British Columbia

Air Canada backs down on $40 fee to seat child with parent

A leading air passenger rights advocate says he was shocked to read that Air Canada refused to guarantee a toddler a seat next to her parents unless a $40 fee was paid.

Airline says it amended procedures to allow complimentary seating for children on Tango flights

Air Canada has amended their procedures around seating children next to a parent or guardian on Tango flights. (Caley Hartney)

Air Canada says it has amended its policies after a leading air passenger rights advocate criticized an incident where the airline refused to guarantee a toddler a seat next to her parents on a Vancouver to Toronto flight unless a $40 fee was paid.

Gabor Lukacs told CBC News Friday that Air Canada is mandated by the Canadian Transportation Agency (CTA) to make all reasonable efforts to seat children 12 and under adjacent to an accompanying adult. Its own operating tariff says it will do just that — and for free, even on the airline's economy brand, Tango, he added.

"Air Canada is misleading the families and is engaging in fear-mongering,"  Lukacs said.

"Essentially Air Canada is asking for ransom money to ensure that children are seated next to their parents while actually as a matter of law,  they are required to do it anyway — and free of charge.

"It is a cash grab," Lukacs said.

New procedures implemented today

Asked for comment over its procedures for seating children,  Air Canada said Friday that it, "automatically assigns seating without an advance seat selection fee soon after the booking has been made, either directly through Air Canada or through a travel agency, for parents and guardians who have indicated they are travelling with children on a Tango fare."

Nevertheless, the statement said, procedures have been amended today so that Air Canada call centre agents will now assign "complimentary seating to children and their parents or guardians right at the time of booking a Tango fare directly through Air Canada Reservations or their travel agent."
Matt and Caley Hartney say Air Canada told them there was a $40 fee to guarantee their toddler sits beside them on a flight. (Caley Hartney)

They said the new information will be updated to their website shortly.

The change of procedure comes a day after CBC News published the story of Caley and Matt Hartney, who were told that their two-year-old daughter, Charlotte, would not be guaranteed a seat next to one of them, without a $40 charge.

"I clarified with the [call centre agent] three or four times, that he was telling me my child was not guaranteed a seat next to [us] without a fee," Carley Hartney said Friday.

Informed that her story had prompted a change in procedures, Hartney said she was delighted.

"I am really happy to hear that," she said.

'Children have to be safe. Full stop'

The idea that a child under 12 should sit next to a parent or guardian on a flight is not about convenience, Lukacs argues. It is a straightforward safety issue.

"The children have to be safe and Air Canada cannot operate a flight, and cannot have terms and conditions that jeopardize the safety of children — whether it is Tango, executive class or whatever.

"Children have to be safe. Full stop."

Lukacs said that no one is expecting that families should be able to insist on all sitting in a specific row number, just that a child under 12 is seated next to an accompanying adult for no extra charges.

"That's all, " he said. "Nothing beyond that."

Last year, following a passenger complaint against another airline, Air Canada, along with several other carriers, were ordered by the CTA to file new tariffs by March 2, 2015 that "reflect the fact that the respondents have adopted supplemental seating policies or procedures and are making reasonable efforts to ensure that children are seated with their accompanying guardian."


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.