British Columbia

Province gives go-ahead to Abbotsford quarry to destroy peregrine falcon nesting ledge

An Abbotsford company has been given the go-ahead from the province to remove a peregrine falcon nesting site from a quarry it plans to reopen. Conservationists and local residents say $75,000 in mitigation plans to encourage continued breeding at the site aren’t suitable.

Mountainside Quarries Group Inc. will spend $75,000 on mitigation

A mature and a young peregrine falcon photographed at the quarry site on Quadling Road in the Barrow Town area of Abbotsford B.C. (Howard Bailey)

An Abbotsford, B.C., company has been given the go-ahead from the province to remove a peregrine falcon nesting site from a quarry it plans to reopen.

The decision is a blow to a group of 17 local homeowners and conservationists who have been campaigning to preserve a rocky ledge at the site, which has been a productive nesting area for the dynamic bird of prey that has been on and off the federal government's endangered list as vulnerable to decline.

Peregrine falcons in B.C. still remain on government lists that include animals or ecosystems of concern or that are threatened.

The birds usually nest on rock ledges high on steep cliffs, mostly in undisturbed areas. Being near the top of the food chain, their well-being is an indicator of how B.C.'s biodiversity is doing.

Data compiled by the federal government shows that, since 1995, there have been on average around eight occupied nesting sites in the Lower Mainland for the subspecies of peregrine falcon found at the quarry site.

A pair of young peregrine falcons at an abandoned quarry in Abbotsford that has been a productive site for the birds since it closed in 2012. A new owner has been given a permit by the province to remove the ledge where the birds breed. (Howard Bailey)

Howard Bailey, a scientist advocating for the resident group and an avid birder, has regularly visited the site for the past six years to observe the peregrines who nest and raise their young there.

"It's literally ... a source of young for the region," he said

'Be absolutely careful'

Bailey, along with local resident Chriss Kitt, who for the past 14 years has lived less than 200 metres from the quarry site on Quadling Road, say that the provincially approved mitigation strategies won't guarantee that the falcons will continue to nest and reproduce at the site.

"You want to be absolutely careful with the remaining viable nesting sites, especially if you're looking at how to recover this population over the long term," Bailey said. 

For the past three years, Mountainside Quarries Group Inc. has been working toward reopening the quarry, which was shuttered in 2012 after its previous owner went bankrupt.

 

Mountainside says it has obtained a mining permit from the province to reopen the quarry to mine for aggregate.

For safety reasons, the company says it needs to remove the ledge where peregrine falcons have been nesting. To do so, the company needed to obtain a special permit from the Ministry of Forests, Lands, Natural Resource Operations and Rural Development (FLNRORD) as the B.C. Wildlife Act protects peregrine falcon nests from being disturbed or destroyed.

On Friday, the ministry issued the permit to Mountainside.

It said the decision was made based on available falcon population estimates, trends in productivity and consultation with local groups and the company.

The province says the company has agreed to create new nest ledges on site and new nest boxes, and to monitor them for the next five years.

Mountainside will also arrange for satellite transmitters to be placed on the pair of falcons that have previously bred at the site, in order to facilitate a study of them for the next four years.

Peregrine falcons at a quarry on Quadling Road in Abbotsford. (Howard Bailey)

Mountainside to spend $75K on mitigation

"Given the mining operation, FLNRORD believes that the mitigation to be completed is reasonable to address the relative risks to these falcons and the local species population," a ministry spokesperson said in an email.

Mountainside said it will spend $75,000 on the mitigation.

"It's a comprehensive mitigation plan," said John Moonen, a spokesperson for the company.

"We've agreed to spend the money and do this plan. It makes up for the loss of that nesting ledge."

Moonen says the company is still working on operational plans with the City of Abbotsford before beginning work.

He did not say when work at the site would begin.

Kitt said the residents group will try to appeal the decision to issue the company the permit to destroy the nesting ledge.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

now