Doctor battles Bell's Virgin Mobile for six months over $2,400 bill she never racked up

For the past six months, Wing Sum Tang has battled Virgin Mobile over $2,400 in wireless charges she never racked up. After being contacted by CBC News, Bell determined that Tang isn't responsible because this is likely a case of mistaken identity.

Bell has now dropped the charge, saying it 'looks to be a case of mistaken identity'

A Toronto-area doctor has spent six months battling a $2,400 phone bill with wireless provider Virgin Mobile, which is owned by Bell. (CBC)

For the past six months, Wing Sum Tang has battled Virgin Mobile over $2,400 in wireless charges she never racked up. In fact, she has never even been a customer with Virgin, a wireless provider owned by Bell.

But someone opened an account in the name "Wing Tang," and Virgin targeted Tang when the charges went unpaid.

From the outset, Tang, a Toronto-area family physician, has contended she's a victim of identity theft. Although she filed a police report and provided Virgin with documents to prove her innocence, the Bell subsidiary continued to demand its money. Tang said Virgin even sent a collection agency after her.

"They're trying to make the victim pay," she said. "A typical case of a big corporation which doesn't care."

After CBC News reached out to Bell this week, the telco offered Tang an apology. Bell stated that it has now concluded she isn't responsible for the charges and that this appears to be a case of "mistaken identity" in a fraud case. 

Tang says she's relieved, but is still upset over the time she spent trying to clear her name.

"I definitely can't get that back," she said. "Six months of my life and all the back and forth that I had to go through, all the accusations suggesting that I'm lying."

'I was in disbelief'

Tang's saga began in early October when she received a mailed letter from Virgin stating that a charge of $148 was past due on her account. 

She contacted Virgin Mobile's fraud department and provided evidence she wasn't behind the account. This included documents showing that she has a wireless plan with Rogers and that personal information Virgin had for her was wrong. 

Tang said she also told Virgin about an incident in July she believes is related. In that case, someone opened an account with Freedom Mobile using her name and ran up a big bill. Within three weeks, Freedom had determined the account was fraudulent and that she wasn't responsible for the charges. 

Following her conversation with Virgin, Tang waited for news about her current case. Instead, about three weeks later she received another letter, this time demanding a payment of $2,400. Virgin said if she didn't pay "immediately," her account would be sent to a collection agency.

"I was in disbelief and obviously very upset," said Tang. "I didn't hear back [from Virgin] and then I just got a giant bill."

Someone else using the name Wing Tang rang up big long distances charges with Virgin Mobile and didn't pay the bill. (Kiyoshi Ota/Bloomberg)

Tang said she called Virgin and learned that its fraud department had determined no fraud had occurred and the charges she faced were valid. 

"That was their conclusion, and it didn't matter what I had to tell them," she said. "It seems they're more interested in recovering their money."

Tang turned to the Toronto police, who are still investigating her case. She also filed a complaint with the Commission for Complaints for Telecom-Television Services (CCTS), an industry group that rules on consumer telecom disputes.

According to submitted documents, Virgin told the CCTS the matter had been "resolved" — with Tang still owing $2,400. She rejected that resolution, so the CCTS began investigating her complaint. 

"Virgin Mobile [is] persisting and persisting and persisting despite all the steps that I have taken," said Tang. 

Detective Constable Wayne Lee with the Toronto police says identity theft is 'pretty rampant.' (Jonathan Hayward/The Canadian Press)

Frustrated by the situation, her husband, Ravi Khindri sent a complaint to Virgin's executive office last week. He condemned the wireless provider for how it has handled the case and insisted that it cancel the charges. Virgin declined. 

"There've been many sleepless nights," said Khindri, also a Toronto-area family physician. "We just want to move on with our life, have this taken away."

'2 people with similar names'

Bell said it now knows enough about the wireless account in question to exonerate Tang.

"We've had the opportunity to continue our investigation into this very complicated case," said spokesperson Jacqueline Michelis in an email to CBC News. 

She said the account was set up in August 2017 by a "Wing Tang" and that there was no indication of fraudulent activity until this past September when big charges were racked up for overseas calls and the phone bill went unpaid.

Bell said this 'looks to be a case of mistaken identity involving two people with similar names.' (CBC)

Michelis said Bell now realizes it was targeting the wrong person.

"Our fraud team has deepened its investigation into new scenarios of subscription fraud and what looks to be a case of mistaken identity involving two people with similar names."

She said the investigation will continue.


Sophia Harris

Business reporter

Based in Toronto, Sophia Harris covers consumer and business for CBC News web, radio and TV. She previously worked as a CBC videojournalist in the Maritimes where she won at Atlantic Journalism Award for her work. Contact:


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?