Male cleaner fish punish females for poor service
Last Updated: Thursday, January 7, 2010 | 3:21 PM ET
CBC News
Two bluestreak cleaner wrasses clean a surgeonfish client. (Gerry Allen)Scientists have found that male cleaner fish will punish their female partners if they do something that offends the larger client fish they are cleaning.
This "third-party punishment" is surprising because the males don't appear to be directly harmed by the females' behaviour.
Nichola Raihani of the Zoological Society of London and colleagues at the University of Queensland, Australia, and the University of Neuchâtel, Switzerland, say their study could explain the evolution of apparently altruistic behaviour in other species, including humans.
The bluestreak cleaner wrasse (Labroides dimidiatus) is a cleaner fish that lives in coral reefs and eats parasites that grow on larger "client" fish.
The fish will occasionally try to sneak a larger meal by eating some of the mucus from the skin of the larger fish, but this upsets the client fish.
"Clients will leave if they are cheated at a cleaning station. That means the male's dinner leaves if the female cheats," said Raihani in a statement.
Males will aggressively chase female cleaners who try to cheat the system by sneaking a bite of skin mucus.
"By punishing cheating females, the males are not really sticking up for the clients but are making sure that they get a decent meal," said Raihani.
Raihani and her colleagues tested this behaviour by putting two cleaner fish, a male and a female, in a tank and giving them a plate of fish flakes and prawns.
The fish will eat both foods, but much prefer the prawns. Whenever a fish ate a prawn, the researchers removed the plate of food.
Eventually, the males started punishing the females whenever the females ate a prawn. The researchers observed that the females were less likely to eat the prawns after being punished.
Punishing the females allowed the males to eat more fish flakes, just as punishing the females in nature for eating the client fish's skin mucus allows the males to eat more parasites.
The research appears this week in the journal Science.
