British Columbia·Video

B.C. Liberal government would end ICBC monopoly, Wilkinson says

B.C. Liberal Leader Andrew Wilkinson said, if elected, his government would end ICBC's monopoly on auto insurance in British Columbia and open the market to competition for all forms of auto insurance.

Minister in charge of ICBC says Liberals' idea is 'ludicrous'

B.C. Liberal Leader Andrew Wilkinson on Oct. 4. Wilkinson said Tuesday that a Liberal government, if elected, would scrap ICBC's monopoly on car insurance in B.C. and allow private insurers to compete for drivers' money. (Darryl Dyck/The Canadian Press)

B.C. Liberal Leader Andrew Wilkinson said, if elected, his government would end ICBC's monopoly on auto insurance in British Columbia and open the market to competition for all forms of the insurance.

Wilkinson said the change would mean drivers could "shop around," choosing to buy vehicle damage insurance and bodily injury insurance from the private market or to stick with the ICBC model.

"A consistent theme we hear in this campaign is that people are really fed up with ICBC," Wilkinson said during a campaign stop on Tuesday. "The ICBC monopoly has been a failure."

Wilkinson said a B.C. Liberal government would introduce lower premiums for young drivers, ensuring those drivers get two years' credit or — if they complete a driving education course — four years' credit. The change would lead to "significantly" lower premiums for young drivers with a clean driving history, he said.

He said private brokers would be able to offer a range of products for customers to choose from, just as with home insurance or life insurance — and similarly to the system used in Saskatchewan.

ICBC has held a monopoly on car insurance in B.C. for 46 years. Its finances have been ubiquitously described as "a dumpster fire" in recent years, though politicians disagree and point fingers over which party is to blame.

Watch | Andrew Wilkinson says introducing competition would mean cheaper insurance rates:

Leader Andrew Wilkinson says his party would open up the auto insurance market to private companies and lower premiums for young drivers. But the B.C. NDP and Green Party disagree with the move, arguing it won't save drivers money or get them the care that they need if injured. 1:49

Liberal plan is 'ludicrous,' minister says

The NDP has repeatedly said the previous B.C. Liberal government drove the corporation "into the ground" during its 16-year term, amassing a deficit of $1.3 billion.

On Tuesday, NDP candidate David Eby — the minister in charge of ICBC — said Wilkinson's election plan was "ludicrous" and accused the leader of bowing to lobbyists who have pushed for private insurance in the province. 

"Running two different insurance systems cost money. That's why we didn't do it," Eby said Tuesday.

"The reason this wasn't pursued by the B.C. Liberals when they were in power, when [former premier] Gordon Campbell was in power and wanted to privatize ICBC, is because it won't work. It will only increase costs."

ICBC has held a monopoly on car insurance in B.C. since 1974. Its finances have been in a shambles in recent years, as the corporation amassed a deficit of more than $1.3 billion. (Ben Nelms/CBC)

The outgoing provincial government was planning to radically overhaul the province's vehicle insurance system effective May 1, 2021, by cutting lawyers out of the process, claiming premiums would drop by as much as 20 per cent — an average of $400 a year — under the new system.

"I understand the frustration with ICBC. I am frustrated with ICBC ... We are on the verge of delivering 20 per cent discounts, on average, for every driver in the province. To lose that work, to go backwards ... [Wilkinson], I have no idea what you are thinking," Eby said.

Eby conceded some drivers over 45 would see lower rates under a competitive insurance model, but said those under 35 would see premiums increase by 18 per cent. He said motorists under 20 would see rates rise by 37 per cent, referencing a 2018 report from the Insurance Bureau of Canada.

ICBC CEO Nicolas Jimenez and B.C. Attorney General David Eby speaking at a news conference in Vancouver on Jan. 29. (Maggie MacPherson/CBC)

On Tuesday, Wilkinson said the NDP has been responsible for rates rising by an average of $620 per driver over the previous three years — an increase of 48 per cent.

"Under [NDP Leader John] Horgan, B.C. drivers pay the highest premiums anywhere in Canada," the Liberal leader said.

Wilkinson pointed out the the NDP also promised to provide drivers with the money the corporation has saved during the COVID-19 pandemic due to fewer accident claims. He said drivers should have been given their money back months ago, and the NDP is using the potential rebate as an election promise.

Removing the ICBC monopoly would impact government revenue. Asked how the loss of the monopoly might hamper the province's financial recovery in the wake of the pandemic, Wilkinson did not offer a direct answer and instead called for the rebates to be returned to drivers immediately.

With files from The Canadian Press

Add some “good” to your morning and evening.

A variety of newsletters you'll love, delivered straight to you.

Sign up now

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

now