Women make meagre gains climbing corporate ladder while racial and ethnic minorities still lag
Number of companies with one female board member has risen from barely 1 in 5 to almost 1 in 3
In America's corporate boardrooms, diversity is making uneven progress: Women increasingly are pulling up a chair while racial and ethnic minorities still rarely get seats at the table.
Twenty-seven per cent of new directors at companies in the Russell 3000 Index were women during 2016-2018, up from 21 per cent in the previous three-year period, according to estimates by ISS Analytics in an analysis for Reuters News. In 2018 alone, the figure was 32 per cent.
Though women still are underrepresented, their gains have been more substantial than those of African-Americans and Latinos. These groups comprised only 5 per cent and 2 per cent, respectively, of new directors in 2016-2018, little changed from the previous three-year period.
White men have long dominated U.S. corporate boards, for reasons including bias and insular networks that don't necessarily invite in female or minority candidates. Some executives say it's hard to find qualified candidates of diverse backgrounds and difficult at times even to discern candidates' race or ethnicity.
Now, directors and experts say, women are gaining seats partly in response to pressure from influential investment firms and lawmakers.
It is partly convenience. Women are easier to count and make up a larger pool to draw from.
Advocates say greater gender diversity also can bring better financial performance, improve public image and is the right thing to do given that women are more than half the country's population.
"All the big holders of securities are focused on gender," said Joe Johnson, a Boston-based partner at the Goodwin law firm who advises corporate boards "They'll move to minorities next," he said.
Dominique Mielle, a white woman who was named a director of REIT Anworth Mortgage Asset Corp in November, said forces like the #MeToo movement have encouraged boards to add women first lest top investors withhold support in corporate elections.
"If they will say no to your slate of directors, that's a problem" Mielle said.
A new California law requires that, by the end of 2021, at least three women sit on the boards of state-based publicly traded companies with six or more directors. At least four other states have passed or are considering similar measures on gender, but not race, according to the National Conference of State Legislatures.
California Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, a Santa Barbara County Democrat who authored the law, said it was aimed at breaking into "the man cave of the CEO suite."
Lack of women a red flag
Other countries are more explicit in their demands for diversity, at least when it comes to gender. In Europe several countries have quotas, including France which requires 40 per cent of board members at its largest listed companies to be women, while Germany has a 30 per cent requirement. Britain has a government-backed target for women to make up a third of its 350 largest listed companies' boards by the end of 2020.
In the U.S., those who favor diverse boards say they help companies respond more appropriately to causes like Black Lives Matter, or immigration reform.
Diversity has also become something of a sales pitch for big asset managers like BlackRock Inc. and State Street Corp., the largest and third-largest U.S. asset managers.
State Street, for instance, placed the "Fearless Girl" statue near Wall Street in 2017 to promote gender diversity and an exchange-traded fund made up of companies with female leaders. Meanwhile BlackRock's proxy voting guidelines urge companies to have at least two women directors. They do not give a target figure for minority representation.
Neither firm made executives available for an interview. A BlackRock spokeswoman said via e-mail, "We encourage companies to think about multiple elements of diversity and we use a lack of women as a flag to trigger a deeper conversation about how a company thinks about diversity."
Some research shows that gender diversity correlates with better financial results, perhaps because those companies are more likely to have engaged employees and lower turnover. But other studies suggest that companies with more women directors perform no better or worse.
In a survey of 714 corporate directors, four-fifths of whom were men, consultant PwC in October found 84 per cent said diversity enhances board performance. But 52 per cent agreed, at least somewhat, that "board diversity efforts are driven by political correctness."
Some companies now provide diversity information in their proxy statements, with varying degrees of specificity.
Last year consumer finance provider Regional Management Corp. included a matrix showing which four of its eight directors were "White/Caucasian" and which four were "Hispanic/Latino."
Regional director Roel Campos said investors probably want these additional details, as many of Regional's customers are Latino.
"We believe that by putting them out there investors are better informed and can judge for themselves whether our diversity is the type that helps deliver positive performance," said Campos, a former securities regulator who is also the incoming chair of the Latino Corporate Directors Association in Washington, D.C.
As it stands, minorities are scarce on corporate boards relative to their populations: African Americans account for 13 per cent of the U.S. population, and those who are "Hispanic or Latino" account for 18 per cent, according to recent U.S. Census Bureau estimates.
The numbers analyzed by ISS Analytics focused on the roughly 2,000 new board members added to Russell 3000 companies each year. The firm estimates that among the roughly 21,000 current directors, about 18 per cent are women and 10 per cent are minorities, including 3.2 per cent who are black and 1.7 per cent who are Latino.
In the past, some companies have argued that it is hard to find qualified women and minorities for their boards.
Luis Aguilar, another former securities regulator who sits on several corporate boards, was skeptical.
"I no longer give much credibility to people saying they can't find who they're looking for, because I can quickly find who they're looking for" through trade groups and other organizations, Aguilar said.
Deb DeHaas, vice-chairman of the Deloitte consulting firm, said its data shows minority directors tend to serve on more boards than non-minorities, suggesting companies keep going back to the same people.
"You need to widen the aperture of where you're looking," she said.
Chicago-based bank Northern Trust Corp. counts three African-Americans and one Latino among its 14-member board.
The board keeps a list of potential candidates and discuss it at every meeting, whether or not the board has a vacancy,.
"When it does come time to add a new director...it's not starting with a blank sheet of paper," CEO Michael O'Grady said.