Story Tools: PRINT | Text Size: S M L XL | REPORT TYPO | SEND YOUR FEEDBACK

Trekkies versus Wookies

by Paul Jay, CBC News online

Festivities are under way to celebrate the 30th anniversary of Star Wars, which some consider to be an all-time science-fiction classic and others decry as the beginning of a bloated marketing exercise.

But Star Wars has tended to fall short is the science part of science fiction. While Star Trek has inspired future technology like Tricorders or matter-antimatter fuel, Star Wars has given us...what, Wookie crossbows?

A couple of years ago Forbes and National Geographic both took at a stab at peering behind the science of Star Wars, and neither source could find too many examples of real science at work in the galaxy far, far away.

Our favourite example is the governing planet Coruscant, located according to the scripts in the heart of the galaxy. As Seth Shostak, a senior astronomer at the SETI (Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence) Institute, told National Geographic:

In general, you don't want to be quite in the "heart" of any large galaxy, as that's almost invariably the site of a massive black hole, and an active nucleus that will fill nearby space with corrosive radiation guaranteed to ruin your whole day.

No wonder the Empire won.

Bob McDonald gives a great defence of the franchise, however, by pointing out the importance of even bad science fiction in inspiring space travel.

Which still doesn't excuse Mission to Mars.

« Previous Post | Main | Next Post »

This discussion is now Open. Submit your Comment.

Comments

Justin

For the time that it was created Star Wars was a fantastic movie about the future, and although not all of it seemed completely plausible it was a fictional melodramatic and almost romantic view of space and science.

Star Trek started in much the same way in case anyone has forgotten. They started out just as ridiculous with tribbles, green women that Shatner could cuddle up to, and let's not forget atmospheric suits made from silver metalic glitter and florescant red, green tubes.

The difference in Star Wars and Star Trek is that Star Trek has had 5 series to perfect it's scientific approach and modernize it's theories on techonology. In many cases we see corrections from the classic 1970 Star Trek made in newer series, or in the very least a little more explanation as to how the technology works.

Star Wars however didn't have season after season to evolve it's technologies and ideologies. Since the new movies were again only as long as a movie it had to be rooted in the science fiction universe the origional movies created.

Star Wars and Star Trek both started just as ridiculous, Star Trek just took the time to grow over time with us.

Posted May 28, 2007 10:17 AM

Jim M.

SK

This seems to be a weird attempt by a trekie to argue the merits of Star Trek over Star Wars and pass it as news.
I would first like to point out that while the blogger lists these technologies as being "inspired" by Star Trek, no-where in the articles is that even suggested. In both, the technologies in question are just compared to technologies that were seen in the series. I still do not see a tri-corder, or matter-antimatter drives. In fact the article on the Matter-antimatter drivesw even goes on to point out several sources that used the concept first, including the original theory that sparked the concept in Sci-Fi usage.
As far as a lack of inspiration from Star Wars? "Look Sir, Droids" A single line and the concept that many feel brought the concept of practical robotics into the mainstream and has been the inspiration behind the advancement of AI and modern robotics.
Frankly, I don't see the point of this blog.

Posted June 2, 2007 12:35 AM

Kari

Mississauga

30 years? Whatever. ;)

Doctor Who hits 45 years and 30 seasons in 2008.

How about a little coverage on that, eh? CBC has coproduced the last three series (What's up with Series 4? Is CBC going to coproduce that too? Why haven't we heard anything one way or another?) and the show was originally created by Canadian Sydney Newman.

Posted November 17, 2007 12:06 AM

GRAHAM COCK

BRAVO!!! Congratulations to my late uncle,
SYDNEY NEWMAN
Sydney was married to one of my mother's sisters.
I'm not a huge fan of Sci-Fi. I am very pleased to read anything mentioned about my uncle. Sydney Newman also had worked for the National Film Board for many years,and was one of the early members on the Juno Commission in the mid-60's.

Posted January 6, 2008 04:59 PM

GRAHAM COCK

Clarification to my previous comment:The Juno Commission=The Canadian Radio TV Commission(C.R.T.C.)with Chairman,Pierre Juneau.
One of my nephews is CBC-TV producer,Stuart Coxe.
From 1979-1983 I had a unique opportunity to do free-lance radio music-documentary programs broadcast on CHAK-AM,Inuvik,N.W.T. I wrote the radio scripts,supplied music recordings,and announced on 25 oldies rock'n roll music programs(55-min./program). I have all of them preserved on music CDs,copied off my cassette tapes/dubbed from the station's master reel-reel broadcast tapes.

Posted January 7, 2008 07:04 AM

GRAHAM COCK

CHATHAM,ONTARIO

Correction to my previous comment:
My nephew,CBC-TV producer, Stuart Coxe, is in fact one of my 2nd cousins..not my nephew. I apologize for my error.

Posted January 7, 2008 07:30 AM

« Previous Post | Main | Next Post »

Post a Comment

Disclaimer:

Note: By submitting your comments you acknowledge that CBC has the right to reproduce, broadcast and publicize those comments or any part thereof in any manner whatsoever. Please note that due to the volume of e-mails we receive, not all comments will be published, and those that are published will not be edited. But all will be carefully read, considered and appreciated.

Note: Due to volume there will be a delay before your comment is processed. Your comment will go through even if you leave this page immediately afterwards.

Privacy Policy | Submissions Policy

Story Tools: PRINT | Text Size: S M L XL | REPORT TYPO | SEND YOUR FEEDBACK

World »

Analysis Health-care havoc: Trump's 1st legislative test a 'big loser' that puts his agenda on shaky ground video
Donald Trump’s first major legislative push to eliminate and replace the current health-care legislation ran off road Friday, striking a blow his young presidency’s momentum and denting his image as a master negotiator.
Jailed Philippine senator says she 'won't be quiet' about President Duterte
Jailed Philippine Senator Leila de Lima says she's a political prisoner. President Rodrigo Duterte says she's a drug trafficker. CBC's Adrienne Arsenault travelled to Manila for an exclusive jailhouse interview with de Lima.
U.S. coalition investigating reports of deadly Mosul airstrike
The U.S.-led coalition fighting ISIS is investigating reports of an airstrike in a western neighbourhood in the Iraqi city of Mosul that allegedly left more than 100 civilians dead last week, according to a statement given to The Associated Press on Friday.
more »

Canada »

Analysis Liberals' latest attempt at parliamentary reform remains a tale of woe, for now video
The latest attempt at parliamentary reform in Canada seems in danger of being strangled by parliamentary democracy.
Dennis Oland's lawyers prepare to seek 'complete vindication'
Dennis Oland's second degree murder case soon could be back before the Supreme Court of Canada as his defence lawyers prepare next steps in their bid toward his "complete vindication."
FIFTH ESTATE 'Strong suspicion': Dylan Koshman's 2008 disappearance in Edmonton upgraded to homicide investigation
An eight-year-old missing person case involving the disappearance of Dylan Koshman in Edmonton has been upgraded to a homicide investigation, The Fifth Estate has learned.
more »

Politics »

Liberal MPs gather in Ottawa for rare weekend caucus meeting
Days after handing down its second budget, the Liberal government has asked its MPs to stay in Ottawa this weekend to discuss how best to sell the financial plan to constituents.
Analysis Liberals' latest attempt at parliamentary reform remains a tale of woe, for now video
The latest attempt at parliamentary reform in Canada seems in danger of being strangled by parliamentary democracy.
Republicans have no plans to revisit Obamacare repeal after bill fails video
In a humiliating failure, U.S. President Donald Trump and Republican leaders yanked their bill to repeal Obamacare off the House floor Friday when it became clear it would fail badly — after seven years of nonstop railing against the health-care law.
more »

Health »

Sorry - we can't find that page
 
CBC.ca

Sorry, we can't find the page you requested.

  1. Please check the URL in the address bar, or ...
  2. Use the navigation links at left to explore our site, or ...
  3. Enter a term in the Quick Search box at top, or ...
  4. Visit our site map page

In a few moments, you will be taken to our site map page, which will help you find what you looking for.

more »

Arts & Entertainment»

How moving to Canada helped Amy Jo Johnson, the first Pink Power Ranger, reinvent her career
The crush of fame that came with starring in Mighty Morphin' Power Rangers in the '90s was almost too much for a young Amy Jo Johnson to handle. But it was the start of a varied and ultimately successful career.
No changes to The Last Jedi because of Carrie Fisher's death, says Disney CEO
Disney CEO Bob Iger says the upcoming Star Wars sequel has not been changed due to the death of Carrie Fisher.
As It Happens Sesame Street puppeteer hopes new Muppet with autism will help kids understand each other
Sesame Street puppeteer Stacey Gordon hopes the new character Julia will help children understand that "kids who might behave like Julia are just like they are."
more »

Technology & Science »

Black hole gets unusual 'kick' out of galaxy core thanks to gravitational waves video
A team of international researchers got a bit of a shock recently: A supermassive black hole — something that normally anchors the centre of a galaxy — was spotted speeding away from its home. The reason? Gravitational waves, says the research team.
The politics of Pluto: 10 years later, the bitter debate rages on
More than 10 years after Pluto was demoted from planet to dwarf planet, the debate continues, with leading scientists on both sides becoming more vociferous and maybe a little testy.
Blog Trump's proposed NASA cuts take aim at Earth science
Officials at NASA were delighted that U.S. President Donald Trump's budget proposal allocates $19.1 billion for the agency, down only 0.8 per cent from last year, but the proposal also cuts several programs to study the Earth.
more »

Money »

Keystone XL pipeline gets OK from U.S. State Department video
Calgary-based TransCanada has received a presidential permit from the U.S. State Department that allows it to build the long-delayed Keystone XL pipeline.
Toronto stock index extends rally, Wall Street mixed after 'Trumpcare' pulled
Canada's main stock index extended its rally for a third consecutive day on Friday after beginning the week at its lowest level this year, as Wall Street idled on the latest 'Trumpcare' news.
Inflation rate cools to 2% in February video
Canada's inflation rate was two per cent in February, a slight cooldown from January's level.
more »

Consumer Life »

Sorry - we can't find that page
 
CBC.ca

Sorry, we can't find the page you requested.

  1. Please check the URL in the address bar, or ...
  2. Use the navigation links at left to explore our site, or ...
  3. Enter a term in the Quick Search box at top, or ...
  4. Visit our site map page

In a few moments, you will be taken to our site map page, which will help you find what you looking for.

more »

Sports »

[an error occurred while processing this directive]
Recap Ducks shut down Jets to pull away from Oilers in playoff race video
Andrew Cogliano scored late in the second period, Jonathan Bernier made 17 saves and the Anaheim Ducks beat the Winnipeg Jets 3-1 on Friday night.
Video Hip Check: Feelin' the Weight video
An emotional roller-coaster for Islanders head coach Doug Weight.
2 players turn down USA Hockey's replacement team invite
Unions representing NHL and Major League Baseball players are backing U.S. women's national hockey team players' decision to boycott next week's world championships because of a wage dispute.
more »

Diversions »

[an error occurred while processing this directive]
more »