Google Classroom’s ratings have dropped and kids might be behind it

CBC Kids News • Published 2020-04-08 07:00

There are smarter ways to voice concerns, expert says

There appears to be an unofficial campaign underway to get Google Classroom shut down.

The free service, run by the super-sized American internet company, allows teachers and students to connect virtually.

Lots of schools around the world, including some here in Canada, have started using the app as a teaching tool while schools remain shut down in an effort to stop the coronavirus from spreading.

It seems some kids are hoping that by giving Google Classroom bad reviews, the app will get deleted from Apple's App Store and homework will magically disappear.

Tweet from carahenderson7 says apparently if an app gets enough bad reviews the App Store takes it down. Everyone give Google Classroom bad reviews.

How likely is that to happen?

“It takes more than bad reviews for something to be removed from the App Store,” said Ramona Pringle, an associate professor at Ryerson University’s RTA School of Media in Toronto.

CBC Kids News reached out to Apple to confirm exactly what the criteria are for an app getting deleted from the App Store, but didn’t get a response.

‘Creative and clever’

Still, Pringle gives kids props for trying.

“They’re protesting in a way that they know how,” she said. “It is creative and clever, and an attempt to work collaboratively to take control of a situation that feels entirely out of their control.”

Where did the protest start?

It’s difficult to pinpoint exactly where the idea came from, said Matthew Johnson, the director of education at a media literacy organization called Media Smarts, based in Ottawa.

It may have roots in China, he said, where students tried a similar campaign earlier this year to get a learning app called DingTalk shut down.

Some kids in North America even lent their support to the cause.

Tweet from Alex Aguiar says downloading Ding talk and gave them a bad review so kids in Wuhan don't have to do homework. If that's not good karma, idk what is.

Current ratings

As of April 7, Google Classroom’s average rating on the App Store was 2.8 stars out of five.

The majority of the more than 300,000 ratings on the page were one-star reviews.

Google Classroom Ratings listed at 2.8 out of 5. 311.1K Ratings. Most are one star.

(Google Classroom/Apps.apple.com)

Negativity spreading

The negative reviews are spreading outside of the Apple universe.

According to AppBrain, a European company that tracks the success of Android apps, the average rating for Google Classroom was around 4.2 stars out of five on Feb. 19.

One day later, the average rating had dropped to only one star.

It has since bumped back up to 3.88 stars out of five, said Mathijs Vogelzang, a co-founder and manager at AppBrain.

Vogelzang said it’s hard to explain the sudden influx of bad reviews, although he did point out that the word “school” is one of the most common words found in reviews with low star ratings.

Word cloud shows a number of words including app bad school work worst.

A word cloud on the AppBrain site shows the most commonly-used words in Google Classroom's one-star reviews, including: worst, ever, school, work and bad. (Google Classroom/Appbrain.com)

What do the reviews say?

A quick read through some of the bad reviews suggests that some people are jumping on the protest bandwagon.

One star review from A Student says I say that we should all vote 1 star to shut down the app like the kids in China.

(Google Classroom/Apps.apple.com)

Others seem genuinely frustrated with the app.

One star review called Worst app ever says My email is filled with useless notifications and worst of all all of my work deletes.

(Google Classroom/Apps.apple.com)

And then there are those who wish that everybody would just stop complaining and get their work done.

Five star review titled students need to grow up says the fact that some students are trying to get this app banned by rating it one star just cause they are lazy and don't want to do work is very childish.

(Google Classroom/Apps.apple.com)

Whether or not Google Classroom gets shut down remains to be seen.

But in the meantime, reading the app reviews seems to have given some distracted students yet another reason to procrastinate.

Tweet from Mithunn S says My new favourite quarantine hobby is reading the App Store reviews for google classroom.

Concerns are legit, experts say

Both Pringle and Johnson said there are reasons to be concerned about a transition to virtual schooling.

For example, Johnson said, young Canadians are concerned about their privacy online and those concerns are growing.

Pringle said that while it’s important for students to have their voices heard, a review page for an app like Google Classroom “is a bit of a black hole.”

It would be better for kids to reach out directly to the decision-makers, she said, including teachers and local politicians.

Get your class on the same page, add this to
Google Classroom

Do you like this story?