Watch on CBC Television


Sunday - Friday 10/10:30 p.m. NT
Saturday 6 p.m. ET*
(* except in Ontario-Eastwhere viewers will see their local CBC News)

Watch on CBC News Network


Monday - Friday 9 p.m., 10 p.m. & 11 p.m. ET/PT
Saturday & Sunday 9 p.m. ET/PT
During NHL playoffs, The National can also be seen Monday-Friday at 10 p.m. ET/PT

Watch The Latest National Online »

Recorded broadcasts are posted at the following times

Sunday - Friday Full broadcast 10 p.m. ET
Saturday Full broadcast 6 p.m. ET

View live broadcasts in the CBC video player at the following times

Sunday - Friday Live stream 9 - 10 p.m. ET
Saturday Live stream 5 -6 p.m. ET

Rex Murphy

Facing the Fallout from Security Hysteria

Last Updated: Friday, January 8, 2010 | 12:11 PM ET

Bookmark and Share
 

Read the transcript from this Point of View

January 7, 2010

On Christmas day some demented al Qaeda type stuffed his underwear with explosives- (there's a desperate Happy Dance) - and then tried, essentially, to set fire to, to detonate, his own privates. With smoke- there's no way to be delicate about this - rising from the bomber's crotch, a brave Dutch filmmaker intervened, leaped across a few seats and proceeded to --- "put out" his smoldering nethers.

He, the nit in question, is now immortalized in Google as the "underwear" bomber - al Qaeda's very own Wile E Coyote in skivvies. Yes it's absurd But it's also, as the world already knows, a billboard illustration of just how useless the great umbrella of airport security, in some of the cases that count, really is.

This guy had been 'ratted' out by his father to the CIA and the American embassy; started out in Yemen, the latest al Qaeda badland; was on a watch list; barred from Britain; bought a one-way ticket; paid in cash, and carried no luggage. In fact, he did everything except wrap his private parts in the Jolly Roger and put a stick of dynamite on his head to catch the attention of those who - we used to believe - are on guard - precisely - to keep his type off the world's airlines.

But if you - typical airline passenger - were getting on in Thunder Bay or Labrador City- neither let me note jihad central - and had four ounces of toothpaste in the wrong kind of Ziploc bag, most likely you'd be carted off for the full pat down, de-shod, un-belted, and given the cold frown reserved for toothpaste mules.

It touched off a blizzard of ever more ludicrous regulations... no visits to the washroom on the last hour of flights - essentially a rule against ..... bowel movements... not being able to read, type, iPod, cell phone or Gameboy. The back of the seat in front of you, always a mesmerizing panorama - the fascinating lint - would be all the entertainment or diversion permitted.

Up to now I thought the precautions since 9/11 had drained every possible comfort or pleasure out of flying. The ingenuity of those guarding us, however, is infinite when it comes to multiplying petty annoyances, fruitless edicts, and ever-changing standards in what is - at least partially - the show of protecting us. But, as the episode starring the jihadist ninja of the flaming crotch demonstrates - they are apparently blind to every obvious and egregious signal of a real villain.

The question is - will passengers put up with these new measures or their offspring? Or have we reached the last straw? Will people now stop flying for any reason except real emergency? Will this Christmas Day bomber, for all his idiocy, prove to be the one who pushed security just that "one inch more" that people are just going to stay off the planes?

Unless, and until the show of security becomes something more sturdy than about contraband toothpaste, and five hours staring at the back of someone else's seat bent over in panic over the urgency to get to a washroom, I fear it will be so.

View / Post Comments
 

Rex Murphy

From politics to pop culture, Rex Murphy brings a unique and always controversial perspective to the news. This season, he'll also be checking in on what Canadians are saying about the stories that matter to them.

Learn more about Rex Murphy »

Recent Rex Murphy

Mike Duffy and that $90,000 cheque video
Rex has a go at Senator Mike Duffy... and he's one angry guy.
Maple Leafs video
Rex Murphy muses on hockey and the Toronto Maple Leafs long, long road to playoffs success.
A Terrible Week in the U.S. video
Rex Murphy shares his thoughts on four days of heartache for our neighbours to the south.
Mulcair's Leadership video
It's not just the Liberals, the NDP are having a convention this weekend too. Rex shares his thoughts on Tom Mulcair's leadership.
Rex pays tribute to Ralph Klein video
Rex Murphy pays tribute to the former Alberta premier.
Download Flash Player to view this content.

Rex recommends:

Life, by Keith Richards
Whether you like him or you don't, he's one of the most interesting creatures on the face of the earth.
Nomad, by Ayaan Hirsi Ali
She is an outsider, and is trying to wake us up again to the moral foundations of western civilization.
Moby Dick, by Herman Melville
Moby Dick is my all-time favourite book and it has been since I began to read it.
Paradise Lost, by John Milton
As soon as I heard the first 42 lines in a first-year English class, I went to the library and got out the book.
aldaily.com
Arts & Letters Daily, A service of The Chronicle of Higher Education
Writer's choice 46: Andrew Bolt, in normblog, the weblog of Norman Geras
Andrew Bolt, columnist with Melbourne's Herald Sun, writes about the idea of a 'favourite' book.
The Ghosts of Katyn, by Michael Weiss, in The New Criterion
After the crash that devastated Poland's leadership, this article sheds light on the Katyn massacre.
British columnist Mathew Parris, in The Spectator
Parris has a very nice touch with an essay, and as this column shows, a sense of "the fine balance".
climateaudit.org by Steve McIntyre
One of the most honest sites on global warming and its statistical basis on the whole internet
"Flawed climate data" by Ross McKitrick in The Financial Post
"Only by playing with data can scientists come up with the infamous 'hockey stick' graph of global warming"
Taken By Storm: The Troubled Science, Policy and Politics of Global Warming
Ross McKitrick published this (now) prescient book a few years back with Christopher Essex
Bryan Appleyard on Leonard Cohen's "Hallelujah"
A great read of Cohen’s repeatedly-covered song and a fine piece of analytic literary criticism
A Conversation with Gore Vidal in The Atlantic
The sage, Vidal, provides a priceless analysis of the arrest of Roman Polanski
William Butler Yeats
Yeats may be the most 'relevant' of the high modern poets to our present moment
"Leap Into Light" by Robert Huddleston, from Boston Review September/October 2009
A review of books on Yeats, including Our Secret Discipline: Yeats and Lyric Form by Helen Vendler