Wireless: News and Alerts Update Services Free News Headlines Live Radio Streaming CBC Newscasts


VIEWPOINT: PETER HADZIPETROS: BACK OF THE PACKIt's all a matter of scale
Peter Hadzipetros

The pace of spring training is picking up steam. Exhibition season is about to hit full stride.

In this neck of Ontario, there are half marathons in Grimsby, Peterborough and Burlington within the next couple of weeks. At this stage in spring marathon preparations, a half marathon offers a chance to see where you are in your training plan.

If everything's going well, you should finish about 10 minutes quicker than half your marathon time. That's what I'm shooting for in this first outing in the 2005 exhibition season. It means I'll have to shave some time off my previous best half marathon time.

Getting there isn't easy. Until now, I've found the simplest way to get faster is to drop a few pounds. You'd think that averaging 100 kilometres a week in training would lighten the load on the scale and do wonders for the waistline.

My daughter seemed to think so. I was getting dinner ready the other night when she remarked how my pants looked to be a fair bit looser – pants that were under the Christmas tree just two months ago. They weren't exactly snug back then, but they wouldn't have been my first choice had I been planning an excursion to the buffet.

"They do feel looser," I told her, as I prepared to take down a wildebeest. "But the scale's telling me a different story."

Generally, I don't pay much attention to scales – they're all rigged anyway – but I do like to see where I'm at every once in a while. Usually at the beginning of a training cycle, halfway through it, and maybe at the end.

Seems no matter how many kilometres I put in, my weight has settled in on a favourite number. One hundred and eighty-two.

I haven't just plateaued – it seems I've parked the RV, built a patio and a shed, hung lanterns and made nice with the neighbours.

Granted, 182 is about 25 pounds south of where I was when I started this running stuff, but it's still more of me than I care to carry around right now. And according to the folks at Health Canada, it's a lot more than what I should weigh.

See, I'm only 5'8" (5'11" when I pull out the Manolo Blahniks the odd Saturday night).

With those numbers, I have a body mass index (BMI) of 27.7, which classifies me as overweight – more than halfway between Normal and Obese Class I. The BMI says I'm at increased risk of health problems should I ever age.

(You can figure out your own BMI by dividing your weight in kilograms by your height squared, or go to their calculator at: http://www.hc-sc.gc.ca/hpfb-dgpsa/onpp-bppn/bmi_chart_java_e.html and let them do the math)

Health Canada claims the BMI is just a guide – and may not be accurate if you're under 18 years old or pregnant and lactating. Last I checked I didn't quite qualify under either category.

But wait – there's more fine print:

"Very muscular adults, such as athletes, may have a low percentage of body fat but a large amount of muscle tissue. This can result in a BMI in the overweight range which may over estimate the risk of developing health problems."

Waist circumference also has to be taken into account. If it's 40 inches or better around your waist, trouble could be looming. I peaked at 38 but am down to 34 these days.

So maybe I'm all right overall, even with a high BMI. Still, a high BMI eventually limits how fast you can go. Blame physics. It takes a lot more energy to move a 182-pound body over 26.2 miles than a 130-pound body. And there's only so much energy the body can store.

According to the BMI chart, I need to drop another 18 pounds to be normal, weight-wise anyway. Not sure I'm prepared to give up that much wildebeest – or add that much mileage – just to call myself normal.


LETTERS | Email Peter

First of all, I am really enjoying reading your articles.

As a recently re-born runner, and someone on his quest for his first marathon this spring, I too am tired of the BMI index.

I am a former football player with a BMI that hovers around 30 ... a number which makes me obese (5' 11", 205). My waist is 36".

I think they need to adjust the BMI, as it clearly inflates the obesity statistics and I want to feel "normal" again, or at least have a guide that is reflective of the many different body types.

I run around 50k a week and play hockey twice. My VO2 max is in the top one percent of 40-year-olds. I know I am not at significant risk of heart disease, as my doctor has confirmed.

Just thought I would drop you a note to voice my agreement with your article.

Conrad J. Mandala
Toronto

Jobs | Contact Us | Permissions | Help | RSS | Advertise
Terms of Use | Privacy | Ombudsman | CBC: Get the Facts | Other Policies
Copyright © CBC 2012


Mar. 9, 2005
It's like meeting Oprah, only sweatier
Feb. 23, 2005
It's all a matter of scale
Feb. 12, 2005
Tuning in to spring training
Jan. 12, 2005
New year, same old woes?
Nov. 30, 2004
It's in the genes
Oct. 21, 2004
Here we go again
Oct. 6, 2004
That time of year
Sept. 16, 2004
5 k's of hell
Sept. 1, 2004
It'll take more than money
July 27, 2004
In the Summertime
May 25, 2004
Odds and Ends
May 12, 2004
There's no place like home
May 3, 2004
Running for a reason
April 21, 2004
Peter beats Boston heat
April 14, 2004
Tying up loose ends
April 7, 2004
The healing power of -- coffee?
March 18, 2004
The winter of my discontent
March 5, 2004
But we already have the preciousssss
Feb. 16, 2004
The inner wimp
Jan. 29, 2004
The resolution shuffle
Jan. 9, 2004
Beware of Greeks driving cabs
Dec. 31, 2003
Not going for the gold
Dec. 11, 2003
Athens gets ready
Nov. 26, 2003
Athens a smokers paradise

ABOUT PETER
Peter Hadzipetros writes background and indepth features for CBC News Online. Until he got into long distance running a few years ago, he was a net importer of calories. He's run several marathons, including two Bostons. In Oct. 2004, he recorded a PB of 3:09.21 in Columbus.