For all of his home runs, all-star accolades and huge salaries, Alex Rodriguez finds himself in a most familiar spot this season.
A-Rod is an October lightning rod.
With every swing and miss, memories of his amazing run during the New York Yankees' championship season in 2009 fade even further. Instead, fans are becoming more and more vocal, calling for manager Joe Girardi to drop him from the No. 3 spot in the lineup.
Rodriguez struck out to end the Yankees' 3-2 loss to the Baltimore Orioles in Game 2 of their American League Division Series Monday night, leaving the best-of-five matchup tied 1-1.
He's fanned plenty of times, five in all while going 1-for-9 so far in the series.
"I feel fine at the plate," Rodriguez said after the loss. "I've just got to finish at-bats. I'm getting good swings."
He'll have the chance to turn things around Wednesday when the series shifts to the Bronx for Game 3 (7:30 p.m. ET). Hiroki Kuroda (16-11) starts for New York against Miguel Gonzalez (9-4), a rookie right-hander who has 17 strikeouts in 13 2/3 innings against the Yankees in two starts.
After their train experienced an electrical outage after the loss Monday and turned a usual two-hour 15-minute trip to New York into a five-hour journey, manager Joe Girardi was reluctant to address the Yankees' more pressing power problem Tuesday.
"I think that we're going to do whatever it takes to win this three-game series. Nothing that we do will be something that is just a knee-jerk reaction," Girardi said. "The great thing about this is I have a great group of guys that's very unselfish, and they really want to win. And that's what we're going to do, what we think is best to win."
Always protective of his players, Girardi might be choosing to coddle Rodriguez after watching Joe Torre cause a stir in 2006 by dropping the 14-time all-star to eighth in the Yankees order against the Detroit Tigers in the first round.
"Sometimes it's just not as easy as just writing a name or taking a guy out, a pitcher out. You have to think about the emotional part," Girardi said. "You always have to think about that as a manager."
A big fan of the numbers, all collated in his ever-present binder, Girardi need not look too deep to see that the 37-year-old Rodriguez is not the same player that has amassed 647 homers, fewer than only Willie Mays, Babe Ruth, Hank Aaron and Barry Bonds.
The third baseman hit only 18 home runs and had a .430 slugging percentage while driving in just 57 runs in 122 games this season, exclusively batting third or fourth for the team that scored the second most runs in the majors with 804.
Rodriguez went a startling 67 at-bats in September without an extra-base hit shortly after returning from a broken left hand. Robinson Cano, who had an RBI double Monday, had nine straight multi-hit games to finish the season, hitting .615 over that stretch, and many fans want to see him hit in the No. 3 slot.
Granted, Rodriguez is not the only player that's nearly Oh-for-October. Baltimore's Adam Jones is 1-for-8, Washington's Bryce Harper is 1-for-10 and Detroit's Prince Fielder is 1-for-8, but the Tigers are up 2-0.
But none of those stars have as much history as the three-time MVP, either. The highest-paid player in baseball with a contract that can exceed $300 million US and has five years remaining, A-list girlfriends, a gossip page fixture.
Ending the Yankees' last two trips to the playoffs with whiffs doesn't help — Game 6 in 2010 AL Championship Series with a caught looking and a swinging strike three against the Tigers last year in the first round. He also hasn't homered in the post-season since hitting six in 2009, but he's fanned 17 times.
Overall, Rodriguez is a career .271 hitter in the post-season with 13 homers and 41 runs batted in since making his first playoff appearance in 1995 with Seattle. He is a career .300 hitter in the regular season with 1,950 RBIs.
But Girardi insisted he likes what he sees from Rodriguez. He hit a sharp liner that Baltimore second baseman Robert Andino stopped with a dive and singled before striking out twice as the Yankees tried to rally.
"He squared up two balls," Girardi said. "You look at the ball he hit in the first inning, he squared it up. And then he had the other hard single. Right now I don't have any plans to make any changes."
Rodriguez isn't the only one struggling for the Yankees against the Orioles solid pitching staff. New York went 2-for-8 with runners in scoring position and stranded 10 in Monday's loss.