| You could be forgiven for thinking the Battle of the Plains of Abraham was a done deal. After all, it took place in 1759. And during its course, the English forces led by General James Wolfe defeated the French forces of Louis-Joseph, Marquis de Montcalm on that famous Quebec site. So: that's it for that then. Except, of course, for the repercussions -- which continue to this day. Last week, we spoke with Horst Dresler, a Vermont man who is hoping to participate in a long-planned re-enactment of the battle. I say "hoping" because there is a chance the re-enactment may be cancelled, due to growing opposition by some Quebeckers. Meanwhile, Talkback obliged Mr. Dresler -- by contributing to the battle online. From Bishop's Mills, Ontario, Michael Whittaker wrote us this e-mail: "The majority of re-enactors who will participate in the Plains of Abraham re-enactment will be American. They have far less comprehension than most Canadians of the socio-political sensitivities in Quebec. That said, I know for a fact a few sovereigntists and nationalists will participate in the re-enactment. They accept the undeniable fact of history and are content to commemorate the fall of Quebec City." That was from Michael Whittaker in Bishop's Mills, Ontario. And Léon Robichaud -- an assistant professor in the Department of History at the University of Sherbrooke -- sent this to our inbox: "Historical recreation is a wonderful opportunity for the participants, and for the public, to discover history in a direct and personal manner. As a low-key event, previous recreations at the Plains of Abraham did not raise eyebrows. Billing it as the event of the year, as some promoters have done, to keep local tourism booming following last year's 400th anniversary, put it in the limelight and at the centre of a debate. "On Tuesday, authorities will decide to maintain or to cancel the recreation. Whatever their decision, hopefully everyone has realised that commemoration is not neutral. Serious thought has to be placed as to why we do it, and how we do it." |