Critics ask why rules to protect air passengers are still waiting in the wings

Transport Canada has unveiled a draft of new rules to protect air passengers. Critics question why, after two years in the making, those rules have yet to take effect.

Transport Canada says it must follow due process before implementing new bill of rights for passengers

Proposed regulations to protect the rights of air passengers aren't expected to take effect until the summer of 2019. (Sang Tan/Associated Press)

Transport Canada's air passenger bill of rights has been more than two years in the making, and some critics say they expected the government would have more to show for it by now. 

On Monday, Transport Minister Marc Garneau unveiled proposed regulations designed to protect air travellers, including minimum compensation requirements for flight delays and lost luggage.

It's only a first draft, and will undergo another round of consultations. Garneau expects the proposed rules to become law in the summer of 2019.

Brian Masse, NDP MP for Windsor West, claims the long wait gives airlines another free pass during the high-peak holiday season. 

He campaigned for air passenger rights for more than a decade, and said Transport Canada should have some concrete rules protecting passengers at this point. 

"It's nothing short of irresponsible and lazy."

Mario Stojanac, Mary Luz Mejia and their 6-year-old daughter, Nathalie returned home from their Sunwing vacation to discover their luggage was lost. (Mary Luz Mejia)

Air passenger Mary Luz Mejia also wonders why federal laws have been taking taking so long to materialize. In April, she spent more than two weeks chasing down lost luggage following a Sunwing flight.

She said she then spent more than a month complaining to the airline before she got compensation for having to replace clothing and toiletries that were in her missing baggage.

She said she's had enough of poor treatment by airlines and believes it's time for the government to put tough rules in place. 

"For those of us who have been inconvenienced — more than once I might add in my case — this is something that does matter to a lot of us," said Mejia who lives in Toronto.

"We just want to see legislation put in place so that we have recourse."

It's coming

Transport Canada said it's simply following due process with the regulations which it wants to ensure are fair to everyone.

"We want to get it right," said Marc Roy, chief of staff for Transport Canada.

The proposed rules include treatment standards requiring airlines to supply food, drink and accommodation for passengers when their flights are delayed.

They also lay out compensation which could go as high as $2,400 if a passenger is involuntarily bumped from an overbooked flight.

Federal Transport Minister Marc Garneau outlined the new draft regulations for passenger rights Monday at the Ottawa airport. (CBC)

The proposed regulations will now undergo public consultation until Feb. 20, 2019.

It will be the third round of consultations held concerning air passenger rights. The first one began back in April 2016 when Garneau travelled across the country and heard a barrage of complaints ranging from cramped cabins to overbooked flights.

By November 2016, the transport minister pledged to pursue legislation that would lay out clear standards for air travellers.

Go with the basics

The NDP's Masse said the government by now could have at least implemented some basic regulations such as minimum compensation for flight delays and lost baggage.

"There is nothing stopping the minister from enacting what he wants to do right now with cabinet."

NDP MP Brian Masse says there should be some basic regulations in place by now protecting air passengers. (File Photo)

The draft regulations also propose a requirement that airlines don't charge extra to let children under age 14 sit next to a parent.

Masse said that's a no-brainer that should be law by now.

"How much more consultation do we need to understand that when you book a ticket and you're flying with your child, you should be able to sit next your child?"

He also questions if the regulations will even come into effect in the summer considering Garneau originally said the new rules will be implemented in 2018.

"[Monday] was just another delay," he said.

Following the rules

Transport Canada's Roy said implementing new regulations is a complex process that takes time and patience.

"We could not have made this faster. It's a prescribed process."

He also said the regulations didn't come into effect in 2018 because numerous people wanted to weigh in on what should be in them.

"So many people put in submissions, stakeholders and individual Canadians, that it took a certain amount of time to get to the first draft."

According to the Canadian Transportation Agency (CTA), which conducted the second round of consultations, Canadians submitted more than 5,000 comments online and 930 randomly-selected air passengers filled out surveys in 11 different Canadians airports.

"The CTA went to airports with a clipboard and interviewed people and said, 'Hey, what do you think should be addressed in a passenger bill of rights?'" said Roy.

He said there shouldn't be any more delays in implementing the regulations because clear skies lie ahead.

"The unforeseens have been dealt with."

But Masse questions if all the "unforeseens" have indeed been dealt with, considering the airlines have yet to weigh in on the proposed regulations as part of the latest consultation process.

About the Author

Sophia Harris

Business reporter

Sophia Harris has worked as a CBC video journalist across the country, covering everything from the start of the annual lobster fishery in Yarmouth, N.S., to farming in Saskatchewan. She now has found a good home at the business unit in Toronto. Contact:


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.