Trekkies versus Wookies

by Paul Jay, CBC News online

Festivities are under way to celebrate the 30th anniversary of Star Wars, which some consider to be an all-time science-fiction classic and others decry as the beginning of a bloated marketing exercise.

But Star Wars has tended to fall short is the science part of science fiction. While Star Trek has inspired future technology like Tricorders or matter-antimatter fuel, Star Wars has given us...what, Wookie crossbows?

A couple of years ago Forbes and National Geographic both took at a stab at peering behind the science of Star Wars, and neither source could find too many examples of real science at work in the galaxy far, far away.

Our favourite example is the governing planet Coruscant, located according to the scripts in the heart of the galaxy. As Seth Shostak, a senior astronomer at the SETI (Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence) Institute, told National Geographic:

In general, you don't want to be quite in the "heart" of any large galaxy, as that's almost invariably the site of a massive black hole, and an active nucleus that will fill nearby space with corrosive radiation guaranteed to ruin your whole day.

No wonder the Empire won.

Bob McDonald gives a great defence of the franchise, however, by pointing out the importance of even bad science fiction in inspiring space travel.

Which still doesn't excuse Mission to Mars.

« Previous Post | Main | Next Post »

This discussion is now Open. Submit your Comment.



For the time that it was created Star Wars was a fantastic movie about the future, and although not all of it seemed completely plausible it was a fictional melodramatic and almost romantic view of space and science.

Star Trek started in much the same way in case anyone has forgotten. They started out just as ridiculous with tribbles, green women that Shatner could cuddle up to, and let's not forget atmospheric suits made from silver metalic glitter and florescant red, green tubes.

The difference in Star Wars and Star Trek is that Star Trek has had 5 series to perfect it's scientific approach and modernize it's theories on techonology. In many cases we see corrections from the classic 1970 Star Trek made in newer series, or in the very least a little more explanation as to how the technology works.

Star Wars however didn't have season after season to evolve it's technologies and ideologies. Since the new movies were again only as long as a movie it had to be rooted in the science fiction universe the origional movies created.

Star Wars and Star Trek both started just as ridiculous, Star Trek just took the time to grow over time with us.

Posted May 28, 2007 10:17 AM

Jim M.


This seems to be a weird attempt by a trekie to argue the merits of Star Trek over Star Wars and pass it as news.
I would first like to point out that while the blogger lists these technologies as being "inspired" by Star Trek, no-where in the articles is that even suggested. In both, the technologies in question are just compared to technologies that were seen in the series. I still do not see a tri-corder, or matter-antimatter drives. In fact the article on the Matter-antimatter drivesw even goes on to point out several sources that used the concept first, including the original theory that sparked the concept in Sci-Fi usage.
As far as a lack of inspiration from Star Wars? "Look Sir, Droids" A single line and the concept that many feel brought the concept of practical robotics into the mainstream and has been the inspiration behind the advancement of AI and modern robotics.
Frankly, I don't see the point of this blog.

Posted June 2, 2007 12:35 AM



30 years? Whatever. ;)

Doctor Who hits 45 years and 30 seasons in 2008.

How about a little coverage on that, eh? CBC has coproduced the last three series (What's up with Series 4? Is CBC going to coproduce that too? Why haven't we heard anything one way or another?) and the show was originally created by Canadian Sydney Newman.

Posted November 17, 2007 12:06 AM


BRAVO!!! Congratulations to my late uncle,
Sydney was married to one of my mother's sisters.
I'm not a huge fan of Sci-Fi. I am very pleased to read anything mentioned about my uncle. Sydney Newman also had worked for the National Film Board for many years,and was one of the early members on the Juno Commission in the mid-60's.

Posted January 6, 2008 04:59 PM


Clarification to my previous comment:The Juno Commission=The Canadian Radio TV Commission(C.R.T.C.)with Chairman,Pierre Juneau.
One of my nephews is CBC-TV producer,Stuart Coxe.
From 1979-1983 I had a unique opportunity to do free-lance radio music-documentary programs broadcast on CHAK-AM,Inuvik,N.W.T. I wrote the radio scripts,supplied music recordings,and announced on 25 oldies rock'n roll music programs(55-min./program). I have all of them preserved on music CDs,copied off my cassette tapes/dubbed from the station's master reel-reel broadcast tapes.

Posted January 7, 2008 07:04 AM



Correction to my previous comment:
My nephew,CBC-TV producer, Stuart Coxe, is in fact one of my 2nd cousins..not my nephew. I apologize for my error.

Posted January 7, 2008 07:30 AM

« Previous Post | Main | Next Post »

Post a Comment


Note: By submitting your comments you acknowledge that CBC has the right to reproduce, broadcast and publicize those comments or any part thereof in any manner whatsoever. Please note that due to the volume of e-mails we receive, not all comments will be published, and those that are published will not be edited. But all will be carefully read, considered and appreciated.

Note: Due to volume there will be a delay before your comment is processed. Your comment will go through even if you leave this page immediately afterwards.

Privacy Policy | Submissions Policy


World »

Republicans rush to find enough votes to avoid U.S. government shutdown
Republican leaders in the U.S. Congress are stepping up their efforts to round up the votes needed to pass a temporary extension in government funding and prevent a looming shutdown.
Bus fire in Kazakhstan kills 52 along route used by migrant workers
A bus fire in northwestern Kazakhstan killed 52 Uzbek citizens on a route used by migrant workers heading to Russia, the Kazakh Interior Ministry said on Thursday.
Grandparents of starved, shackled children in California shocked at the news
The grandparents of 13 starved and tortured children say their son's family looked happy and healthy when they last visited the family in California six years ago.
more »

Canada »

Foreign spouses hit snags with 'streamlined' sponsorship program video
A Swedish woman living in Ottawa says the government erroneously returned her spousal sponsorship application twice, forcing her to apply all over again. It's a problem that some immigration lawyers say they're seeing happen more often since the government imposed new deadlines on processing times.
New Toronto makes cut of top 20 cities vying to be Amazon's 2nd headquarters
Toronto is the only Canadian city to make the list of the top 20 cities that Amazon is considering for its second headquarters.
GO PUBLIC More Rogers employees come forward, revealing how they say they're coached to upsell you
Rogers employees reveal tactics they use to push products and services on customers, or risk losing their jobs.
more »

Politics »

Bonuses, performance pay for government executives rose in Trudeau's 1st year
Spending on bonuses and other performance pay for top federal government executives increased by more than double the rate of inflation and double what the rest of the public service got in Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s first year in office, CBC News has learned.
Analysis Jagmeet Singh's question-popping photo op and the vague limits of touchy-feely transparency
Jagmeet Singh might have announced his impending nuptials by simply tweeting a photo of himself and his bride-to-be. Instead, he went a step further: inviting a photographer from the Canadian Press wire service and a reporter from Toronto Life to witness and document the moment of his proposal.
Analysis Facebook's newsfeed changes mean political parties need to adapt — or pay up
Facebook's new emphasis on content from friends and family will force political parties to make more engaging content and spend more on advertisements to reach voters.
more »

Health »

Sorry - we can't find that page

Sorry, we can't find the page you requested.

  1. Please check the URL in the address bar, or ...
  2. Use the navigation links at left to explore our site, or ...
  3. Enter a term in the Quick Search box at top, or ...
  4. Visit our site map page

In a few moments, you will be taken to our site map page, which will help you find what you looking for.

more »

Arts & Entertainment»

Barenaked Together: Steven Page to join Barenaked Ladies for Music Hall of Fame induction
​Barenaked Ladies aren't getting back together with Steven Page, but for a few minutes at the Juno Awards it might almost feel that way.
New Police probe 3rd Kevin Spacey sex assault allegation, U.K. media report
Britain's media say police in London are investigating a third allegation of sexual assault against two-time Academy Award winning actor Kevin Spacey.
Exclusive London, Ont., school boards pull funding for gay prom musical over script
Two school boards in London, Ont., have pulled their financial backing of a play about a gay student's fight to take his boyfriend to the prom, CBC News has learned, with one board spokesperson saying the script doesn't coincide with school "culture and values."
more »

Technology & Science »

Hidden black hole caught flinging star back and forth in distant cluster
Astronomers using an observatory in Chile have revealed a star in a cluster that is being flung hundreds of thousands of kilometres back and forth because of a nearby black hole.
In world first, drone rescues 2 swimmers off Australian beach video
A drone rescued two swimmers off an Australian beach on Thursday, a world first for the fast-developing technology that seems perfectly suited to saving lives at sea, authorities said.
Scientists calculate proteins in a single cell and find 42 million
Scientists have produced what they say is the first reliable count of protein molecules in a simple cell. They hope the finding will lead to new ways to predict diseases such as cancer in more complex human cells.
more »

Money »

New Toronto makes cut of top 20 cities vying to be Amazon's 2nd headquarters
Toronto is the only Canadian city to make the list of the top 20 cities that Amazon is considering for its second headquarters.
New Tax reform prompts Apple to pay $38B tax bill to bring home $245B in foreign profits
Apple plans to build a new corporate campus and hire 20,000 U.S. workers in an expansion driven in part by a tax cut that will enable the iPhone maker to bring an estimated $245 billion US back to its home country.
Analysis Gloom over debts and NAFTA threats trounced by 'positive surprises': Don Pittis
The Bank of Canada's leaders say NAFTA and Canadians' debt keep them awake at night. But they say a string of positive surprises like rising wages and business investment outweigh those risks.
more »

Consumer Life »

Sorry - we can't find that page

Sorry, we can't find the page you requested.

  1. Please check the URL in the address bar, or ...
  2. Use the navigation links at left to explore our site, or ...
  3. Enter a term in the Quick Search box at top, or ...
  4. Visit our site map page

In a few moments, you will be taken to our site map page, which will help you find what you looking for.

more »

Sports »

[an error occurred while processing this directive]
Longtime snowboard star Sebastien Toutant doesn't want big air to be all about quad video
Sebastien Toutant has played a significant role in helping snowboard progress during his stellar career. But the Montreal native doesn't want the sport to be defined by a singular trick like the quad.
Analysis Mind Games: Older athletes prove experience can be golden
Their hair may show strands of grey, and in athletic years they may be considered geriatric, but do not let that fool you. By no means should you overlook the abilities of the older athlete and fall victim to believing they are past their prime.
Martin Brodeur wants that golden feeling again
Martin Brodeur says the gold medal he won in 2002 means as much to him as his three Stanley Cups. Now the future Hall of Fame goalie is chasing another Olympic title — this time as an executive with Team Canada.
more »

Diversions »

[an error occurred while processing this directive]
more »