British Columbia

'Huge' Atlantic lobster washed up in Vancouver likely set free by animal lovers

A huge lobster found dead in Vancouver waters was probably put there on purpose by someone who thought they were helping, say biologists.

Alien lobster with claws almost as big as a man's shoe may have been cruising the Pacific for some time

The large lobster carcass was found washed up in New Brighton Park in Vancouver by Damon Gudaitis, whose size 11 shoe is pictured alongside the claws. (Damon Gudaitis)

It's certainly not a typical sight on Vancouver beaches, or anywhere on the West Coast, in fact: The carcass of a large lobster, native to the Atlantic Ocean, with claws almost as big as a man's size 11 shoe.

"I saw it from far away, and thought, 'Wow, that's a lobster,'" said Damon Gudaitis, who spotted a dog walker pick it from the surf while walking in New Brighton Park in East Vancouver last week.

Gudaitis, curious what the alien crustacean was doing there, snapped a picture of the lobster and sent it to Fisheries and Oceans Canada. He didn't hear back, but local biologists have offered a likely explanation.

And before you break out the garlic butter, it doesn't appear to be a human meal thrown overboard: cooked lobster turns bright red, and the huge claws — which hold tasty meat — were left intact.

Buy and release

We showed the picture to Chris Harley, a marine ecologist at the University of B.C., who said Atlantic lobsters turn up in the Pacific from time to time. One, for instance, was caught off Bowen Island that became a minor media sensation in 2014.

Then, as now, Harley said, the lobster likely crossed the country destined for a dinner plate.

"It was almost certainly brought over live through the live seafood trade for restaurants or the seafood markets," said Harley.

"People will buy live seafood, including lobsters, and then through what they think is an act of kindness, release it into the wild here in Vancouver."

Harley was struck by how big this particular one is, larger than what's normally seen in a live fish tank at the store.

"Those claws are pretty huge," he said. "That suggests that if someone bought it in a store and released it ... then it may have been cruising around for quite a while to grow that big."

Buddhist monk Geshe Tenley releases a lobster back into the ocean during Chokhor Duchen, or the anniversary of Buddha's turning of the Dharma Wheel, from a boat in the waters off Gloucester, Mass., Aug. 3, 2011. (Reuters)

Buddhist ceremony?

Though anyone could be behind such an act, Buddhist monks have been known to free lobsters — including a ceremonial release of hundreds in Massachusetts in 2011.

However, the resident minister at the Vancouver Buddhist Temple, Tatsuya Aoki, said he had never heard of that happening.

Danny Kent, curator of B.C. waters at the Vancouver Aquarium, said people call to ask about liberating lobsters.

"In my time at the aquarium, which is the last 25 years, I've had calls from just average citizens who want to release them," said Kent. A group of Buddhists also called more than a decade ago, he said.

"They ask me if it's a good idea and I told them no."

It's also illegal under federal fisheries law.

Buddhist monk Zhihan, who grew up in Vancouver, said freeing animals is a practice going back 2,000 years — but he doesn't recommend it.

"As Buddhists we treasure life, so whenever we see beings suffering, or about to be killed, then we try to save them."

Zhihan said he hasn't participated in the rituals and tells his students not to because it could "disrupt the ecological balance.

"I try to tell them that it's better to just eat less meat."

Alien invaders

There have been decades of attempts to introduce Atlantic lobster to the Pacific, including federal government programs tossing thousands into the ocean as far back as the 1950s, but none has seemed to take, said Harley.

Still, that's no reason to think tossing a live, alien species into local waters is a benign act.

"It's a bad idea to introduce any animal that's not native to an area," said Kent.

A powerful predator like a lobster could eat other animals, eat other animals' food, and introduce parasites or diseases from a foreign ocean.

Plus, said Harley, scientists know from other introductions — like the now omnipresent European starling — that it can take 10 tries before an alien species takes off.

"You never know which lobster you add that becomes the important one."

With files from Matthew McFarlane


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?