Bill Cosby denied new trial; comedian's wife accuses judge of bias

Camille Cosby accuses judge of bias, citing wife's advocacy for sex assault victims

Posted: October 23, 2018
Last Updated: October 24, 2018

After a judge rejected Bill Cosby's bid for a new trial, Cosby's lawyers have filed an appeal with Philadelphia's Superior Court. (Matt Slocum/Associated Press)

A judge on Tuesday rejected Bill Cosby's bid for a new trial or sentencing hearing, leading the comedian's wife, Camille, to again accuse the judge of bias against her husband.

The ruling by the same judge that presided over Cosby's trial also led the entertainer's lawyers to file their appeal with the state Superior Court, the next step in trying to reverse his felony sex assault conviction.

Cosby is serving a three- to 10-year state prison term after a jury this year found he drugged and molested a woman in 2004. The defence wants the legally blind, 81-year-old actor released on bail while he appeals over alleged trial errors.


Cosby, in the meantime, is living in a single cell near the infirmary at the State Correctional Institution-Phoenix in suburban Philadelphia and has access to a day room, where he can watch television or eat meals, a state prisons spokeswoman said.

For now, he is the only person using that day room, spokeswoman Amy Worden said. Several inmates are assigned to help him as part of their prison jobs, she said. He has also had several visitors.

Bill Cosby and his wife Camille Cosby earlier this year arriving at a Pennsylvania courthouse for his sexual assault trial. (Matt Slocum/Associated Press)

Camille Cosby continued to issue searing attacks against Montgomery County Judge Steven O'Neill, as she has done since the first trial ended in a jury deadlock in June 2017.

In the latest missive Tuesday, she again said he should have stepped down from the case because his wife has advocated for sex assault victims. O'Neill has heard the argument before and said his wife's work has no bearing on his legal rulings.


The defence also renewed attacks on the judge over what they call his feud with a key pretrial witness, former county district attorney Bruce Castor.

Castor had declined to arrest Cosby when the accuser first came forward in 2005 and said he'd promised Cosby he would never be charged. When a successor did charge the actor, O'Neill ruled that any verbal promise Castor made wasn't legally binding.

In an affidavit attached to Tuesday's appeal, Castor said he believed O'Neill's ruling was influenced by a long-ago feud between them.

"Mr. Cosby had a right to have his petition reviewed and decided by a judge who could make a decision free of bias, or even the perception of bias, where the ability to prosecute hinged on the testimony of the 2005 district attorney," his new lawyers, the latest of about 20 to work the criminal case, wrote in the appeal.

The defence also challenged O'Neill's decisions to: