Air conditioning is a necessity, not a luxury — despite the emissions and energy costs, advocates say
Critics say B.C.'s current response to heat emergencies is not helpful for vulnerable people
B.C. planners and policy analysts say the benefits of air conditioners during extreme heat situations are very clear — and concerns over their environmental and financial impact show misplaced priorities.
During last year's deadly heat dome in B.C., authorities found over two-thirds of the 619 people that died did not have air conditioning in their homes.
With extreme heat events more likely in future due to climate change, advocates are asking the province to provide vulnerable people with air conditioning units.
Data shows air conditioner use is already on the rise in B.C., leading to an associated energy and emissions toll — including one instance of the province's public housing authority switching off cooling in some of its properties to save energy.
Robyn Chan, chair of the Vancouver City Planning Commission, says little has changed since last year with respect to B.C.'s extreme heat response. Unlike other jurisdictions like Portland, Ore., B.C. has never handed out air conditioners through social assistance programs or otherwise.
"I haven't seen anything put into place that is actually providing people with cooler temperatures, which is what they need to survive," she told CBC News.
"We've been pushing the city and Vancouver Coastal Health to … make faster changes because we've already seen the impacts this summer of what a heat wave can do."
In a 2021 memo during the heat dome, the planning commission — a volunteer body that advises the city on short and long-term planning solutions — had recommended the city work directly with health providers to hand out air conditioners, as well as ensure 24-hour access to shaded parks. The memo was co-authored by planning commissioners Gabrielle Peters and Amina Yasin.
Research shows that air conditioners can help vulnerable people who cannot easily regulate their own body temperatures or have mobility issues.
Meanwhile, energy costs from ACs are rising. A 2020 report from B.C. Hydro found residential air-conditioning use had more than tripled since 2001, and many residents were adding an average of $200 to their summer bill by using air conditioning units inefficiently.
B.C. Housing facilities switched off cooling
Chan said that as the one-year anniversary of the heat dome approached, she unearthed a 2017 report that showed that B.C. Housing — the provincial body responsible for low-income housing — had switched off the cooling function in four of their properties for over a decade.
The report describes how the authority had retrofitted certain properties with heat pumps in 2010-11, which provide cooling as well as heating, and what they learned from the process.
It details how the cooling function was switched off in three Vancouver locations and one Surrey location, containing 179 housing units in total, due to energy costs.
I hope everyone denying that air conditioning is an immediate and life saving tool is lobbying <a href="https://twitter.com/bcndp?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">@bcndp</a> for other solutions right now. Because <a href="https://twitter.com/BC_Housing?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">@BC_Housing</a> disabled the cooling function on heat pumps because tenants "abused" it (page 22).<a href="https://t.co/sDvEP4F5Yd">https://t.co/sDvEP4F5Yd</a>—@robynmchan
"The heat pumps introduced cooling in the summer and that was not thought out very well. They were only supposed to provide cooling above 27 C outside, but our tenants quickly found out that they could override that," reads a quote from an unnamed maintenance supervisor in the report.
"Because the tenants are not paying the heat pump electricity bills, there are certainly abuses."
Chan said the case showed that B.C. Housing seemed to prioritize financial costs over tenant safety or comfort.
- Hundreds died because they couldn't escape B.C.'s extreme heat. Alerts wouldn't have saved them, advocates say
In a statement, a spokesperson for B.C. Housing said cooling functions at one property had been reactivated this year after the report came to light, with work underway to reactivate the function at the other three locations.
"While we have more to do, we have taken important steps to enhance our readiness for extreme heat events," the spokesperson said, pointing to an initiative that saw the authority hand out fans, spray bottles, and portable air conditioners to some tenants on a case-by-case basis.
Peters, a disabled writer and policy analyst, said the B.C. Housing incident was reflective of a wider attitude in B.C. that paints air conditioning as a luxury, and not a life-saving necessity.
"I think people, in order to sustain life, should be allowed to pollute as much as is necessary," she said, saying a focus on individual carbon footprints is a distraction from the much larger amount of emissions caused by rich and powerful people.
Peters says that in B.C., many low-income people live in small apartments that do not have good ventilation — often relying exclusively on windows for air circulation, which means heat often stays inside longer and leads to people feeling heat exhaustion quicker.
She says the current provincial response to heat — which involves cooling centres and advice for individuals — is at odds with science, and reflects ableist attitudes.
"They're giving advice for the people least likely to die in heat and totally ignoring the rest of us," she said.
"Just telling people … to put a cold cloth on themselves or something is very much a temporary measure for a modest increase in external pressure. It's not a way to cope with extreme heat."
Staying cool helps to prevent dehydration and heat-related illness. Learn more tips to keep you and your family safe: <a href="https://t.co/vuyPQkdtG2">https://t.co/vuyPQkdtG2</a> <a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/BCHeat?src=hash&ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">#BCHeat</a> <a href="https://t.co/J7eHaBATS6">pic.twitter.com/J7eHaBATS6</a>—@BCGovNews
Peters says policymakers should work to create a multifaceted approach to handing out air conditioners as a form of heat mitigation.
This includes classifying them as medical devices, providing them through community centres and food banks, funding mutual aid groups to assist with installing them, and creating summer projects for university students around heat mitigation.
A coroner's report into last year's heat wave deaths recommended the Ministry of Health review the possibility of making air conditioners and other cooling devices available to vulnerable people as medical equipment by December this year.
Meanwhile, the International Energy Agency forecasts that increasing demand for cooling will lead to a spike in greenhouse gas emissions by 2050.
In a report co-authored with the United Nations Environment Programme, it said an estimated 3.6 billion cooling appliances are currently in use; but if cooling was provided to everybody who needs it, as many as 14 billion of the appliances would be required by 2050.
To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.
By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.
Become a CBC Account Holder
Join the conversation Create account
Already have an account?