Slumping Maple Leafs lacking fight | Hockey | CBC Sports

Hockey Night in CanadaSlumping Maple Leafs lacking fight

Posted: Thursday, January 9, 2014 | 10:41 PM

Back to accessibility links
Nine times this season the Toronto Maple Leafs have given up 40-plus shots and four times it has been 50-plus shots. (James Guillory/USA TODAY Sports/Reuters) Nine times this season the Toronto Maple Leafs have given up 40-plus shots and four times it has been 50-plus shots. (James Guillory/USA TODAY Sports/Reuters)

Beginning of Story Content

The Toronto Maple Leafs were embarrassed 6-1 by the Carolina Hurricanes on Thursday, consequently dropping out of a playoff spot. If Leafs general manager Dave Nonis is looking for a list of things he should be concerned about, he has plenty of options, writes Mike Brophy.

On the one-year anniversary of his appointment as general manager of the Toronto Maple Leafs, Dave Nonis finds himself painted into a corner.

One year on the job and a strong case could be made his work has just begun. If there is such a thing as a grace period in a new job, Nonis's is over.

His Maple Leafs made the playoffs last year for the first time in eight seasons and after a good start to this year, they have fallen on hard times. Despite locking up captain Dion Phaneuf and top scorer Phil Kessel on huge long-term deals, the Maple Leafs are now in jeopardy of missing the playoffs.

They were embarrassed 6-1 by the Hurricanes in Carolina on Thursday and consequently dropped out of a playoff spot. They will face the Capitals in Washington Friday night before hosting the New Jersey Devils at the Air Canada Centre Sunday night.

Toronto has now lost three games in a row since winning the Winter Classic in a shootout over the Detroit Red Wings Jan. 1 in Ann Arbor, Michigan.

If Nonis is looking for a list of things he should be concerned about, he has plenty of options.

It probably starts with suddenly poor goaltending, although of all his concerns, this might be the most temporary. James Reimer, who was pulled in two of his previous four starts, didn't receive much support from his teammates against the Hurricanes, but clearly continued to struggle regardless. His running mate, Jonathan Bernier, has also struggled of late.

Former Maple Leafs goalie Mike Palmateer, 59, who looked great in one of the alumni games in Ann Arbor, may get the start in Washington Friday.

Then there is leading scorer Phil Kessel going through one of his dry spells yet again. The streaky right-winger has scored goals in just two of Toronto's past 11 games. Kessel has three shots on goal against the Hurricanes, but no serious scoring chances. He was otherwise invisible.

There is also an eight-man defensive corps that seemingly can't defend. The Leafs get out-shot night after night. Nine times this season the Maple Leafs have given up 40-plus shots and four times it has been 50-plus shots. One defender the team gave up on, veteran John-Michael Liles, scored against them Thursday.

Perhaps Nonis's biggest concern should be his team's lack of compete. There is currently no fight in this team. They are being led by a coach who wants them to play a gritty game and they throw his instructions right back in his face. They are soft and passive.

Nonis is a patient man, but his boss, CEO and president Tim Leiweke is not. If Nonis isn't thinking about making a move or two to jump-start his team, the request to do so may come from above.

Download Flash Player to view this content.

Coach Carlyle cross

Following the game coach Carlyle appears to be growing more and more exasperated with his players. Asked what he'd like to see his team do differently in Washington Friday, he said, "The first thing we can do is move our feet because we stood around a lot tonight," Carlyle said. "For whatever reason we're doing things standing still and watching teams skate. We're not engaged in the hockey game to a level to give ourselves a chance. It seems like we just stand still and try to make plays and we don't skate. We're a step behind."

Strange decision

The Maple Leafs had trouble finding the net in Carolina one day after sending Peter Holland and his five goals (in 22 games) to the minors and replacing him with Carter Ashton who has no goals in 34 NHL games now. Carter is a hard worker, no question about it. He has 10 goals in his last 12 games with the AHL Marlies, but he can't find the net in the NHL. Against Carolina he played 3:42 on seven shifts and was minus-2.

Killer goal against

The Maple Leafs opened the third period trailing 4-1, but on the power play for 1:18. A power play goal might have given them new life. However, a shorthanded goal by Carolina's Jordan Staal put a dagger in them.

Lupul drops 'em

Veteran winger Joffrey Lupul tried to spark his team by engaging in a fight -- the fifth of his NHL career -- against Carolina's Justin Faulk in the third period. Probably a case of too little, too late.

Welcome back

Carolina welcomed back former Hurricane defenceman Tim Gleason who was traded to Toronto last week for fellow defender John-Michael Liles. Gleason was held out of the lineup against the New York Rangers, but made his Maple Leafs debut Tuesday in a loss to the New York Islanders.

Gleason had a hand in the first Hurricanes goal. A centering pass from behind the Toronto net bounced off his skate directly to Zach Boychuk who snapped a backhander past Maple leafs goalie James Reimer at 2:33 of the first period. Gleason had three shots and three hits in 18:12 ice time and took one minor penalty.

Liles, meanwhile, was plus-5 in his first three outings with the Hurricanes and then scored his first goal of the season against his old team. He was plus-2 on the night.

Clarkson returns

Right-winger David Clarkson missed the Islanders game with a bruised foot, but was back in action against Carolina. Clarkson seemed to be having trouble with his foot and missed part of the second period while having it attended to in the dressing room.

View from the press box: With the Maple Leafs carrying eight defencemen on the roster, Paul Ranger and Jake Gardiner were the odd men out. Carl Gunnarsson returned from an elbow injury and Mark Faser also played. Tough guy Frazer McLaren, a left-winger, also sat.

End of Story Content

Back to accessibility links

Story Social Media

End of Story Social Media

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Submission Policy

Note: The CBC does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. By submitting your comments, you acknowledge that CBC has the right to reproduce, broadcast and publicize those comments or any part thereof in any manner whatsoever. Please note that comments are moderated and published according to our submission guidelines.