Oil patch earnings season will bring more red ink

Energy sector earnings are expected to be better than they were in the winter, but that's not saying much.

Fort McMurray wildfires are a complicating factor

Analysts are expecting oilsands numbers to improve over the first quarter of the year, when oil hit a low of $26 US a barrel.

Today, earnings will start to flow from the energy sector. Generally speaking they're expected to be better than they were in the winter quarter, but that's not saying much.

Red ink will continue to be a major theme, but it won't be the only theme. The impact the Fort McMurray wildfires had on production will be key for oilsands companies, and as importantly, analysts will be watching to see if there's any confidence in oil at least maintaining current levels.

"You'll see some strong improvement in Q2 over Q1," said Martin Pelletier, a portfolio manager with Trivest Wealth Counsel

"You had oil up 48 or 49 per cent. Natural gas was up 31 per cent, that's going to reflect in some pretty good top-line revenue numbers."

Refining margins were also strong in the quarter. That will help the big so-called integrated companies, such as Imperial Oil and Suncor, which refine oil and sell gasoline. In a research report, BMO Capital Markets analyst Randy Ollenberger noted that refining margins in Canada were above $40 a barrel.
The Fort McMurray fires led to an estimated 1.5-million barrels of oil being pulled off the market. That caused a bump up in the price of crude. (user @ccccrystal__. (Twitter))

Impact of the wildfires

But then there are the wildfires that raged through the Fort McMurray region in May, taking as much as 1.5 million barrels a day of supply off the market. 

As a result, Ollenberger wrote that he expects the production of four key oilsands players: Suncor, Cenovus, Husky, and Imperial Oil to be lower by 25 per cent in the quarter. Ollenberger expects all but Imperial to post a loss and forecasts that Imperial will break even in the quarter. Notably, Ollenberger is expecting oilsands numbers to improve over the first quarter of the year, when oil hit a low of $26 US a barrel.

It was, of course, the production cuts resulting from the fires that helped to boost the price of oil, the very definition of cold comfort.

Outside of the oilsands, the picture is brighter, with the large majority of senior producers able to take advantage of higher prices without the pain of production cuts.

But what's next?

However, Pelletier pointed out that the market prefers to look forward, not backward, so the focus will be on what comes next. Will oil prices manage to stay above $40 US a barrel, or will they sink again?

In the past two springs, oil topped out in late spring, and then fell sharply as the summer driving season came to an end. In 2014, the situation was made worse by OPEC's decision to turn on the taps. Those taps are still turned on maximum. 

According to the International Energy Agency, oil production in the Middle East has been above a record 31 million barrels a day for three months, offsetting, at least in part, the drop in U.S. production. The IEA still thinks that the market will be in balance in this half of 2016.

Pelletier counts himself as bear on oil at the moment. He said he will be watching to see if energy companies chose to hedge (or presell their oil) when oil prices were high, whether they are continuing with cost cutting, or possibly increasing spending.

"I think the risks are certainly more to the downside, the question is: are companies sharing that same view, or are they optimistic?"


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.