British Columbia

B.C. woman wins $1,200 payout from Air Canada after baggage was delayed 2 days

In September 2021, Jessica Kalynn arrived in Dubai for a six-day trip. Her baggage, however, didn't make it there until two days later. B.C.'s Civil Resolution Tribunal has ordered the airline to reimburse Kalynn for items she bought while waiting for her luggage.

Tribunal rules in favour of woman who bought shoes, clothes and toiletries while waiting for luggage

Jessica Kalynn says she was forced to buy more than $2,000 in new items after her baggage was delayed during a trip to Dubai. (CBC)

In September 2021, Jessica Kalynn arrived in Dubai for a six-day trip.

Her baggage, however, didn't make it there until two days later. 

Air Canada offered Kalynn $500 in compensation, but she filed a claim with B.C.'s Civil Resolution Tribunal, demanding more money to cover her expenses.

Last week, the tribunal ruled in her favour. 

Baggage delays are one of many frustrations travellers are facing at airports across Canada as airlines scale up operations to meet post-pandemic travel demand.

In the dispute, Kalynn argued she was entitled to $2,120.67 for all the items she claimed she was forced to purchase in Dubai while she waited for her baggage.

Since Air Canada had already paid $500, she sought another $1,620.67.

Four pairs of shoes, five tops

Once she learned her baggage was delayed, Kalynn purchased more than $2,000 in items, including four pairs of shoes, six bottoms, five tops, one bathing suit, two bras, two pairs of underwear, one package of socks and toiletries, according to the tribunal's written judgment. 

Kalynn told the tribunal she needed the clothing because her trip included a work conference, a professional dinner at a high-end restaurant, and gym workouts.

Air Canada argued the expenses were excessive and tribunal member Shelley Lopez agreed — to a degree.

"I find it was reasonable for Ms. Kalynn to purchase some different clothes and shoes given the activities she undisputedly had scheduled," she wrote.

"Even with the different activities, I find Ms. Kalynn has not adequately explained why she needed four pairs of footwear (in addition to what she wore on the plane) and six bottoms and five tops, even if she had to change her clothes during a day."

Still, Lopez found that Air Canada owed Kalynn further compensation. She ordered the airline to pay $700 in compensation on top of the $500 the airline had already paid.

Air passengers aren't immediately entitled to the maximum amount in compensation, but must explain to the tribunal why their purchases were reasonable. (Geoff Robins/AFP/Getty Images)

Passengers entitled to compensation

Gábor Lukács, an air passenger rights expert, welcomes the decision.

"[It] shows that passengers going to the CRT are going to get justice," he said, adding that passengers don't need to simply accept whatever amount an airline initially offers and deems reasonable.

In Canada, if baggage is delayed, passengers can claim up to about $2,200 in damages.

But the key, Lukács says, is to make it clear that your purchases were justifiable.

"This decision ... signals to the passenger when your baggage is delayed, it's not a reason to go on a shopping spree," said Lukács.

If a traveller can prove to the CRT that all the purchased items were necessary, he says it's entirely reasonable to expect the maximum in compensation. He encourages air passengers who lose their baggage to keep all their receipts, as well as documentation regarding how the items were used.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Joel Ballard is a reporter with the CBC in Vancouver. You can reach him at joel.ballard@cbc.ca

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?

now