature enough to absorb the additional carbon.

"It's a huge problem that the emissions from forests are not counted as part of our official emissions," Wieting said. 

An old-growth cedar in a grove slated for logging near Cowichan Lake on Vancouver Island. (Chris Corday/CBC)

Wieting says the combined climate impact of the emissions caused by logging — 42 million tonnes of carbon dioxide, and about 26 million tonnes not captured because of the amount of forests logged — is greater than the 64 million tonnes the Environment Ministry says were released by fossil fuel emissions in all of 2017.

"[Those figures] are somewhat hidden at the bottom of an excel file that the B.C. government released," Wieting said.

The forest's ability to store carbon in the future is also reduced as the trees are cut down. 

A map showing carbon sequestration dead zones in B.C (Sierra Club B.C. )

'Swiss cheese landscape'

These dead zones are not just a problem in British Columbia but, according to the chief scientist with the U.S.-based Geos Institute, Dominick DellaSala, it's some of the worst he's seen. 

"It's shocking to me that a developed country that has such great policies overall is just chewing through its rainforest," DellaSala said. 

"Whenever I fly over the region, it looks like a Swiss cheese landscape … it's devastation."

Old-growth forests, like the ones in B.C., are particularly adept at capturing carbon and can store over 1,000 tonnes of carbon per hectare, which is one of the highest rates on earth. 

"British Columbian coastal and inland rainforests have extraordinary carbon values that are exceeded by only a few places in the world," he said. 

Rik Logtenberg, a city councillor in Nelson, worries about how reports like the one coming out of the Sierra Club B.C. will impact public morale.

"We're working our butts off to plan and think about reducing [our emissions]," Logtenberg said. 

"When you look at all the work and expenses that we are being asked to bear and that we're going to be asking our residents to bear, and then you look at forestry that sort of has a pass — it's really hard to digest and it's hard to sell." 

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.