British Columbia

Arbutus community gardens' destruction 'bullying tactic' says Vancouver Mayor Gregor Robertson

Vancouver Mayor Gregor Robertson says CP Rail ignored his request for facilitated talks, as the firm rips up community gardens nurtured for years along the disused Arbutus corridor railway.

Railway brings in heavy equipment, starts dismantling gardens after dispute with city over land

Vancouver Mayor Gregor Robertson says CP Rail ignored his request for facilitated talks, as the firm rips up community gardens nurtured for years along the disused Arbutus corridor railway.

Today's residents are caught in the middle of a decades-old dispute between CP Rail and the city ever since the city refused to allow the railway to develop the land and insisted it remain a greenway

The dispute went all the way to the Supreme Court of Canada, which in 2006 ruled the city had final say over whether to allow development of the corridor, but the railway still maintained the right to use it for train traffic.

The actions by CP are counterproductive, unnecessary, and disrespectful.- Vancouver Mayor Gregor Robertson

"CP's removal and destruction of long-standing structures along the Arbutus Corridor is completely unwarranted, and these actions are simply a bullying tactic," Robertson said in a news release Friday.

"The City offered to purchase the land at fair market value, which CP rejected...There is no business case to reactivate cargo trains along the Corridor, and the City's right to control the zoning was upheld by the Supreme Court of Canada."

Robertson said he had written to the head of CP Rail in July in hopes of reaching a long-term solution through facilitation discussion.

"[This request] has been ignored," said Robertson. "The actions by CP are counterproductive, unnecessary, and disrespectful."

A community garden encroaching on CP Rail's right-of-way is removed. (CBC)

CP says the city's offer isn't what it considers fair. It says the railway shouldn't be faulted for behaving like one.

In a statement issued Thursday, CP Rail spokeswoman Breanne Feigel said it is following through on what it had said it would do — remove obstructions along the track to get it up to federal operating standards for a rail right-of-way.

"We approached the work carefully and were respectful to our neighbours along this corridor," said the statement. "CP Police and other officials were on the property to ensure public safety as machinery was being used."

The statement went on to say work will continue into next week and asked that the public respect the corridor as CP private property and stay out of the area "for their safety and the safety of CP Rail crews."

Community gardens destroyed

CP Rail brought in heavy equipment Thursday afternoon and began tearing down structures and removing the community gardens that local residents have nurtured for years along the disused railway.

CP Rail tears up community gardens

8 years ago
Duration 2:02
Gardens torn down to make way for Arbutus corridor railway in Vancouver

On Wednesday, "no trespass" signs went up and crews moved in with weed whackers to cut back vegetation, but the community gardens remained untouched. By Thursday, however, the clearing of the rail line was underway in earnest.

Gardeners like Kate Wilczak say the removal of the gardens has nothing to do with trains. 

"This has absolutely everything to do with CP feeling that the city isn't meeting their negotiations. Even though the city has made an offer and is willing to negotiate. This is CP greed — this is greed."

Local resident Gerry Oldman stood helplessly by while the community garden he spent years building was destroyed.

"My son and my wife and I spent hours in that garden, you know, building the soil every year and planting," he said looking at the remains.

"You know, not wanting to hurt anybody, not wanting to be in anybody's way, just quietly going about our ​business and planting food that we love. And now it's gone."

Oasis of flowers and veggies

Trains haven't run along the line in more than a decade and some gardeners have spent 20 years or more trying to create an urban green space there — an oasis of flowers and trees.

But in early May, CP Rail suddenly announced it would clear the tracks for train traffic, a move the city considered more of a negotiating bluff than a serious proposal.

CP Rail asked community gardeners to remove everything that encroached on CP land by the end of July, including all plants and gardening sheds. 

That deadline came and went with the gardeners refusing to remove anything. However, the railway continues to follow through on that announcement.

On mobile? Click here for an interactive map of the whole Arbutus corridor line

Follow our web reporter Steve Lus as he travels the Arbutus corridor rail line in his blog below:

On mobile? Click here to follow Steve Lus' Arbutus Corridor blog


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?