Why the Bank of Canada won't fight a recession till there is one: Don Pittis

With Canada's real economy going strong there's reason to think cutting rates in fear of recession would only make its effects worse once asset prices start to fall.

With the economy riding high, Poloz is unlikely to be pressured into early cuts

Toronto Raptors fans climb on a parked vehicle on June 17 to get a view of the the team's parade through downtown Toronto to celebrate their NBA title. Some credit the championship for boosting the Canadian economy, but there are signs that ordinary Canadians really are better off than their U.S. counterparts. (Dan Hamilton/USA Today Sports)

Inevitably, Bank of Canada governor Stephen Poloz must do his job in the shadow of his powerful U.S. equivalent at the Federal Reserve.

But as Canada's central banker reveals his rate decision on Wednesday, he will have an edge on Fed chair Jerome Powell. The Poloz advantage is that Prime Minister Justin Trudeau won't be hollering at him to cut interest rates or insulting him when he doesn't.

With so much fearful talk of a coming recession, U.S. President Donald Trump is not the only one who has called for rate cuts to boost the economy.

But as the fundamental strength of Canadian growth, employment, income and housing seems an oasis in a world beset by recessionary fears, Poloz and his advisers will do what good central bankers like best: follow the data.

Whatever may be around the corner, it is hard to dispute that right now the fundamentals of the Canadian economy are strong. Annualized gross domestic product numbers on Friday hit nearly four per cent, well above forecasts, although the year-over-year gain is less than half that. 

Jobs, wages and inflation remain strong. Housing is no longer soaring, which is good, but it is no longer plunging either. Canadian shoppers are still shopping.

Seeking hints 

It is almost certain that the Bank of Canada will leave rates unchanged tomorrow at 1.75 per cent.

This is not one of the times when Poloz and his deputy Carolyn Wilkins explain their thinking to the business media. Nonetheless, market watchers will be going over their written statement with a fine-tooth comb for hints of whether there will be rate cuts before the end of the year.

poll of 40 economists by Reuters now shows a majority foresee no rate cuts in 2019. But it's a split decision. Just over 40 per cent say not only will there be a cut, but some suggest it will be half a percentage point, double the usual quarter-point decrement.

"With the Fed likely easing in September and then again in October, it looks as if it would be the prudent thing to do for the Bank of Canada to take up some insurance as well," BMO's Benjamin Reitzes told the news agency.

Bank of Canada governor Stephen Poloz, second from left, walks with other bank governors and Japan's finance minister at a G7 meeting in France on July 17. Poloz is not facing pressure to cut rates. (Pascal Rossignol/Reuters)

U.S. easing is not yet certain. Warnings of price increases by retailers due to the China-U.S. trade war may push inflation higher. A partial resolution of the trade fight may make two cuts unnecessary.

Poloz may indeed find himself pressured by U.S. and other countries' rate cuts if he believes there will be an impact on Canada. But the idea that central banks can do much to compensate for an economy smacked by the growing costs of trade disputes, especially by cutting interest rates in advance, was a subject of debate at the recent central bankers' conference at Jackson Hole, Wyo.

With rates already so low, it is not clear even a half-point cut would convince business borrowers to take out additional loans to expand their businesses just when they have been warned a recession is about to strike. 

And rather than boosting business fundamentals, rate cuts when an economy is running hot would mostly jack up asset prices like real estate and stocks, which might please speculators, but would only make a bigger noise should a recession bring those asset prices crashing down.

The wrong message

Another documented effect is that when people see them battening down the hatches for a coming storm, central bankers are viewed as having privileged information about the economy and its future, and research shows businesses and consumers tend to take it as a signal to cut spending, slowing the economy.

While there will be plenty of criticism and suggestions for improvement during the upcoming election campaign, there are signs that Canada is benefiting from years of relatively good government by Trudeau and Stephen Harper before him.

Immigration and high levels of education have given Canada a healthy workforce. Recent data shows that while Canada's rich are not as rich as their U.S. counterparts, those earning median salaries and below are significantly better off.

"Our income estimates may actually underestimate the economic well-being of Canadians relative to Americans," writes Bloomberg's Justin Fox. "Indeed, Canadians usually receive more in-kind benefits from their governments, including notably in health care."

Canadian Mark Carney, governor of the Bank of England, left, and U.S. Federal Reserve chair Jerome Powell attend a monetary policy conference in Jackson Hole, Wyo., last month where they debated how much power banks had to fix economies battered by trade battles. (Jonathan Crosby/Reuters)
As previously reported, research from C.D. Howe's Farah Omran shows that stronger incomes at the lower end of the wage spectrum result in more spending, recirculating money in the active economy rather than transferring it into inactive savings.

Of course, that economic advantage Fox reports only comes after you look at Canadian purchasing power parity. Canadian dollars buy more goods and services here at home, but as we discovered during a summer visit to Alaska, they don't go so far in the U.S.

Last week The Atlantic reported that a coming recession was going to doom U.S. young people weighed down by student debt and poor job prospects. But as Bloomberg's Fox observed, the mood really is different in Canada.

While Canadian youth also face the burden of high rents and entry-level wages, subsidized education means levels of student debt are not as extreme. And with boomers departing the workforce in droves, young Canadians know there are hundreds of thousands of good jobs going begging if only they can get the right credentials.

Follow Don on Twitter @don_pittis


Don Pittis

Business columnist

Based in Toronto, Don Pittis is a business columnist and senior producer for CBC News. Previously, he was a forest firefighter, and a ranger in Canada's High Arctic islands. After moving into journalism, he was principal business reporter for Radio Television Hong Kong before the handover to China. He has produced and reported for the CBC in Saskatchewan and Toronto and the BBC in London.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?