Afghanistan: Was It Worth It?

Listen

This week on a special edition of The House, Evan Solomon looks at the impact and legacy of Canada's mission in Afghanistan. The final group of Canadian soldiers left the country this month. We ask if the past 12 years, the 158 Canadian lives lost, and the $12 billion spent were worth it.

Here are the full interviews we conducted for this special program.

Major-General Dean Milner was the last Canadian commander to serve in Afghanistan. He talks about the situation that Canadians left behind, where the security situation stands, and if it was all worth it.
Download Flash Player to view this content.



Former UK Chief of Defence Staff Sir David Richards was the commander of International Forces in southern Afghanistan when Canadian troops first took control of Kandahar in 2006 during what was a very difficult time. He talks about the difference Canadians made.
Download Flash Player to view this content.



David Macdonald served in Afghanistan. He was seriously injured. He talks about his experience, and what he's doing now to help his fellow soldiers.
Download Flash Player to view this content.



Sheila Fynes' son, Corporal Stuart Langridge, took his own life after returning from Afghanistan. Sheila and her husband Shaun Fynes discuss what it's like to have a child in a war zone, what the return from such an experience is like, and what the country should do to help its veterans.
Download Flash Player to view this content.



Maryam Sahar Naqibullah was an interpreter for Canadian Forces in her native Afghanistan. She's currently studying in Ottawa. Maryam talks about how things have changed in Afghanistan, and why she's optimistic about the future.
Download Flash Player to view this content.



Peter MacKay was Minister of National Defence from the summer of 2007 until last year. We ask him about whether the mission was worth it, and if he has any regrets about how it was handled.
Download Flash Player to view this content.



Chris Alexander is a former Canadian ambassador to Afghanistan. He's now the Citizenship and Immigration Minister. We discuss what comes next now that Canadian troops have left Afghanistan. And the challenges that Afghanistan's neighbour Pakistan presents.
Download Flash Player to view this content.



We have a special In House panel this week. David Mulroney is the former Deputy Minister responsible for the Afghanistan Task ForceMike Capstick is a retired Colonel, he commanded the first deployment of the Canadian Forces Strategic Advisory Team in Afghanistan and returns to Afghanistan frequently to work on various training and development projects. And Graeme Smith is an award-winning journalist and author, who covered the war extensively and who is still living in Kabul. We ask our panel what challenges are still ahead for Afghanistan, if the mission in Afghanistan can be considered 'mission accomplished' and what happens after the rest of the international forces leave. 
Download Flash Player to view this content.


 


Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Submission Policy

Note: The CBC does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. By submitting your comments, you acknowledge that CBC has the right to reproduce, broadcast and publicize those comments or any part thereof in any manner whatsoever. Please note that comments are moderated and published according to our submission guidelines.