CBC Digital Archives CBC butterfly logo

CBC Archives has a new look: Please go to cbc.ca/archives to access the new site.

The page you are looking at will not be updated.

Debate on prisoners’ right to vote

The Story


Gary Rosenfeldt doesn't think prisoners should have the right to vote. As executive director of Victims of Violence and the father of a teenager murdered by serial killer Clifford Olsen, Rosenfeldt feels strongly about this issue. On the other side of the debate, Winnipeg lawyer Jeff Gindin points out that "The Charter of Rights is not an elitist document; it's supposed to be for everyone." This 1995 CBC Television debate from Winnipeg looks at a topic that's been highly contentious since the 1980s. 

Medium: Television
Program: 24 Hours
Broadcast Date: May 25, 1995
Guest(s): Jeff Gindin, Gary Rosenfeldt
Host: Diana Swain
Duration: 5:28

Did You know?


• Prisoners in Canada had previously been barred from voting since 1898.
• At the time this clip (1995), the Canada Elections Act had prohibited "every person undergoing punishment as an inmate in any penal institution for the commission of any offence" from voting in federal elections.

• After the Charter of Rights and Freedoms was passed in 1982, prisoner Rick Sauvé launched what was to become a well publicized 18-year-long fight for prisoners' voting rights in Canada.

• The main argument for prisoner voting rights was that prisoners are citizens, and every citizen is guaranteed the right to vote, so prisoners should therefore be able to vote. Many advocates also pointed out that the majority of prisoners aren't serial killers in prison for life; most will be back in mainstream society at some point. So, getting them involved in the voting process will help them feel they have a say in the society they will eventually be a part of again.

• Those opposed to prisoner voting rights feel that people who commit crimes have forfeited their right to vote. As one victim's rights' group member said in a 1988 CBC Television report, "Murderers should get the right to vote as soon as their victims do." Calgary professor F.L. Morton has been very outspoken on the issue. In a 2002 National Post article, he said giving prisoners the right to vote was "both an absurdity and an insult…it is an insult to law-abiding citizens."


More

Categories:

Voting in Canada: How a Privilege Became a Right more