Keep your arms down, defenders
January 4, 2010 12:07 PM | Posted by John MolinaroIt's a familiar scene on the soccer field, one you've probably witnessed a million times:
A cross gets whipped into the middle of the box from the wing, a mad goal-mouth scramble ensues and the ball eventually lands at the feet of an opportunistic striker who pokes it past the goalkeeper and into the back of the net.
While the forward celebrates, the defenders partake in what has becoming one of the most annoying rituals in the modern game: shooting their arms in the air in unison in a desperate plea to convince the assistant referee that the player was offside and the goal should not be allowed to stand.
Every defender has done it at one time another, from the lowliest hoofer trying to make a living in England's League Two, to players the calibre of Carlos Puyol, John Terry and Fabio Cannavaro. It happens at least once in almost every game and has become as much a part of the game as diving.
And it has to stop.
Players are often taken to task for trying to convince the referee to show an opponent a yellow card after they’ve suffered a foul. In particular, players who brandish an imaginary yellow card in an attempt to get another player booked are viewed as morally reprehensible, and the argument has been made that they should be the one who gets cautioned for their un-sportsmanlike actions.
Once we get that rule on the books (let's hope the International Football Association Board, soccer's official rule-making body, makes it happen within the next year) it would make sense to book players who insist perfectly legitimate goals should be negated.
That's not to suggest that players should not have any recourse when they honestly think a goal was scored in an offside position - that should be left to the captain to pursue with the officials. But this routine that defenders have of jetting their arms in the air as soon as the ball crosses the line and looking at the ref with a hopeful plea after a perfectly legitimate goal is shameful.
Such an act is not only cowardly, but it's also a deliberate attempt to con the referee and as such, it must be dealt with in the same manner that officials deal with simulation.
Follow John Molinaro on Twitter at: http://twitter.com/JohnMolinaro
About the Author
John Molinaro
John F. Molinaro is a reporter for CBCSports.ca whose chief love is soccer.
John served as senior editor of CBC's 2007 FIFA U-20 World Cup website and was the driving force behind our coverage of the 2006 FIFA World Cup. His work on CBC Sports Online's Euro 2004 site earned him a CBC.ca Award of Excellence.
He holds an honours BA in sociology from York University and a print journalism diploma from Sheridan College.
Categories
- Hockey (462)
-
- Bob Cole (2)
- Cassie Campbell (34)
- Craig Simpson (36)
- Elliotte Friedman (83)
- Glenn Healy (6)
- Guy Carbonneau (13)
- Jeff Marek (37)
- Jennifer Botterill (3)
- Jim Hughson (33)
- Kelly Hrudey (33)
- Kevin Weekes (11)
- Marc Crawford (18)
- Mike Milbury (30)
- PJ Stock (19)
- Scott Morrison (66)
- Trade Deadline (25)
- Soccer (220)
-
- Greg Sutton (6)
- Jason de Vos (64)
- John Molinaro (69)
- Nigel Reed (72)
- Ron Kuipers (8)
- Baseball (1)
-
- Jesse Barfield (1)
- Basketball (26)
-
- Paul Jay (26)
- Amateur Sports (71)
-
- Scott Russell (72)
- Curling (4)
-
- Kevin Martin (3)
- Figure Skating (43)
-
- Pj Kwong (40)
- Scott Russell (6)
- Aerial Skiing (4)
-
- Veronika Bauer (4)
- Alpine Skiing (16)
-
- Britt Janyk (1)
- Kelly VanderBeek (15)
- Bobsleigh (13)
-
- Heather Moyse (13)
- Boxing (44)
-
- Chris Iorfida (44)
- Football
-
- Short Track (14)
-
- Jessica Gregg (14)
- Sports (1)
-
- Rowing (5)
-
- Kevin Light (5)
- Snowboarding (9)
-
- Katie Tsuyuki (9)
- Mixed Martial Arts (2)
-
- Jeff Marek (2)
- Badminton (6)
-
- Anna Rice (6)
- Paralympics (3)
-
- Matt Hallat (3)
- Authors (14)
-
- Anna Rice (6)
- Bob Cole (2)
- Britt Janyk (1)
- Cassie Campbell (32)
- Chris Iorfida (40)
- Craig Simpson (36)
- Elliotte Friedman (79)
- Glenn Healy (6)
- Greg Sutton (6)
- Guy Carbonneau (13)
- Heather Moyse (13)
- Jason de Vos (58)
- Jeff Marek (38)
- Jennifer Botterill (3)
- Jesse Barfield (1)
- Jessica Gregg (14)
- Jim Hughson (30)
- John Molinaro (48)
- Katie Tsuyuki (7)
- Kelly Hrudey (32)
- Kelly VanderBeek (14)
- Kevin Light (5)
- Kevin Martin (3)
- Kevin Weekes (10)
- Marc Crawford (18)
- Matt Hallat (3)
- Mike Milbury (30)
- Nigel Reed (67)
- P.J. Stock (19)
- Paul Jay (26)
- Pj Kwong (36)
- Ron Kuipers (4)
- Scott Morrison (62)
- Scott Morrison - My Greatest Day (10)
- Scott Russell (72)
- Veronika Bauer (4)
Recent Post
- Carl Robinson deserved a proper send-off from TFC
- Monday, March 8, 2010
- Getting serious about headshots starts now
- Monday, March 8, 2010
- Winning formula determined by trades, team philosophy
- Monday, March 8, 2010
- Five questions: Montreal’s relative deadline inactivity, Olympic hangover
- Sunday, March 7, 2010
- Olympics reinforce value of talented defenceman
- Friday, March 5, 2010
Archives
- March 2010 (12)
- February 2010 (33)
- January 2010 (51)
- December 2009 (60)
- November 2009 (74)
- October 2009 (65)
- September 2009 (53)
- August 2009 (26)
- July 2009 (35)
- June 2009 (48)
- May 2009 (27)
- April 2009 (40)
- March 2009 (79)
- February 2009 (70)
- January 2009 (64)
- December 2008 (58)
- November 2008 (71)
- October 2008 (71)
- September 2008 (5)


