 |
BACKGROUNDER: BARRY BONDS FACES STEROID ALLEGATIONS
Under a cloud of suspicion
CBC Sports Online | Last updated March 30, 2006
He
is a sports writer's dream come true. Superb on the field, he has
spent the past few years rewriting some of the most hallowed records
in that most tradition-minded of sports, baseball. Flinty and flawed
off the field, he has kept tabloid press and Pulitzer-winning papers
busy chronicling his arrogance and personal relations.
And now in
the twilight of his career, allegations of doping may forever taint
the legacy of Barry Bonds.
Starting as a true five-tool player, Bonds wowed fans and journalists
alike with his highlight-reel catches, sizzling speed on the bases
and prowess at the plate. Today, the first two elements have all but
disappeared from his baseball profile, while the last has grown to
mythic some charge questionable proportions and have
put the focus almost exclusively on what Bonds does when he's not
on at the plate.
CBC Sports Online takes a look at the recent allegations against the player
some say is the greatest ever, detailed in Game of Shadows, a book
released this month by two San Francisco Chronicle reporters.
1. What are the allegations against Barry Bonds?
2. What kind of drugs did Bonds allegedly take?
3. Where did Bonds get the drugs he allegedly used?
4. Has Bonds ever tested positive for steroids?
5. If the drugs were undetectable, how did authorities
find out about them?
6. What is baseball's doping policy?
7. So why didn't baseball take action against drug cheats
earlier?
8. So what happens now?
9. What is Bonds's legacy?
What are the allegations against Barry Bonds?
|
| Barry Bonds
works out at the Giants practice facility. (CP File Photo) |
A cloud
of suspicion has hovered over the Giants slugger ever since the 2000
season, when a bulked-up Bonds began hitting more homers with increased
power.
Bonds smacked 37 home runs in 1998, his fourth-highest total up until
that time. In 2000, he hit a career-high 49 homers and the next year
rewrote the history books, clobbering 73 to break Mark McGwire's single-season
record. He followed that up with three consecutive 45-home run seasons.
Prompted by his change in appearance (a bloated face, thinning hair
and muscles aplenty), there were murmurs inside and outside baseball
that Bonds was using steroids. Bonds attributed his changed physique
and increased hitting power to an intense off-season weight-training
regime.
But a recently published book alleges Bonds used a host of performance-enhancing
drugs before Major League Baseball introduced mandatory drug testing
in 2004.
The authors of the book Game of Shadows conducted a two-year investigation
which included audio tapes and interviews with more than 200 sources,
as well as court documents, affidavits filed by investigators into
the BALCO scandal, confidential memoranda of federal agents (including
statements made to them by athletes and trainers) and grand jury testimony.
Mark Fainaru-Wada and Lance Williams, reporters for the San Francisco
Chronicle, claim Bonds was spurred on to seek out steroids after the
1998 season in which McGwire and Sammy Sosa engaged in their home-run
record chase.
The book asserts Bonds grew jealous of the attention paid to McGwire
(which Bonds felt was partially motivated by race) and enlisted the
help of Anderson to supervise strength conditioning prior to the 1999
season.
The authors also cite the grand jury testimony of Kimberly Bell, Bonds's
mistress. In addition to telling the grand jury that Bonds confessed
to her in 2000 about his steroid use, Bell also described the numerous
changes in Bonds's physical appearance and behaviour that are consistent
with steroid use, including acne, hair loss, and a larger-than-normal
head.
Another new book, Love Me, Hate Me: Barry Bonds and the Making of
an Antihero by Jeff Pearlman, also outlines Bonds's jealousy over
McGwire as the impetus for taking steroids.
Recounting a dinner at Ken Griffey Jr.'s house following the 1998
season, Pearlman quotes an agitated Bonds as saying, "As much as I've
complained about McGwire and (Jose) Canseco and all of the bull with
steroids, I'm tired of fighting it. I turn 35 this year. I've got
three or four good seasons left, and I wanna get paid.
"I'm just gonna start using some hard-core stuff, and hopefully it
won't hurt my body. Then I'll get out of the game and be done with
it.''
Griffey has recently denied that conversation ever happened.
What kind of drugs did Bonds allegedly take?
Fainaru-Wada and Williams allege Bonds used a cornucopia of performance-enhancing
drugs before 2003, including insulin, human growth hormone, testosterone
decanoate (a fast-acting steroid known as Mexican beans), trenbolone
(a steroid created to improve the muscle quality of cattle), Clomid
(a women's infertility drug thought to help a steroid user recover
his natural testosterone production), and Modafinil (a narcolepsy
drug used as a powerful stimulant).
He also allegedly used designer THG-base steroids that were undetectable
by drug tests.
ESPN claims Bonds, in 1997, took androstenedione the same drug
a keen-eyed reporter spotted in McGwire's locker during his historic
1998 season.
Furthermore, Game of Shadows claims Bonds took the drugs in a variety
of ways: injection, pill form or liquid drops.
He's also said to have eschewed the breaks from the cycles of steroid
use. The time off from the drugs help the body naturally produce testosterone.
Where did Bonds get the drugs he allegedly used?
|
| BALCO
founder Victor Conte. (CP File Photo) |
Aside from Bonds himself, Victor Conte and Greg Anderson are the two
key figures at the centre this steroid maelstrom.
Conte the scientist found guilty of selling illegal performance-enhancing
drugs through his San Francisco-based company BALCO made the
designer steroids Bonds allegedly used.
Anderson, the slugger's long-time personal trainer, introduced Bonds
to Conte.
Together Conte and Anderson built Bonds into the most fearsome home
run hitter ever.
According to Fainaru-Wada and Williams, Anderson was already injecting
Bonds with powerful steroids and human growth hormone when Conte arrived
on the scene prior to the start 2000 season.
Bonds told the bodybuilding magazine Muscle and Fitness the two men
put him on a comprehensive training and individualized diet regime
that included consuming Conte's signature nutritional supplement ZMA.
In their book, Fainaru-Wada and Williams claim Conte gave steroids
to high-profile athletes in exchange for ZMA endorsements.
The authors also argue it was Conte's expertise with performance-enhancing
drugs that pushed Bonds to the next level.
"Anderson knew steroids, but his knowledge was from the inject-and-grow
school," wrote Fainaru-Wada and Williams.
"Conte's drug cocktails were designed not only to be undetectable
but also to address an athlete's specific needs."
The book cites U.S. law enforcement officials who says Conte claims
Bonds used his two THG-based drugs dubbed The Clear and The
Cream "on a regular basis."
In 2004, Bonds testified during a grand jury investigation into BALCO
that Anderson incorporated flaxseed oil and a pain-relieving balm
into his regime.
Bonds said he didn't know those substances may have contained steroids.
Has Bonds ever tested positive for steroids?
There is no smoking gun. Bonds has never tested positive for performance-enhancing
drugs.
In an interview with USA Today earlier this year, MLB commissioner
Bud Selig confirmed there is "no empirical data that [Bonds] did anything
wrong."
That said, baseball didn't test for steroids until 2003.
Bonds did undergo a random drug test in September 2004. Afterward,
he said he was "glad" the test was done and it would prove he was
clean.
"The fact that someone should write in the newspaper is, 'I've never
failed a drug test,'" demanded Bonds in the fall of 2005.
That said, a Fainaru-Wada and Williams story in the San Francisco
Chronicle suggested Bonds passed tests because Conte's drugs couldn't
be picked up.
"The whole thing is, everything that I've been doing at this point,
it's all undetectable," Anderson said in a secret recording obtained
by the newspaper.
"See the stuff I have, we created it, and you can't buy it anywhere
else, can't get it anywhere else, but you can take it the day of [the
test], pee, and it comes up perfect."
If the drugs were undetectable, how did authorities
find out about them?
The case against Bonds erupted in 2003 after the United States Anti-Doping
Agency (USADA) received a tip from an anonymous track and field coach,
who claimed several star athletes were using a designer steroid that
couldn't be detected by tests.
The unnamed source later revealed to be Trevor Graham, the
coach of Olympic sprint champion Justin Gatlin provided a syringe
with a sample of the steroid, which would come to be known as THG.
Graham alleged the drug came from BALCO.
On Sept. 3, law enforcement officials raided BALCO's San Francisco
area lab and confronted Conte and his partner James Valente.
Conte co-operated with government officials, giving what Fainaru-Wada
and Williams called, a "remarkable account of the steroid conspiracy
he had directed."
Conte also surrendered boxes of "The Clear" and "The Cream"
variants of THG and implicated 27 athletes including
Bonds. Detailed files on all Conte's athletes were also turned over,
according to Fainaru-Wada and Williams.
Conte was contacted in prison by Reuters just before the release of
Game of Shadows. In a letter to the wire service, Conte condemned
Fainaru-Wada and Williams's book saying it "contains outright lies."
"Much of the information prepared by federal agents regarding what
I said on the day of the BALCO raid was completely fabricated," Conte
wrote.
Conte also recently issued a statement to USA Today denying he gave
Bonds steroids directly, but he did admit giving drugs to Anderson.
Valente told officials Anderson was BALCO's contact with baseball
players.
According to Fainaru-Wada and Williams, Anderson admitted giving baseball
players drugs, including "The Clear" and "The Cream," but wouldn't
say he gave steroids to Bonds.
Anderson, Conte and Valente all pleaded guilty to distributing steroids
last year. Conte was sentenced to four months in jail. He's due to
be released at end of March 2006. Afterward he'll begin four months
of house arrest.
What is baseball's doping policy?
Major League Baseball's stance on drug use has changed over the years
from turning a blind eye to casting a suspicious glance, thanks in
large part to political prodding.
Prior to the 2003 season, players were not subjected to drug testing
and risked pretty much nothing for taking steroids. A clause in the
collective bargaining agreement forced MLB to adopt mandatory drug
testing of all players starting with the 2004 campaign.
However, the punishments doled out under the new testing were seen
as too lenient by many critics, and in the aftermath of the BACLO
scandal, America's pastime came under attack.
Politicians like U.S Senator John McCain joined with anti-doping officials
to call on baseball to institute tougher drug testing. U.S. President
George W. Bush asked MLB to take "strong steps" to eradicate the use
of steroids and performance-enhancing substances in baseball.
The possibility of legislative intervention from Congress was enough
to force Selig to unveil a new drug policy in January 2005.
Last season, players were subject to one mandatory test and random
testing during the course of the season, as well as out-of-season
testing. Players also faced a one-year ban after a fourth positive
test.
Despite the tougher penalties, baseball was put directly under the
microscope when a U.S. congressional hearing conducted a formal investigative
hearing into the game's new drug-testing policy.
Current and retired baseball players were subpoenaed to come to Washington
to testify, an infamous event punctuated by Rafael Palmeiro's over-the-top
denial of steroid use, later shown to be a lie. But Bonds was not
there.
Many legal experts believe Bonds was not called because his testimony
could undermine a potential perjury case against him Bonds
did not receive immunity for his testimony before the grand jury in
2003, leaving him open to a potential perjury case if he lied under
oath.
Following the hearings, and with the U.S. senate now threatening legislative
action, MLB players and owners revised the drug-testing program in
November 2005, coming to terms on a set of tougher penalties for steroids,
as well as amphetamine use.
Starting this upcoming season, all players will be tested during spring
training physicals and at least once during the regular season. There
is also the possibility of random tests. Players now risk a lifetime
ban for a third positive test.
So why didn't baseball take action against drug
cheats earlier?
|
|
Mark McGwire captured the attention of sports fans with his historic chase of Roger Maris in 1998. (CP Photo)
|
Most critics argue the seeds of baseball's current drug scandal were
sown in 1994.
That summer, the game's owners waged a bitter labour war against the
players, resulting in a 232-day strike that led to the cancellation
of the World Series.
Baseball returned in spring of 1995, but many disillusioned fans didn't.
Revenue, attendance and TV numbers dropped. The game was never able
to recover in some markets, such as Montreal.
Team owners looked to the past for a cure, and found it: the home
run.
In 1919, baseball was almost destroyed by the Black Sox match-fixing
scandal. Fans were horrified by revelations that eight members of
the Chicago White Sox conspired with gamblers to throw the World Series.
To win fans back, a livelier "juiced" ball was introduced. The move
ended, what baseball historians call, the "Dead-ball Era" and launched
the legend of Babe Ruth.
Ruth's bravado and big bat brought fans back to the game in droves.
Due in no small part to his popularity, the New York Yankees were
able to build a new, bigger ballpark in the Bronx. Yankee Stadium
would become known as the "House that Ruth Built."
Owners reasoned if homers saved the game at the beginning of the century,
they could do the same at the end of the century.
"Every concession was made to power," wrote Thomas Boswell in a column
for the Washington Post.
One of those "concessions," according to Boswell, was turning a blind
eye to the use of performance-enhancing drugs by its players.
And it appears the move worked. Many experts credit a home-run spike
and the Mark McGwire-Sammy Sosa chase of Roger Maris's single-season
homer crown in 1998 with resurrecting the game.
And today the league is flourishing. Major League Baseball generated
a record $4.8 billion in revenue last year, according to USA Today.
In that light, Boswell argues Bonds's alleged drug use should be viewed
as merely a symptom of baseball's bigger problem: greed.
"When sports fundamentally warp themselves out of greed, we never
know until later where the long-term damage will manifest itself,"
he wrote.
"… [Y]our sins don't 'find you out' in the forms of your own choosing.
Your misdeeds come back in warped and intractable ways."
So what happens now?
That's the $64,000 question.
With the steroid controversy the talk of the sports world thanks to
the publication of Game of Shadows, Bud Selig announced plans
for formal investigation into drug use in baseball.
Selig hired- former Senate majority leader George Mitchell to conduct
the probe. Mitchell has been given complete control of the investigation, which won't focus only on Bonds
but other players as well.
"The unique circumstances surrounding BALCO and the evidence revealed in a recently published book have convinced me that Major League Baseball must undertake this investigation," Selig said.
Selig isn't the first commissioner to hire an independent investigator:
Bart Giamatti hired lawyer John Dowd to probe Pete Rose's gambling
activities in the 1980s. The Dowd Report detailed Rose's betting on
baseball games, and led to Rose's lifetime ban in August 1989.
So what will Selig do?
Many pundits are encouraging the commissioner to invoke the "best-interests-of-baseball"
clause written into baseball's Major League Constitution to suspend
Bonds, thus bypassing the guidelines for suspension outlined in MLB's
drug-testing policy.
But unilaterally suspending Bonds, who has passed every drug test
since 2003, isn't that easy: short of direct evidence that Bonds took
performance-enhancing drugs, a suspension would lead to a standoff
with Donald Fehr and the players' association.
Veteran player agent Alan Hendricks told USA Today that if Selig tried
to suspend Bonds, "the (players) union would squash him.
"It may be all right to make Bonds uncomfortable, but it's not right
to suspend him."
It's also important to keep in mind that baseball first implemented
its drug-testing policy in 2003. Before then, it was not illegal for
players to take steroids.
Legal experts believe Bonds would have strong grounds for a lawsuit
if Selig tries to suspend him for taking steroids during a period
in MLB's history when it wasn't even illegal to do so.
What is Bonds's legacy?
|
| Barry
Bonds is the only member of the 500 homer-500 stolen base
club. But will he make it to the Hall of Fame? |
Some believe Bonds's name should be uttered in the same breath with
baseball deities like Ruth, Hank Aaron and Willy Mays.
Others argue Bonds should be made a pariah, banished from the game
like Rose and Joe Jackson.
If Bonds retires after the 2006 season he'll be eligible for baseball's
Hall of Fame in 2011. Based just on his gaudy numbers he's an automatic
first-ballot inductee.
But critics maintain Bonds's legacy shouldn't solely be based on statistics.
They argue a player's character should also be considered when determining
Hall-worthiness.
While on the field his numbers may be unmatched, it's in this arena
where Bonds may come up short.
"If the allegations in Game of Shadows are accurate," wrote Michael
O'Keeffe of the New York Daily News, "Bonds' integrity, sportsmanship
and character are well below the Mendoza line, and the only way Bonds
should get into Cooperstown is if he buys a ticket."
Bonds has never been accused of being a nice guy. His clashes with
teammates, trainers and media have been well chronicled.
Over the years, he's been described as arrogant, self-absorbed and
bitter and now he's being called a drug-cheat and a liar.
Bonds's stiffest critics charge he knowingly took steroids and committed
perjury when he told the grand jury he didn't. They also argue all
of Bonds's records should come with an asterisk, if they're not erased
outright.
"As someone who has been counting ballots for 13 years, I can say
our people don't like drug users, Jack O'Connell," secretary-treasurer
of the Baseball Writers' Association of America the group that
decides who gets into the Hall told the San Francisco Chronicle.
Bonds's defenders point out there's no iron-clad proof of steroid
use and even if Fainaru-Wada and Williams's allegations are true,
Bonds didn't break any of baseball's rules, at least not until very
recently.
Baseball had no policy against steroids when Bonds was allegedly doping
in the late 1990s and early 2000s. Steroids weren't outlawed until
a year ago and Bonds hasn't failed a drug test.
"I couldn't care less what people write or about this investigation
or that investigation," said superstar Alex Rodriguez when asked about
the steroid allegations against Bonds.
"Until you are proven guilty, you are innocent. We are in America,
right?"
And even if proof that Bonds cheated does surface, it wouldn't make
him be first baseball player saddled with ethical baggage. Hall of
Famer Ty Cobb was a racist. Pitcher Gaylord Perry used all sorts of
questionable methods to illegally doctor baseballs.
Some also maintain Bonds's alleged crimes against the game are not
nearly as heinous as those perpetrated by Rose and Jackson, who violated
baseball's cardinal rule when they brought gambling into the clubhouse.
"[Steroid] cheating is, in a twisted way, in keeping with the spirit
of the game. They're trying to win," wrote Stephen Canella for CNNSI.com.
"Drug use doesn't guarantee a home run any more than throwing a spitball
guarantees a no-hitter. Even if everyone's juiced, the ball still
has to be hit, pitches still have to be made.
"Rose's gambling, on the other hand, casts into doubt nearly everything
that happened in any game he was involved in. It raises the possibility
that those games were rigged, that the outcomes were determined before
the first pitch."
Bonds boosters argue the slugger would be a Hall of Famer with or
without the help of drugs.
Before the 1999 season Bonds's first on steroids according
to Fainaru-Wada and Williams he'd already won the National
League's most-valuable-player award three times, made eight all-star
teams and won eight Gold Gloves for his stellar defensive play.
Bonds had also slugged 411 home runs more than Joe Dimaggio,
Hank Greenberg and Johnny Bench.
Still, pitcher Bob Feller, who has been in baseball's Hall of Fame
longer than any other living player, doesn't believe players like
Bonds or Palmeiro, maybe even McGwire, will be enshrined.
"He's not going to get the numbers when it comes to Cooperstown,"
said the 87-year-old Feller about Bonds.
"Those players who have been convicted of using steroids or are caught
using them are not going to get the numbers to be elected to the Hall
of Fame when they become eligible for that great honour. And I am
with them on that."
|
 |