Music Review: Neil Young - A Treasure


treasure-cover[1].jpgThe latest offering in the Neil Young Performance Series comes from 1984-85, the time of the International Harvesters, or Neil's Country Period. It was the first show of his I ever saw, in Fredericton's Aitken Centre, with The Judds as opening act. I remember it being a lot more rock than I would have expected from the country album he put out, Old Ways, and that's exactly what this live set shows. Despite the presence of a fiddle, banjo and pedal steel, Young really couldn't keep himself from straying into his other loves. The disc includes 12 cuts, five of them never released officially in any form before, including a couple of legendary unreleased favourites, Grey Riders and Amber Jean. As with the live shows at the time, this set proves the country period was a lot better in the concert hall than it was on the overly-cliched Old Ways disc. It was one of the discs record company Geffen originally refused to release, and ended up with a different track list and a lawsuit from the label against Young, for willfully making uncommercial music.


It sure seemed commercial that night at the Aitken Centre, and on TV shows such as Austin City Limits and Nashville Now. Crowds were generally pleased with the show, especially when it started with Harvest classic Are You Ready For The Country?, included here. My memory tells me there were other well-known tracks played that night, including Heart Of Gold, Needle & the Damage Done, and Helpless, but this disc concentrates on the surprises, quite rightly. For my ears, the best one is Flying On The Ground Is Wrong, the old Buffalo Springfield song, and in fact, the number that so impressed Stephen Stills that he wanted to play with Young. Neil seemed to take delight in finding obscurities which could make the country transition, including Reactor's Southern Pacific and Motor City. Plus, a few shows in, he was writing new songs and itching to play them, as opposed to the old Old Ways numbers, and that pulled him even further from the country trail. The unreleased Soul Of A Woman is a raunchy blues, and nothing but, despite Rufus Thibodeaux's attempts to fiddle with it.


It's a pity in some ways that we don't get a full Old Ways-era concert, but as usual, the reasons are complex and we're at the whim of Young. He states in technical notes you can find on the web that it's all about the audio here, and he found these excellent performances buried away, a cache of tapes pedal steel pal the late Ben Keith called "A Treasure". So audio is the top criteria for Young, and as usual he's leaning us towards blu-ray. For visual content, his archives bunch found some footage online, and synched up a few cuts to the live tapes, but they are not the same performances. In fact, Young points out the video they have even has the wrong bass player, from earlier shows. When they don't have any footage, they used the album cover on the blu-ray. But ya, it does sound great. And bless them for using the Nashville Now version of Amber Jean, which remains a great song and performance. You audiophiles can also bask in the sound of the 180-gram vinyl pressing, over two albums. Even if great sound isn't your bag, this is a very satisfying archive release from Young, from one of his most unheralded periods.

more »

Latest East Coast Music Reviews

Tomato/Tomato top the awards nominations for Music NB
Tomato/Tomato top the awards nominations for Music NB
Sep 21, 1:15 PM

Saint John folk duo Tomato/Tomato lead the way in this year's nominations for Music New Brunswick awards. The husband-and-wife team has grabbed six nominations, including those for Album of the Year, Group Recording of the Year and Song of the... more »

 Hot Toddy reunion a Harvest highlight
Hot Toddy reunion a Harvest highlight
Sep 20, 6:05 PM

On stage at Fredericton's Playhouse on Saturday, the members of Hot Toddy had more to share than just music. Bass player Tom Easley had brought along a band tour journal that had been kept in the van from 2001-2003, full... more »

Samantha Martin brings exciting blues-gospel vocals to Harvest Fest
Samantha Martin brings exciting blues-gospel vocals to Harvest Fest
Sep 18, 3:58 PM

The Harvest Jazz and Blues Festival is well-known for introducing new, exciting acts to the East Coast that wouldn't normally tour in this area.  They might be from Los Angeles or New Orleans, or some of the best Canadian groups... more »

Steve Hill brings Juno-winning, one-man band to Harvest
Steve Hill brings Juno-winning, one-man band to Harvest
Sep 17, 3:58 PM

As the Harvest Jazz and Blues Festival celebrates its 25th year, several favourite acts from the past have been invited back, including some that haven't been around for quite awhile. Even though he lives in Montreal, this year's Juno Award-winning... more »

EARTHBOUND TRIO launches new album at Harvest gig
EARTHBOUND TRIO launches new album at Harvest gig
Sep 16, 3:51 PM

How busy is Fredericton during Harvest Jazz and Blues Festival week? It's delaying some Federal government work, that's how busy. A friend of mine, a government employee from another city, e-mailed me a couple of weeks ago to say she... more »

Amy Helm continuing Dad Levon's legacy at Harvest fest
Amy Helm continuing Dad Levon's legacy at Harvest fest
Sep 15, 3:06 PM

It was a Harvest show that went down as a classic for the people crowding in the Blues tent in 2011. Levon Helm and his great big 13-piece band rolled into Fredericton for the jazz and blues festival, and stole... more »

View all reviews for September 2015 »

About Bob Mersereau

Rockin' BobBob Mersereau has been covering music, and the East Coast Music Scene since 1985 for CBC. He's a veteran scene-maker at the ECMA's, knows where the best shows and right parties are happening, and more importantly, has survived to tell the tales. His weekly East Coast music column is heard on Shift on Radio 1 in New Brunswick each Wednesday at 4'45. He's also the author of two national best-selling books, The Top 100 Canadian Albums (2007) and The Top 100 Canadian Singles (2010).

Share this review