Bernie Ecclestone to pay $100M US to settle bribery case
Ex-F1 boss was charged with bribery, incitement to breach of trust
A German court on Tuesday dropped the bribery case against Bernie Ecclestone after the Formula One chief agreed to make a $100 million US payment, ending a trial that lasted more than three months.
The Munich state court announced its decision to drop proceedings against the 83-year-old Ecclestone hours after prosecutors said they had agreed to the move. Ecclestone is now free to concentrate on running the global racing series.
Ecclestone went on trial in late April on charges of bribery and incitement to breach of trust, which can carry a sentence of up to 10 years in prison.
After hearing evidence since late April, "the court did not consider a conviction overwhelmingly likely," court spokeswoman Andrea Titz said.
With Tuesday's decision, "there was no conclusion on guilt or innocence of the defendant," she said. "He is leaving this courtroom a free man."
"Bye-bye," Ecclestone said to reporters as he left the court, adding he was off "to take care of Formula One."
Later, Ecclestone said he was "a bit of an idiot" for agreeing to the huge settlement as he believes he would probably have been acquitted had the trial continued.
"Anyway, it's done and finished, so it's all right," he told Britain's Press Association. "I'm contented. It's all fine. This now allows me to do what I do best, which is running F1."
The charges involved a $44 million payment to German banker Gerhard Gribkowsky, who is serving an 8 1/2-year sentence for taking the money. Gribkowsky was convicted of corruption, tax evasion and breach of trust in a trial led by the same judge who heard Ecclestone's case, Peter Noll.
Ecclestone denied wrongdoing and contends that Gribkowsky, who was in charge of selling German bank BayernLB's 47 per cent stake in F1 in 2005, blackmailed him. The court said it seriously doubted that bribery could be proven.
Prosecutors alleged that the payment was meant to facilitate the sale of Munich-based bank Bayern LB's stake in Formula One to a buyer of Ecclestone's liking. Still, the court noted in Tuesday's decision that witness testimony suggested that the sale of the stake to CVC Capital Partners was "an unexpectedly profitable deal" for the bank.
Defence lawyer Sven Thomas welcomed the court's decision and said it showed that there would have been a "clear option of acquittal" had the trial continued, news agency dpa reported.
"I have the feeling he is relieved," Thomas said of Ecclestone.
The defense last week called for proceedings to be dropped, using a provision in German law that allows for prosecutors to drop a case in exchange for conditions such as a fine or community work, so long as the gravity of a possible offense is sufficiently small. The $100 million figure emerged from talks with prosecutors over recent days.
Such deals are common in Germany though they rarely involve anything near the amount Ecclestone will pay. The $100 million is believed to be a record for such a payment.
Noll, the judge, stressed that the size of the payment took into account the assets of the defendant, and said Ecclestone had given assurances that the $100 million represented "an appreciable portion" of his wealth without overburdening him. According to Forbes magazine, Ecclestone and his family are worth $4.2 billion.
Most of the payment, $99 million, will go to the German state. The remaining $1 million will go to a German organization that helps terminally ill children. Ecclestone has a week to pay up.
"In the end what has happened today is good and bad," Ecclestone told the Press Association. "The good is the judge more or less said I was acquitted, and they (the prosecution) really didn't have a case. So I was a bit of an idiot to do what I did to settle because it wasn't with the judge, it was with the prosecutors."
According to Forbes magazine, Ecclestone and his family are worth $4.2 billion. Noll, however, said after examining documents on his assets, that Ecclestone isn't a billionaire, dpa reported.
A former German justice minister criticized the deal as it took shape ahead of Tuesday's decision, saying that the scale of it didn't fit with the spirit of the law.
"In my eyes, there should not be negotiations in this dimension with justice," Sabine Leutheusser-Schnarrenberger told Deutschlandfunk radio Monday. "It doesn't just leave a bad taste, it is really barefaced cheek."