HomeRadioTelevisionLocal ContactSearchHelp
Ontario Votes 2003

Main > Features > Critical care > Romanow Prescription
Election Day: Oct. 2, 2003   

The Romanow Prescription and the Federal Cure
by Barry Brimbecom

In the 1990s, Canada's governments faced deficits that were ballooning out of control, causing fiscal angst and years of cost-cutting measures to bring spending in line. And of course, as the largest government expense, health care took its share of the whacking.

As federal health transfers started to wane, drug costs began to skyrocket, waiting lists became a national issue, Alberta introduced private diagnostic clinics, and hospital emergency rooms started to clog.

   Roy Romanow
Former Saskatchewan premier Roy Romanow.
In short, Canada's much-loved system of universal health care started ailing under the pressures of fiscal restraint. Provinces complained loudly that the federal government was shirking its responsibilities and was losing its moral authority to dictate how health should be delivered across the country.

In recent years, however, fiscal pressures have started dissipating as Canada's governments crawled out of the red. Money has become available to re-invest in health.

Federal and provincial governments are now facing the task of mapping a course to fix Canada's publicly administered health system. Does it need structural change? How much money is needed to live up to the Canada Health Act's principles of universality, comprehensiveness, portability between provinces, accessibility and public administration?

To tackle these questions, Prime Minister Jean Chretien commissioned former Saskatchewan premier Roy Romanow to consult Canadians and propose a remedy.

"Our most cherished national program is at a crossroads," Romanow said when he delivered his final report, Building on Values, in November 2002.

Saying that "the medicare house needs remodelling, not demolishing," Romanow called for:

  • a $15-billion increase in federal funding by 2006
  • home-care coverage
  • a limited drug insurance plan
  • a ban on extra billing for diagnostic services
  • accountability to taxpayers
  • private electronic health records
  • improved Aboriginal health care
  • support for the changing roles of health-care providers
  • a plan to promote preventative care.

But any major changes required agreement between the provinces and the federal government. So, at the start of February 2003, Canada's first ministers met to hammer out a new health agreement.

Ottawa took Romanow to heart, upping its health contributions by $16 billion over three years. It also offered $16 billion to establish a fund to reform primary care and home care, and for catastrophic drug coverage.

The provinces complained the federal offer fell short by at least $12 billion, but accepted the arrangement because they "felt it was important to put the interests of patients first," according to P.E.I. Premier Pat Binns.

Ontario Premier Ernie Eves also accused Ottawa of exaggerating its contribution, claiming the federal offer included some $3 billion that had already been committed under a previous deal.

The federal government responded by accusing the provinces of not accounting for how federal health transfers are spent.

Both disagreements over numbers flow from the complicated way the federal government distributes money through Canada Health and Social Transfer (CHST) payments. As implied by its name, the CHST bundles money for more than just health. It provides funding in cash and in tax credits, so breaking out absolute numbers is a difficult task and differs dramatically depending on whether you sit on the federal or provincial side of the fence.

It's widely acknowledged that the feds needed to put in more cash, but it's more of a mug's game when dealing with the tax credits. Some observers have noted that by dramatically cutting provincial income taxes, Ontario's entitlement to CHST tax credits has diminished, exacerbating the province's health funding crunch during the lean years.



Education Highlights

PC Health Platform               more
Create Ontario Health Quality Auditor to ensure funding is being spent wisely and tracking waiting times
Build more hospitals through public-private partnerships
Set guaranteed wait limits for general surgery, cataract surgery, cancer treatment, MRIs, and hip and knee replacement. Would provide out-of-province care if necessary to meet time limit
Provide 40 MRI machines and 50 CT scanners over five years

NDP Health Platform            more
Full and immediate implementation of Romanow recommendations
Create Patients' Bill of Rights and Health Care Standards Commissioner, ensuring health money "goes to patients, not tax cuts"
Stop expansion of private MRI and CT clinics, diverting funds to public system
Stop private-public partnerships the Tories are using to build hospitals
Extend universality to long-term and home-care sectors

Liberal Health Platform        more
Create independent agency to track delivery of medical services
Give provincial auditor the authority to audit all health-care agencies
Set limits for waiting times, starting with cardiac care, cancer care, joint replacements and MRI/CT scans
Invest in home care, taking first steps to follow recommendations of Romanow to make it an essential part of medicare

Riding Results Riding Results
See how the election played out across the province, in each riding.
more »

Reptilian Alien Alien Nation
The Tory campaign strategy was doomed from the start, writes Don Wanagas.
more »

This note's for you PC 2003:
The Musical

The reporters and the Tories serenade each other as the blue bus rolls on.
more »

Miss Kitten The cat came back
Julie Ireton observes as the now-infamous Tory news release returns as a juicy photo-op for the Liberals.
more »

Are you wealthy? Are you wealthy?
A quick look at some of the salaries earned by public servants, both "wealthy" and "not wealthy," according to Ernie Eves' criteria.
more »

Platform Promises Party Platforms
Compare the platform promises of the three main parties, point by point.
more »

Media Election Video and Audio
Daily archives of election video and audio in a variety of streaming formats from CBC Radio and CBC Television.
more »

Twenty Elections from the Archives
From the Big Blue Machine to Premier Bob, the Common Sense Revolution and beyond, CBC Archives looks back at nearly 20 turbulent years of Ontario elections.
more »

Student Vote 2003
Find out how more than 500,000 Ontario students will get into the habit of voting during this provincial election.
more >>

Terms of Use | Privacy | Copyright | Other Policies
Copyright © CBC 2003