Business

Several provinces are dropping vaccine passports, but some businesses aren't on board

Some provinces are dropping COVID-19 vaccine mandates for restaurants, gyms and other venues. Businesses in these areas are essentially being allowed to decide for themselves if they want to keep the requirements or open their doors to unvaccinated customers.

Some businesses choosing to maintain vaccine requirements say they've faced a backlash

Some businesses to keep using vaccine passports after mandates end

10 months ago
Duration 1:57
As provinces end mandates for proof of COVID-19 vaccination, some businesses are ready for a return to normalcy, but others say they plan to continue checking vaccine passports anyway.

Although Saskatchewan has dropped its provincewide vaccine passport program for businesses, Colin Hall would like to continue requiring customers show proof of vaccination at his Regina yoga studio.

Even so, he has decided instead to nix the requirement. Hall said when he first introduced a vaccine requirement last July, months before Saskatchewan imposed a provincial mandate, he had support from his customers, but also faced a backlash. 

"We were subjected to a barrage of harassment online and by phone … 'We're going to boycott you, we're going to sue you, we're going to find out where you live,'" said Hall, co-owner of Bodhi Tree Yoga.

"I'm honestly not sure that I can handle another round of anti-vaxxers harassing us and trying to intimidate us."

Colin Hall is the co-owner of Bodhi Tree Yoga in Regina. The studio first introduced a vaccine requirement last July, but reluctantly ended it when the province removed vaccine mandates earlier this week. (Matt Howard/CBC)

Several provinces are dropping their COVID-19 vaccine passport programs for entry to restaurants, gyms and other venues, leaving it up to individual businesses to decide if they want to open their doors to unvaccinated customers. 

"You're kind of making businesses choose one side of the fence themselves, where previously governments made that choice for them," said Toronto-based retail consultant Bruce Winder. 

"It's going to be a tough one for businesses, because it's such a polarizing topic right now."

On Feb. 9, Alberta became the first province to nix its vaccine passport program.

WATCH | Alberta scraps vaccine requirement for businesses: 

Alberta drops vaccine passport, plans to loosen other COVID-19 restrictions

10 months ago
Duration 3:55
Albertans no longer need to show their proof of vaccination to dine in restaurants or sit in entertainment venues. As of Monday, masking requirements will be lifted for students of all ages.

"The threat of COVID-19 to public health no longer outweighs the hugely damaging impact of health restrictions on our society, on people's mental health, on their emotional well-being," Premier Jason Kenney said at a news conference last week. 

Saskatchewan was next in line, ending its vaccine passport policy on Monday. Both Ontario and Manitoba plan to drop all proof of vaccination requirements on March 1. Quebec and Newfoundland and Labrador will end all vaccine mandates for businesses by mid-March. 

'I'm getting 1-star reviews'

Although most businesses are expected to drop their vaccine requirements in line with the provinces, not all are following suit — despite the possibility that they could face a backlash.

Dave Kantor, owner of The Cave Beastro in Edmonton, said he decided to keep his restaurant's vaccine mandate in place because he felt it was premature for Alberta to drop the requirement.

Dave Kantor, owner of The Cave Beastro in Edmonton, said he decided to keep his restaurant’s vaccine mandate in place because he felt it was premature for Alberta to drop the requirement. (Submitted by Dave Kantor)

"I look at the [COVID-19] numbers. They're still pretty high," he said. "I don't feel that squeezing all kinds of people into a place and getting more people sick is what we need to do right now."

He said his decision has garnered mixed reviews, with some people applauding it. Others, not so much.

Kantor says people have told him "I'm discriminating, I'm segregating, how I'm just a disgusting person for allowing this to go on."

"I'm getting one-star reviews."

Still, he says he has no regrets about his decision and won't drop his vaccine requirement until he feels it's safe to do so. 

Other holdouts include Café Bicyclette in Edmonton.

"We have taken a more prudent approach," said Daniel Cournoyer, executive director of Café Bicyclette. "So far, overwhelmingly, our patrons are saying, 'Thank you so much for doing so.' "

Daniel Cournoyer, executive director of Café Bicyclette in Edmoton says his customers support keeping the café's vaccine requirement in place, even though Alberta dropped its mandate last week. (Nathan Gross/CBC)

Saskatoon's Broadway Theatre is maintaining its vaccine mandate for all films and events, according to a post it made on Facebook

More than 100 people have commented on the post, some praising the theatre for keeping patrons safe, while others are alleging discrimination. 

"I certainly hope you have legal repercussions for this discriminatory policy," wrote one person. 

The theatre declined to comment. 

Businesses may face legal disputes

At a news conference earlier this month, Saskatchewan Premier Scott Moe said businesses that maintain their vaccine requirement are now on their own if they face legal disputes.

"My advice to them would be to consult their lawyer," he said. "Private businesses [are] free to do what they choose, but they also may have some consequences."

Tanya Walker, employment lawyer with Walker Law in Toronto, said that in general, business have the right to impose vaccine requirements for their customers. (Submitted by Tanya Walker)

Toronto employment lawyer Tanya Walker of Walker Law said businesses can, in general, impose vaccine mandates for customers.

"I don't think it should be a problem for a business owner to continue to require that its customers supply proof of vaccination in situations where the customers are in close proximity to each other," said Walker. "[It's] justified to help the public." 

The Canadian Civil Liberties Association has said businesses could face a legal challenge if their vaccine requirement infringes on individual human rights, such as refusing entry to someone who can't get vaccinated for medical reasons. 

Landmark Cinemas scraps vaccine mandate

Many businesses, including Landmark Cinemas, are choosing to drop their vaccine requirement in provinces that no longer have mandates.

Landmark's CEO Bill Walker said the theatre company, which has 40 locations across western Canada and Ontario, supports vaccination but also feels it's time to return to some sense of normalcy. 

To help customers feel safe, Walker said theatres will continue to implement safety precautions such as spacing out seating and enforcing mask policies.

Landmark Cinema's CEO Bill Walker said the theatre chain will drop its vaccine requirement in locations that no longer have vaccine mandates. (CBC/Colin Hall)

"We're going to continue to try to create an experience that makes everyone feel comfortable and welcome and just try to escape and enjoy the movies for a couple of hours," he said. 

For Hall, who felt he had to drop the vaccine requirement at Bodhi Tree Yoga, there's some consolation as he believes unvaccinated people aren't interested in coming to his studio anyway.

"At this point, I think we've kind of alienated everyone who's not vaccinated."

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Sophia Harris

Business reporter

Based in Toronto, Sophia Harris covers consumer and business for CBC News web, radio and TV. She previously worked as a CBC videojournalist in the Maritimes where she won an Atlantic Journalism Award for her work. Contact: sophia.harris@cbc.ca

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?

now