Business

Mustard shortage could lead to higher prices and empty shelves, industry warns

A mustard seed shortage is driving up prices and could leave some store shelves with scant supply of the yellow spread before products from the new harvest hit markets this fall, industry experts say.

Canada is a major supplier of mustard seeds, and the 2021 crop yield was far lower than usual

Under normal circumstances, Canada is one of the world's largest suppliers of mustard seeds, but 2021 was a bad year for the country's crop. (Shane Hennessey/CBC)

A mustard seed shortage is driving up prices and could leave some store shelves with scant supply before the new harvest hits markets this fall, industry experts say.

France, the world's biggest consumer of the popular condiment, is already facing shortages while other countries are seeing prices climb as last year's mustard seed stocks are depleted.

The problem can be traced back to the Canadian Prairies, where the majority of the world's mustard seeds are grown.

A drop in the number of acres planted last year in Saskatchewan and Alberta combined with a severe summer drought means crop yields are far lower than usual.

In Saskatchewan, for example, about 300,000 acres or roughly 120,000 hectares were seeded with mustard last year, a drop of about 25 per cent compared with the 10-year average of 400,000 acres (about 160,000 hectares), according to provincial data.

Weather a factor

Then dry, hot weather badly damaged crops.

"The heat that we got last July just absolutely devastated yields," said Stuart Smyth, associate professor in the Department of Agricultural and Resource Economics with the University of Saskatchewan in Saskatoon.

"Mustard seed yield was only 35 per cent of the 10-year average."

Prices for the yellow spread have steadily increased since.

For example, a hundredweight of yellow mustard seeds, roughly 45 kilograms, cost more than $150 a week ago — triple the $50 price tag from last year, according to a Saskatchewan database of agricultural commodity prices.

Brown mustard seeds, used in Dijon-style mustard, cost $182.33 per hundredweight a week ago, compared with $45 last year.

Eric Giesbrecht, a chef and owner of Brassica Mustard, had no choice but to pay 400 per cent more for his supply of mustard seeds this year. (Rory Mayer/The Canadian Press)

Lack of seed availability

Yet for mustard makers, the high prices are only half the battle. Some are struggling to even find enough Canadian seeds to buy.

"I bought mustard seeds in the spring of this year from last year's harvest … and I had to almost beg my supplier to sell it to me," said Eric Giesbrecht, a chef and owner of Brassica Mustard.

"It was probably the last 2,000 pounds he had and he was worried he wouldn't have enough to fill his other orders."

The Calgary-based business owner ended up paying about 400 per cent more than usual — an astronomical cost increase he's mostly had to absorb.

"Using Canadian mustard seeds is just part of the identity of my company, so importing seeds wasn't an option," Giesbrecht said.

Some mustard makers feel the squeeze

Kraft Heinz Co., which makes Heinz Yellow Mustard and the Dijon mustard brand Grey Poupon, said the shortage has only impacted the brown mustard seeds it uses in its Dijon variety.

The company said as soon as it identified a potential supply issue, it worked to find other sources of brown mustard seed in different parts of the world.

"We also worked to prioritize [products] in our Grey Poupon portfolio that we know are customer favourites to ensure we would avoid shortages of those key products," the company said in an emailed statement.

The brown mustard seeds that go into premium mustards like Dijon are currently the hardest to find, while basic varieties have manageable supply, so far. (iStock/Getty Images)

No one from Dijon mustard maker Maille Canada, a subsidiary of Unilever, was available for comment.

McCormick & Co., Inc., maker of French's mustard, said it's not experiencing shortages of mustard seeds.

The company attributed its inventory position to its "resilient global supply chain and strong sourcing capabilities."

Domestic processing can't cut the mustard 

Canadian grocers directed inquiries on mustard supply to the Retail Council of Canada.

Michelle Wasylyshen, spokesperson for the retail industry group, said Canadians should have no concerns about food availability though "there may be times when consumers will have to look for alternatives and substitutions."

LISTEN | Why Canada's mustard seed crop is facing a 'perfect storm' for shortages: 
Canada is the top producer of mustard seeds in the world. But over the past two years the crop has experienced major shortages. Experts say the drought out West as well as low inventory resulted in a “perfect storm”.

"In Canada, last year's harvest for mustard was heavily impacted by drought and this affected production," she said.

"We don't manufacture a lot of mustard domestically, but rather provide the seed to other countries which then produce the actual condiment."

Indeed, the shortage has underscored how little of the mustard seed crop grown in Canada stays here to be processed into a condiment.

"It's a missed opportunity," said Sylvain Charlebois, a professor of food distribution and policy at Dalhousie University.

"Our process sector needs help developing the expertise and capacity."

A farmer holds a handful of mustard sees in this Aug. 24, 2015 photo. A drop in the number of acres of mustard crops planted last year in Saskatchewan and Alberta combined with a severe summer drought means yields are far lower than usual, resulting in both a shortage of seeds and higher prices for what is available. (Mike McCleary/The Associated Press)

Dijon shortage a larger issue in France

While so far Canadian stores appear to have ample supply, it may just be a matter of time before broader mustard market conditions hit retail here, he said.

"It takes a while before ingredient shortages work their way through the supply chain," Charlebois said.

"It's quite possible that we'll run short of mustard but it may happen a little bit later in Canada."

Unlike in France, where Dijon mustard is a kitchen staple almost as commonplace as salt and pepper, Canadians tend to only buy mustard once every six months or less and would likely be more amenable to substitutes, Charlebois said.

"We could actually see less supply at some point but it wouldn't be a catastrophe and it would be short lived."

Healthy fall harvest expected

Meanwhile, scientists warn climate change could lead to more frequent and severe droughts in the Prairies, a situation that could affect future crop yields.

But Smyth said drought management has improved dramatically in recent years, which will help maximize harvests.

This year so far, he said the growing season has been promising, boding well for a healthy harvest this fall.

In addition, the number of planted acres is up.

Saskatchewan farmers planted about 550,000 acres of mustard seed this year, or roughly 220,000 hectares, an increase of almost 40 per cent compared with the 10 year average, according to provincial data.

"If conditions hold here over the next four to six weeks, we should be in good shape," Smyth said.

"Definitely by the time we have our Christmas hams rolled out we'll have lots of Dijon for it."

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?

now