Jesse Brown:15 years for violating MySpace’s Terms of Use?

By Jesse Brown, CBC technology columnist.

Millions of people pretend to be someone they’re not on the internet. On the scale of fraud, I’d say most people consider creating a fake online persona to be slightly less harmful than, say, sneaking in to a movie.

Then again, most fake online identities don’t result in suicide.

Missouri mom Lori Drew, along with her daughter and an employee, are alleged to have created a fictitious dreamboat boyfriend named Josh Evans to torment their 13 year-old neighbour, Megan Meier. “Josh” romanced Megan and then turned on her, telling her that “the world would be a better place without you.” Megan hanged herself.

Missouri law was powerless to do anything about the alleged impersonation. But now, two years after Megan’s death, Drew is on trial before a federal grand jury in Los Angeles. Why L.A.? Because that’s where MySpace’s servers are located.

The criminal charges against Lori Drew are one count of conspiracy and three counts of “illegally accessing computers”. Though the law has traditionally been used against hackers, in this case the prosecution is arguing that violating MySpace’s Terms Of Use qualifies. The TOU requires “truthful and accurate" registration information. Each charge carries a maximum sentence of five years in prison.

But this potentially precedent-setting case has problems:

  • When you break a law on the internet, whose jurisdiction are you in? The place you were in at the time? Or maybe where the recipient is? Or is it where the servers are stored? This case suggests that when the authorities are mad enough, it’s wherever the laws are stiffest.
  • Can violating an online TOU be considered a federal crime, punishable by imprisonment? Long, confusing, non-negotiable TOU agreements are clicked by millions every day: often by minors, and often on sites like MySpace, which many kids look at as a casual entertainment.

You don’t have to sign a contract before watching Hannah Montana, and I question how binding a MySpace TOU should really be. In any event, I hope that this isn’t the case to decide the point.

« Previous Post | Main | Next Post »

This discussion is now Open. Submit your Comment.




See now I think people like this need to be nailed to the wall (not actually thought I'm not for capital punishment). Actions they took with the intent to hurt her ended in her death, and there needs to be answers for this. The Mom is the worst in all this with a daughter of her own, I can't believe a grown person would be such a child. They deserve some kind of punishment, I think what ever we can find is good.

Posted November 19, 2008 07:33 PM

Gordon Chamberlain

It would be an interesting article to see what our politician have done to protect Canadians from harrasment, bullying, intimidation and malliscious intent by others on the internet

Posted November 20, 2008 10:14 PM



I agree with Alex, the mother come across like a very imature and unresponsible person. crushing someones heart online for fun is the same as bullying in my opinon and should be punished.

oh, and for the record I agree with capital punishment in limited forms. the strap is an excellent deterant and brought me back to the real world when I was grossly out of line.

Posted November 22, 2008 10:58 AM



Have you ever read the terms of service on some of these sites?
They can be pretty scary, if you take them all as law.
If by agreeing to a sites TOU you are opening yourself to prosecution, we will have to be very very careful.
There should be consequences, but how far should the law go in enforcing arbitrary agreements like this?

Posted November 26, 2008 04:39 PM

Mike Parniak


This is a truly reprehensible judgment. While Drew's actions were undeniably mean and puerile, especially considering the age of the girl she was acting against, being a jackass is not, in itself, illegal.

Did she set out with the genuine intention to cause the death of Megan Meier? Unlikely. Did she break into anyone else's account to do it? No. The law used as an excuse to perform what is little more than a mob lynching would result in the imprisonment of more than 90% of internet users. People misrepresent themselves everywhere, for various reasons. The law was not about forcing people to be honest, it was meant to prosecute those who hijack other people's accounts.

As much as we may (correctly) think Drew is slime, it doesn't give us free permission to pervert the justice system to administer arbitrary justice based on our dislike for the woman.

Any code of ethics that one does not hold to when it is not convenient to do so, is not a code of ethics at all.

Badly, badly done LA.

Posted December 3, 2008 06:12 AM

« Previous Post | Main | Next Post »

Post a Comment


Note: By submitting your comments you acknowledge that CBC has the right to reproduce, broadcast and publicize those comments or any part thereof in any manner whatsoever. Please note that due to the volume of e-mails we receive, not all comments will be published, and those that are published will not be edited. But all will be carefully read, considered and appreciated.

Note: Due to volume there will be a delay before your comment is processed. Your comment will go through even if you leave this page immediately afterwards.

Privacy Policy | Submissions Policy


World »

U.S. federal appeals court blocks Trump's revised travel ban
A U.S. federal appeals court dealt another blow to President Donald Trump's revised travel ban targeting six Muslim-majority countries on Thursday, siding with groups that say the policy illegally targets Muslims. The White House says it remains confident its order is legal.
New Philippines says foreigners among ISIS-linked gunmen fighting government troops
Foreign fighters are among the ISIS-linked militants who are battling government troops in the southern Philippines, an official says.
Updated Republican wins U.S. election 1 day after being charged with assault
Republican multimillionaire Greg Gianforte won Montana's only U.S. House seat on Thursday despite being charged a day earlier with assault after witnesses said he grabbed a reporter by the neck and threw him to the ground.
more »

Canada »

Montrealer fighting for her life after Times Square crash
Montrealer Elena Avetisian is still in critical condition in a New York City hospital after she was struck by a motorist who drove his car into the Times Square crowd.
Annual G7 meeting coming to Quebec next year
Canada will play host to next year's meeting of G7 leaders at a remote luxury resort in the Charlevoix region of Quebec, The Canadian Press has learned.
2 guilty pleas in crash that killed RCMP Const. Sarah Beckett
Kenneth Fenton has pleaded guilty to two criminal counts in the death of RCMP Const. Sarah Beckett.
more »

Politics »

Analysis Trudeau suggests defence review will invest more in troops than weaponry video
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, facing demands that Canada invest more in its military, says caring for troops is the priority in the upcoming defence policy. His comments in Brussels raise questions about the focus of the Liberal government's long-awaited statement.
New trial ordered in sex assault case after Ontario judge refuses to explain her verdict
Canada's judicial watchdog is initiating a complaint against Ontario Superior Court Justice Susanne Goodman after the province's court of appeal issued a blistering ruling that calls into question her very abilities as a judge.
Midweek podcast: Who will lead British Columbia? audio
On The House midweek podcast, the final results are in and we still don't know who will end up in charge in British Columbia. The Green Party holds the balance of power and could decide to help the Liberals or the NDP form a minority government. We speak to leader Andrew Weaver. We also talk to former chief Bill Wilson about why he added his voice to the growing chorus of critics of the national inquiry into missing and murdered indigenous women and girls.
more »

Health »

Sorry - we can't find that page

Sorry, we can't find the page you requested.

  1. Please check the URL in the address bar, or ...
  2. Use the navigation links at left to explore our site, or ...
  3. Enter a term in the Quick Search box at top, or ...
  4. Visit our site map page

In a few moments, you will be taken to our site map page, which will help you find what you looking for.

more »

Arts & Entertainment»

Video How Star Wars ruined Hollywood video
Forty years ago today, director George Lucas unleashed his dream about a fantastic universe filled with brave warriors, devoted robots and exhilarating space battles. But the success of the epic series has come at a creative cost for the movie industry.
Is nostalgia enough to make Ultra Street Fighter 2 a success?
Ultra Street Fighter 2 brings back one of the most popular games of all time on Nintendo's Switch. But does this remastered version justify its $50 asking price?
'I'll never be sorry': Dirty Dancing remake viewers might disagree
ABC entered the musical adaptation game with a leap on Wednesday night, but its Dirty Dancing remake landed with a thud with many viewers and critics.
more »

Technology & Science »

NASA'S Juno spacecraft finds chaotic weather, massive cyclones over Jupiter's poles
Once it began skimming Jupiter's cloud tops last year, NASA's Juno spacecraft spotted chaotic weather, including enormous cyclones over the planet's poles, according to new research.
Q&A New research reveals what happens when adults learn to read
New research found that brain regions associated with ancient functions are largely responsible for our ability to read.
Russian spies may have backed email phishing campaign in effort to spread disinformation
New evidence of a global espionage campaign involving email phishing attacks and leaked falsified documents emerged on Thursday, with clues suggesting the Russian government might have been involved.
more »

Money »

GM accused of installing 'defeat devices' in diesel trucks to beat emissions tests
GM says it plans to defend itself against "baseless" allegations.
Canadians hoarding $16B worth of unused loyalty points
We all love free stuff so it’s no surprise that Canadians are pledging allegiance to multiple loyalty programs. However, many of us are not bothering to cash in on our rewards.
Analysis Trump's 1st budget could worsen distortions as economy cools and assets soar: Don Pittis
As inflation and the economy stagnate, house prices and stocks are hitting new highs. The danger is that Donald Trump's first budget means more of the same for North America.
more »

Consumer Life »

Sorry - we can't find that page

Sorry, we can't find the page you requested.

  1. Please check the URL in the address bar, or ...
  2. Use the navigation links at left to explore our site, or ...
  3. Enter a term in the Quick Search box at top, or ...
  4. Visit our site map page

In a few moments, you will be taken to our site map page, which will help you find what you looking for.

more »

Sports »

[an error occurred while processing this directive]
Recap Heartbreak for Senators as Penguins win in 2OT to advance to Stanley Cup video
Pittsburgh's Chris Kunitz scored in the second overtime period, bringing the Ottawa Senators' storybook spring to an end after a 3-2 loss to the Penguins Thursday in Game 7 of the Eastern Conference final.
Preview Andre De Grasse has unfinished business at Prefontaine Classic
Andre De Grasse is scheduled to run the men's 100 metres at the Prefontaine Classic in Oregon on Saturday (CBC,, 5:24 p.m. ET) , where the Canadian sprinter finished last in his Diamond League season debut a year ago.
Canada 150 Harry Jerome: Race against time video
He owned a share of the 100-metre world record while still a teenager and went on to win an Olympic medal, but Canadian sprinting legend Harry Jerome struggled to outrun the prejudice of his day.
more »

Diversions »

[an error occurred while processing this directive]
more »