Baking Show hosts Ann Pornel and Alan Shane Lewis treat us to a double helping of positivity
For an hour each week, the pair gives us an exceptionally warm escape from the real world
It’s hard to compete with a classic. For 13 seasons, The Great British Baking Show has held us tightly in its doughy embrace and showed us that true comfort is watching a group of enthusiasts bake their hearts out. And when its Canadian counterpart debuted in 2017, it proved that the only thing better than one Baking series is two.
As CBC’s gentle answer to what it would look like if the kindest, most earnest contestants this side of the Atlantic tried their hardest to bake their best (while making lifelong friends in the process), The Great Canadian Baking Show has morphed into the TV equivalent of a bed of clouds. The series’ sixth season created an exceptionally warm, inclusive space to escape from the real world for an hour each week — thanks, in large part, to its hosts, Ann Pornel and Alan Shane Lewis.
Writers, actors, comedians and alumni of Toronto’s Second City, the pair have hosted Baking Show since the fourth season. Their friendship creates a sense of camaraderie not just between the bakers, but between the judges and those of us watching at home. Plus, they’re just completely delightful and I could watch them forever.
Last November, Pornel wrote about the joy she felt after being styled by Vanessa Magic for her role as Baking Show host. “As a fat, Filipino woman, I know how rare it is to see someone who looks like me on television,” she said. “Fat women are often the mothers, the caretakers, or the comedic relief as the skinny heroine’s best friend. We rarely get to be seen as the object of desire; the pretty one. For the first time ever in my life, in the tent, I get to be one of the pretty ones. I’m eye candy.”
But she’s also far more. In her first episode, she compassionately comforts a contestant we see melting down over a stovetop mishap. She banters with contestants like they’re in on every joke with her, ensuring there’s no moment where they’re not on the same level. And her Instagram is like a fashion show, with wardrobe choices that not only showcase her own incredible taste but also spotlight labels like the Toronto-based “modern Filipiniana” brand VINTA Gallery. Her approach to authenticity and kindness is infectious. (I just want to go to the mall with her.)
Alan Shane Lewis follows suit. While he’s long been a beloved stand-up presence in Toronto, his most recent written work saw him get vulnerable when he spoke about his experiences as a Black man with alopecia — an autoimmune disorder shared by this season’s contestant Chi — and the journey he took to embrace his authentic self.
“This is extremely important to me,” he writes. “Representation. Not just diversity for diversity’s sake, but full-on inclusion. Not just Black pain, but Black joys. Small and large.”
Alan’s essay mirrors the approachability he demonstrates on our TVs every week. There’s no TED Talk rhetoric, no sense of “I have it all figured out now” superiority. Like Ann, Alan leads with sincerity. You get the sense that who these two are on Baking Show is who they are in real life. And in real life, they’re navigating the waters of being people who share their own stories to remind anyone watching that nobody’s alone.
Which is what I hope to see more of in 2023, especially since every day of this year has felt like an exercise in various forms of defeat. That, and another season of The Great Canadian Baking Show, helmed by Ann and Alan. They’ve taught me that we deserve a slice of positivity, powered by the rapport of two funny people I’d like to make my best friends — preferably while we all eat as many baked goods as we can.