CP Rail headquarters might not be in Canada if merger with Norfolk Southern goes ahead

North America's largest railway may not be headquartered in Canada in the event of a merger between Canadian Pacific and Norfolk Southern, CP Rail chief executive Hunter Harrison said Thursday.
Canadian Pacific Railway CEO Hunter Harrison, pictured at the company's annual meeting in May, told an industry conference Thursday that details such as where CP would have its headquarters if it were to merge with U.S. rail company Norfolk Southern have not yet been worked out. (Larry MacDougal/Canadian Press/Associated Press)

North America's largest railway may not be headquartered in Canada in the event of a merger between Canadian Pacific and Norfolk Southern, CP Rail chief executive Hunter Harrison said Thursday.

The veteran American railroader told an industry conference webcast from Florida that details such as the headquarters location, distribution of board seats and which jobs are protected would have to be worked out during negotiations.

"To get there we have to talk," he told the UBS Industrials and Transportation Conference.

Harrison and his Norfolk counterpart got together for just one meeting lasting over two hours last week to discuss the Calgary-based railway's offer. The bid, valued at about $28 billion US, was detailed publicly Wednesday.

CP has presented a 50-50 stock-and-cash offer that would give U.S.-based Norfolk Southern shareholders $46.72 in cash and 0.348 of a share in the new merged company for each share they hold.

That would see Norfolk Southern shareholders own a 41 per cent stake in the combined company, which would be listed on both the New York and Toronto Stock Exchanges.

Norfolk Southern gave a cool initial response to the takeover proposal, describing it as an "unsolicited, low-premium, non-binding, highly conditional indication of interest."

CBC News contacted CP VP Marty Cej who said the company has "absolutely no plans at this time" to move CP's head office out of Calgary.

Not final offer

Analysts have described CP Rail's offer as a "starting point."

Harrison said he believes all the potential concerns of Norfolk, including price, can be resolved.

"If you can sit down and have a dialogue, we think that we can maybe solve most or all of those issues that they seem to be concerned about," he said.

Harrison said it was hard to set a price for an offer when Norfolk didn't indicate what it would consider acceptable.

"Is that our final offer, line in the sand? No. And I tried to indicate that to them," he said.

Harrison said he's not aware of any non-financial issues that could be an impediment to getting a friendly deal done and believes regulatory and shipper concerns can be addressed within the two-year timeline it has set.

CP has taken a proactive approach to addressing potential concerns by proposing to give shippers the option to connect with another railway at terminals and gateways if the merged company fails to provide adequate service or competitive rates.

CP has also said the merger would alleviate congestion in Chicago by using underutilized hubs that would free up capacity for other railways operating through the city without the need for more infrastructure.

While he would prefer not to launch a hostile battle, Harrison said he wants to take the proposal to shareholders to explain how it can deliver value. Harrison said CP Rail has experience driving efficiency and believes Norfolk's operating ratio can be cut about 10 percentage points to around CP's 60 per cent level.

Much of the $1.8 billion cost savings can be realized by running longer trains and reducing the number of locomotives, car fleet, rail yards and staffing, he added.

Harrison says the merger could involve various structures, including voting trusts and a holding company headed by Harrison, with CP chief operating officer Keith Creel and Norfolk Southern CEO Jim Squires running either of the railways.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.