Jesse Brown:15 years for violating MySpace’s Terms of Use?

By Jesse Brown, CBC technology columnist.

Millions of people pretend to be someone they’re not on the internet. On the scale of fraud, I’d say most people consider creating a fake online persona to be slightly less harmful than, say, sneaking in to a movie.

Then again, most fake online identities don’t result in suicide.

Missouri mom Lori Drew, along with her daughter and an employee, are alleged to have created a fictitious dreamboat boyfriend named Josh Evans to torment their 13 year-old neighbour, Megan Meier. “Josh” romanced Megan and then turned on her, telling her that “the world would be a better place without you.” Megan hanged herself.

Missouri law was powerless to do anything about the alleged impersonation. But now, two years after Megan’s death, Drew is on trial before a federal grand jury in Los Angeles. Why L.A.? Because that’s where MySpace’s servers are located.

The criminal charges against Lori Drew are one count of conspiracy and three counts of “illegally accessing computers”. Though the law has traditionally been used against hackers, in this case the prosecution is arguing that violating MySpace’s Terms Of Use qualifies. The TOU requires “truthful and accurate" registration information. Each charge carries a maximum sentence of five years in prison.

But this potentially precedent-setting case has problems:

  • When you break a law on the internet, whose jurisdiction are you in? The place you were in at the time? Or maybe where the recipient is? Or is it where the servers are stored? This case suggests that when the authorities are mad enough, it’s wherever the laws are stiffest.
  • Can violating an online TOU be considered a federal crime, punishable by imprisonment? Long, confusing, non-negotiable TOU agreements are clicked by millions every day: often by minors, and often on sites like MySpace, which many kids look at as a casual entertainment.

You don’t have to sign a contract before watching Hannah Montana, and I question how binding a MySpace TOU should really be. In any event, I hope that this isn’t the case to decide the point.

« Previous Post | Main | Next Post »

This discussion is now Open. Submit your Comment.




See now I think people like this need to be nailed to the wall (not actually thought I'm not for capital punishment). Actions they took with the intent to hurt her ended in her death, and there needs to be answers for this. The Mom is the worst in all this with a daughter of her own, I can't believe a grown person would be such a child. They deserve some kind of punishment, I think what ever we can find is good.

Posted November 19, 2008 07:33 PM

Gordon Chamberlain

It would be an interesting article to see what our politician have done to protect Canadians from harrasment, bullying, intimidation and malliscious intent by others on the internet

Posted November 20, 2008 10:14 PM



I agree with Alex, the mother come across like a very imature and unresponsible person. crushing someones heart online for fun is the same as bullying in my opinon and should be punished.

oh, and for the record I agree with capital punishment in limited forms. the strap is an excellent deterant and brought me back to the real world when I was grossly out of line.

Posted November 22, 2008 10:58 AM



Have you ever read the terms of service on some of these sites?
They can be pretty scary, if you take them all as law.
If by agreeing to a sites TOU you are opening yourself to prosecution, we will have to be very very careful.
There should be consequences, but how far should the law go in enforcing arbitrary agreements like this?

Posted November 26, 2008 04:39 PM

Mike Parniak


This is a truly reprehensible judgment. While Drew's actions were undeniably mean and puerile, especially considering the age of the girl she was acting against, being a jackass is not, in itself, illegal.

Did she set out with the genuine intention to cause the death of Megan Meier? Unlikely. Did she break into anyone else's account to do it? No. The law used as an excuse to perform what is little more than a mob lynching would result in the imprisonment of more than 90% of internet users. People misrepresent themselves everywhere, for various reasons. The law was not about forcing people to be honest, it was meant to prosecute those who hijack other people's accounts.

As much as we may (correctly) think Drew is slime, it doesn't give us free permission to pervert the justice system to administer arbitrary justice based on our dislike for the woman.

Any code of ethics that one does not hold to when it is not convenient to do so, is not a code of ethics at all.

Badly, badly done LA.

Posted December 3, 2008 06:12 AM

« Previous Post | Main | Next Post »

Post a Comment


Note: By submitting your comments you acknowledge that CBC has the right to reproduce, broadcast and publicize those comments or any part thereof in any manner whatsoever. Please note that due to the volume of e-mails we receive, not all comments will be published, and those that are published will not be edited. But all will be carefully read, considered and appreciated.

Note: Due to volume there will be a delay before your comment is processed. Your comment will go through even if you leave this page immediately afterwards.

Privacy Policy | Submissions Policy


World »

CBC IN MANILA 'Sometimes, I blame myself': Marites Flor on surviving hostage-taking that killed boyfriend Robert Hall video
In 2016, Canadians Robert Hall and John Ridsdel were killed by militants who held them hostage in the Philippines. Hall's girlfriend, Marites Flor, was also taken and spoke to CBC about the harrowing ordeal.
Trump takes 1st step in NAFTA renegotiation: Sends draft letter to Congress
The Trump administration has taken an early step in renegotiating the North American Free Trade Agreement, sending Congress a draft list of priorities that expresses hope for change in a broad range of areas. Now Congress will be involved in revising that list.
U.S. senator cites Russian 'propaganda on steroids' during 2016 election
The top Democrat on the U.S. Senate intelligence committee accuses Russia of mounting a campaign of "propaganda on steroids" seeking to influence the 2016 U.S. presidential election, and lists several areas of concern about possible links to Republican Donald Trump's campaign.
more »

Canada »

'Very depressing': CIBC staff losing jobs to workers in India, expected to help with training
CIBC is eliminating up to 130 jobs in its Toronto finance department and sending the work to India. Staff losing their positions must train other local CIBC employees, who will then train workers in India to take over the jobs.
Ex-Montreal mayor Michael Applebaum sentenced to 12 months behind bars
Former Montreal mayor Michael Applebaum has been sentenced to 12 months in jail and two years' probation after being found guilty of fraud and breach of trust.
Key member of Calgary jihadist cluster revealed for 1st time
CBC News has learned the full name and identity of another key member of a cluster of Calgarians who left to wage jihad in Syria and Iraq in late 2012.
more »

Politics »

New Little appetite in the U.S. business community for border tariff, says Jim Carr
Natural Resources Minister Jim Carr says there appears to be little appetite in the U.S. for a new border adjustment tax on Canadian goods.
Updated Provinces poised to sign historic Canadian Free Trade Agreement in April
Territories and provinces in Canada are expected to sign a free trade deal in April that will change the way goods and services are exchanged across the country.
RCMP appeals decision in officer's bullying lawsuit
The RCMP is appealing the judgment in a bullying lawsuit brought by one of its officers, in which the judge called the Mounties' behaviour "outrageous." The RCMP allege the trial judge made a host of errors in her ruling.
more »

Health »

Sorry - we can't find that page

Sorry, we can't find the page you requested.

  1. Please check the URL in the address bar, or ...
  2. Use the navigation links at left to explore our site, or ...
  3. Enter a term in the Quick Search box at top, or ...
  4. Visit our site map page

In a few moments, you will be taken to our site map page, which will help you find what you looking for.

more »

Arts & Entertainment»

Why a Batgirl movie by Joss Whedon is just what DC needs
The director of Avengers makes a major move: Joss Whedon is poised to leap into the DC cinematic universe to make a standalone Batgirl film
Video Musical chairs: Game of Thrones stars appear in Season 7 teaser trailer
Game of Thrones fans got the best glimpse yet into the penultimate season of the epic fantasy series with a teaser trailer that went online Thursday.
CBC BOOKS Fifteen Dogs, championed by Humble the Poet, wins Canada Reads
After four days of heated debate and passionate arguments, Fifteen Dogs by André Alexis has won Canada Reads 2017, thanks to the book's persuasive champion Humble the Poet.
more »

Technology & Science »

​SpaceX to launch first reused rocket, testing cost-cutting model
SpaceX is aiming for another space industry first on Thursday when it plans to reuse one of its rockets to launch a satellite into space.
Video Russia's Putin says climate change in Arctic good for economy video
Speaking at an Arctic forum in northern Russian city of Arkhangelsk, Putin also said Russia's shipping and energy projects in the Arctic were guided by the principle that they should do no harm to the environment.
Astronauts complete 7-hour spacewalk to set up new parking spot on ISS video
Two astronauts are back inside the International Space Station following a spacewalk that took an unintended turn when a piece of equipment got away.
more »

Money »

GDP numbers Friday expected to show economy started 2017 strong
Some economists are revising their forecasts upward for Canadian first-quarter gross domestic product growth ahead of the Friday release of figures for January.
TD Bank reviewing sales practices, CEO Bharat Masrani tells AGM
TD Bank says it is reviewing concerns about its sales practices in light of reports that some employees allegedly broke the law in order to meet sales targets and keep their jobs.
Bombardier under fire for $32.6M US given to executives while taking government cash
Bombardier is being slammed for its "sense of entitlement" after awarding more than $32.6 million US to senior executives even as it laid off thousands of workers and sought government aid.
more »

Consumer Life »

Sorry - we can't find that page

Sorry, we can't find the page you requested.

  1. Please check the URL in the address bar, or ...
  2. Use the navigation links at left to explore our site, or ...
  3. Enter a term in the Quick Search box at top, or ...
  4. Visit our site map page

In a few moments, you will be taken to our site map page, which will help you find what you looking for.

more »

Sports »

[an error occurred while processing this directive]
Hobbled Radford and partner Duhamel gut it out to finish 7th at world championships video
Hours after Eric Radford considered withdrawing due to injury, he and partner Meagan Duhamel held on to finish seventh in pairs at the world figure skating championships.
Coming Up Road to the Olympic Games: World Figure Skating Championships video
Watch as CBC TV's coverage of the World Figure Skating Championships in Helsinki, Finland continues with the men's short and pairs free programs Thursday at 6 p.m. ET.
Live Blog World Figure Skating Championships
Follow the action in real time with live dispatches from CBC Sports' Pj Kwong, Scott Russell and Brenda Irving in Helsinki, Finland.
more »

Diversions »

[an error occurred while processing this directive]
more »