KPMG tax exec to testify at Commons committee about alleged offshore 'sham'
Greg Wiebe not named in Isle of Man offshore tax dodge, court documents show
Greg Wiebe, tax partner and former global head of tax for the accounting firm, isn't named in any of the court documents filed by the CRA alleging KPMG itself earned a 15 per cent cut in an offshore tax dodge that promised multimillionaire clients they would pay "no tax" on their investment income.
- Canada Revenue Agency's case against KPMG over offshore 'sham' delayed — again
- CRA offers amnesty to rich clients of KPMG's offshore 'sham'
- Internal KPMG memo outlined "product alerts" that explained the Isle of Man Offshore Company structure to employees
- Internal KPMG memo, part of court documents filed by CRA after obtaining KPMG's Isle of Man product alert
KPMG has been fighting a judge's order since early 2013 to hand over the names of the wealthy clients involved in the controversial $130-million offshore scheme that launched more than 15 years ago.
Wayne Easter, Liberal chairman of the finance committee, says members passed a motion to call on KPMG officials to explain their role in what the CRA has called a "sham."
"The pressure we're getting from the public is, 'Look, KPMG is the one named," Easter said. "That's why that decision was made."
But, Easter says, it was up to the firm to decide who would testify.
None of the KPMG officials named in the court documents will appear before the committee today, but Easter didn't rule out calling on additional tax executives from the firm closer to the file at a later date.
"I don't know the partner coming forward for KPMG, but we'll hear what they have to say," he said. "If need be, there will be more meetings called. This is the initial brush."
- Send confidential tips on this story to email@example.com, or contact Harvey Cashore at 416-526-4704.
Dennis Howlett, executive director of Canadians for Tax Fairness, says he would like to see KPMG executives directly involved in the Isle of Man scheme to address the committee and is concerned about a possible "whitewash" if that doesn't happen.
He says he isn't convinced Wiebe has enough knowledge about who all was involved and how the scheme was orchestrated within the firm.
"We're just hoping that the members of Parliament on the committee are sufficiently prepared to not let him use it as a PR opportunity for KPMG."
In a statement, KPMG noted Wiebe's longstanding service with the firm in senior positions and says it is "extremely confident that Greg is the best person to respond to the committee's enquiries."
The decision to launch hearings came in March after CBC News revealed the CRA offered a secret amnesty to wealthy KPMG clients involved in the firm's tax scheme based out of the Isle of Man, a small European island between Ireland and England.
The offer, leaked to CBC News in a brown envelope, allowed the wealthy clients to pay taxes on the income they previously had not declared, plus some modest interest, and promised no civil penalties and no criminal investigations. The agency's offer came with a strict condition that clients never talk about it in public.
"Right now, we need to get information," says Guy Caron, NDP finance critic and vice-chairman of the parliamentary group hosting Tuesday's meeting. "The finance committee is actually the perfect place to get that information."
Today's committee hearing comes more than a decade after a U.S. Senate subcommittee held its own hearings into accounting firms and tax-avoidance schemes.
In the U.S. probe in 2003, politicians issued subpoenas for specific KPMG executives involved in an alleged scheme, which included the use of offshore companies. The Senate committee also issued subpoenas for KPMG's documents.
Six KPMG officials would later testify, including the firm's partner in charge of the personal financial planning division and the vice-chair of tax services.
In 2005, the U.S. Internal Revenue Service (IRS) charged KPMG and several senior executives in the case, alleging they helped hide billions in taxable income. Three KPMG executives were later convicted. As part of a plea bargain, the firm itself admitted to "criminal wrongdoing" and agreed to pay $456 million in penalties.
The Canadian KPMG Isle of Man tax dodge hasn't been tested in court, and no one from the firm has publicly admitted to any wrongdoing.
Difference between IRS and CRA
Bay Street tax lawyer Jonathan Garbutt says there is a difference between how Canada and the U.S. investigate tax-avoidance cases.
"I always tell clients you don't mess around with the IRS," he told CBC News in an on-camera interview in February, noting their criminal investigations officers have firearms permits.
"IRS agents have badges and carry guns. CRA officials have calculators and carry pencils."
The Commons finance committee also plans to call justice department and CRA officials to testify in its KPMG hearings. Agency officials include CRA commissioner Andrew Treusch, assistant commissioner Ted Gallivan, and Stephanie Henderson, manager of offshore compliance.
Revenue Minister Diane Lebouthillier is scheduled to testify on May 19.