I believe comments like those of John Hall (posted
below) are representative of the myths many people
believe are true for all First Nations in Canada
- i.e. they don't pay taxes, free university,
etc etc. All untrue.
Only aboriginals living and working on reserve
are tax exempt (and the on-reserve population
is a minority of First Nations people in Canada).
Bands are allocated only a small amount of
money to send high school graduates to university,
but this amount is far less than that required
to meet demand. Others are left to struggle
with debts and part-time jobs like other Canadians,
with the catch that most do not have the ability
to secure the bank loans that many Canadians
can so easily walk out of a bank with.
That said, the systematic discrimination against
First Nations, through economic manipulation,
going back more than a hundred years and continuing
today, is a major cause of poverty - not the
myths that continue to propagate in society.
Maybe CBC should take a good look at the history
and present of First Nations in Canada and
the UN reports damning our government, in order
to eliminate some of the myths and stereotypes
in society.
- Paul Cobb
Thanks
for having the courage to bring the issue of racism
and Aboriginal peoples to the forum for public
dialogue.
I believe in the goodness of Canadians - at
least I believe that reconciliation and a reduction
in racism is only possible once all Canadians
have solid information on the lived experience
of Aboriginal peoples in Canada and what was
lost to both Aboriginal and non Aboriginal Canadians
as result of colonization. Once Canadians know
- they have a choice about the type of life we
want to live and the example we want to set for
our children.
Too many Canadians think that history of this
land began when the Europeans arrived muting
the great histories and contributions of Aboriginal
peoples who have lived on these lands for at
least 10,000 years according to carbon dated
evidence. The gifts of Aboriginal peoples pervade
Canadian society - from our system of federalism
which was informed by the Iroquois Confederacy,
to many of the foods we enjoy (corn,turkey,pumpkin,
maple syrup), medicines that keep us well and
of course - the name of the country itself...
not to mention the land. The problem is that
too many Canadians remain unaware of these contributions
and thus think that Aboriginal people have only "taken" from
society and not given - and continue to give.
The other stereotype is that Aboriginal people
get more than the rest of Canadians. Whilst groups
such as the United Nations has repeatedly encouraged
Canada to redress the gap in life chances between
Aboriginal and non Aboriginal peoples (especially
children)- research indicates that too ofter
there continue to be significant gaps in services
and service access.
And as for the "get on with it" advice
offered by some - Aboriginal people are doing
that everyday - and we hope those offering this
sage advice will too - get on with educating
themselves and their families, get on with understanding
that respectful co-existance is work that belongs
to Aboriginal and non Aboriginal Canadians -
because it is about the kind of society we want
for all our children.
- Cindy Blackstock
While
I am a white woman, I was bullied as a child
because I was different (glasses, braces, you
name it). As a result, I found the documentary
to be extremely moving. I experienced my own "blue-eyes" situation
when I taught English in Japan for a year, and
I was one of a few Westerners in my town. I was
fortunate that I never ran into any trouble because
of my colour, but I was certainly forced to re-evaluate
my place in the world.
The most striking point
for me in the documentary was when the one aboriginal
man said "You
don't see me as an Indian, and I find that condescending".
It came as a big shock because we are now teaching
our children to be "colour-blind", because
we feel it's the right thing to
do. Maybe we need to change our teaching philosophy
- do not be colour-blind, be colour-aware.
- Beth Sneyd
Changes in society occur when HEARTS are changed
rather than just minds. Does not the recent outpouring
of compassion for the victims of the tsunami
illustrate this?
I found Ms Elliot's tactics appalling. Carrying out her crusade of ridicule and
belittlement of white males in Canadian society does nothing to change hearts
OR minds.
Hearing the stories of oppressed people changes hearts. The young woman who tearfully
described what it was like sending her children to school to face racism touches
my (white) mother's heart.The wounded survivor of a residential school touches
my own wounded soul. The soft spoken "elder" reflected peace and forgiveness
in his voice and thereby draws me into his world.
Ms Elliot may prove her point about racism in Canada but her method does little
to change it. What is this priviledged self appointed WHITE woman doing advocating
for a people whom SHE apparently presumes cannot do it for themselves? The aboriginals
who I heard speak on the show were very capable of making their own points.
Perhaps she needs to examine her OWN motives for this high handed and self righteous
mission she has assigned herself. I think if anyone is indecently exposed it
is Jane Elliot herself.
- Catherine Brown
Same old, same old :"the white man is the
root of all evil" nonsense. Perhaps if natives
want to be viewed in a better light by the wider
spectrum of Canadian society, they should be demanding
that their leaders stop playing the race card and
end the cult of victimology. Only when natives
stop pointing fingers at the outside world and
start looking in the mirror will they start to
progress as a culture.
For every crime that has been committed against
native Canadians, there is a perk which they
receive (and evidently take for granted) that
most other Canadians would kill for - free post-secondary
education, tax exemptions and easier access to
government jobs to name a few.
Its fine for natives to point the finger at
the white man for their problems, but with citizenship
comes responsibility. Maybe its time for natives
to do a better job of accepting theirs.
- John Hall
My husband was one of
the participants in the workshop and had his eyes
opened. Being a metis woman I think that everyone,
not just in Canada but everywhere, should see this
film. Thank you to the producer, Jane Elliott and
everyone else who had anything to do with this
film for helping get this message out.
-Stephanie
Reed
I tuned into "The Passionate Eye" with great interest, and while I
did learn a great deal about racism and ethnocentric views in our own country,
I felt that the program itself was poorly put together and much of the information
was contradictory and confusing.
So called "expert," Jane Elliott refered
to First Nations Canadians as "Indians," and suggested that the "blue
eyes" had to walk a mile in "the moccasins" of First Nations Peoples.
Moreover, It was suggested that many First Nations people feel that they want
to be treated equally. This suggestion was later contradicted when it was suggested
that First Nations peoples wish to be recognized as Native peoples of Canada
who are unique.
This made the show quite confusing and unclear as to what we
should do as Canadians to eliminate racism in our country. If there are no clear
guidelines or expectations, how do we act to rid our country of these racist
views?
- Ken Miles
I am First Nations, and I think this workshop is
a start. I am faced with these issues daily. I
work for a predominately "white" institution,
and sometimes I am made to feel like the "token
indian girl". One of these workshops would
be really great in an institution of "know
it alls". I was surprised about the attude
that came from the guy "who knew it all".
After hearing that , I thought to myself "that's
why there is racism".
There are so many people
that think they know when really instead of talking
they should be listening. I believe racism is the
lack of education and the willingness to accept
people for who they are and not what they are.
It's nice to see
these First Nations issues are being spoken about.
-Anna
Watching this workshop makes me think that as
a country we have a lot of work to do. I was
brought to tears watching this documentary because
I know that I have said or done things that have
been racist in some form or another. I honestly
thought that I was not 'like that'. I will listen
more and perhaps more importantly speak up when
I hear or see people saying or doing rascist
acts. Thank you for showing this documentary.
I can only hope that it will make a few people
change their ways in the future.
-Valerie Aucoin
I am Native, and proud. Watching this episode of
The Passionate Eye has changed my views.
Seeing
'Blue Eyes' act so stupidly, and the mandatory
need to have power opened my eyes. I have faced
racism all my life, and have even realized that
now, in my highschool, with the white kids growing
up in their schools being taught not to call us "Indians" but
to call us "Natives"..and that right
there shows that they need to be right. I realized
they want the power.
White people THINK they know what
its like... But they never walked a mile in my
mocccasins.
-Kristin Kewaquom