The late Cory Monteith was known primarily for his high-profile role on TV's Glee. (Adam Rose/Fox/Associated Press)
In addition to its regular "In Memoriam" segment, Sunday's Emmy Awards will showcase a special tribute to late Canadian actor Cory Monteith — a move that has raised questions about whether the Glee star's brief but high-profile career is worthy of the honour.
Organizers of the U.S. TV honour revealed the special tributes — to Monteith as well as departed actors James Gandolfini, Jean Stapleton, Jonathan Winters and producer Gary David Goldberg — on Monday.
As news of the upcoming tribute spread, Variety's Andrew Wallenstein has sparked debate with a column questioning whether Monteith's inclusion in Sunday's special memorial is fitting.
"When Monteith's name is elevated alongside the other four people who are being elevated from the usual In Memoriam reel — actors James Gandolfini, Jean Stapleton and Jonathan Winters and writer-producer Gary David Goldberg — his inclusion risks coming across ill-considered. The unspoken, uncomfortable truth of the matter is that while the work he did on Glee showed great promise, it was not equal to the incredible careers the other four amassed," wrote Wallenstein, the industry publication's editor-in-chief of digital.
"[T]o merit special treatment like what the Academy is doing here, an actor should have a body of work that puts him head and shoulders above his peers. There will surely be disagreement from his ardent fans, but if Monteith had really achieved that status, those accolades would have been coming even before his death. Unlike many of his co-stars, Monteith never received an Emmy nomination," Wallenstein wrote.
"By putting Monteith in this elite group, the Academy is risking having its honorable intentions misconstrued as using the actor's memory to cater to the younger audiences that are in decreasingly short supply for award shows these days. The Emmy Awards is a business that requires generating TV ratings to maximize advertising dollars, but that needs to be balanced with the need for the Academy to maintain appropriate perspective in recognizing excellence and influence in television."
Wallenstein also noted that putting Monteith on this particular pedestal meant relegating dozens of others, including veteran actors like Dallas icon Larry Hagman, to the standard "In Memoriam" montage — an omission that others also noted online.
For Monteith's young fans, however, Sunday's posthumous tribute is absolutely deserved.
What do you think? Share your vote and your thoughts in the comment section below.
About the Author
Other The Buzz Entries
About the Authors
- 2014 (51)
- October (2)
- September (3)
- August (1)
- Watch the Mockingjay Trailer
- Is this the Christian Grey YOU envisioned?
- Celebrity lifestyle sites: Good or GOOP?
- FILM REVIEW: I Origins
- FILM REVIEW: Boyhood
- Goddess of Thunder? The new female Thor
- FILM REVIEW: Life Itself
- It's official: There's no shame in loving TV!
- Robin Thicke: Riding a wave of ick straight to the top of the charts?
- Eerie Hunger Games: Mockingjay - Part 1 trailer debuts
- Pearl Jam Let It Go tribute shows hit song's grown-up appeal
- Emma Stone, Andrew Garfield turn tables on paparazzi
- The fault in our reading habits: is it so bad that adults are fans of YA stories?
- Psy and Snoop's satirical Hangover soars online
- FILM REVIEW: Chef
- Stage interruptus: what to do when someone disrupts a live show?
- Aerosmith's Steven Tyler jams with Helsinki buskers
- May (4)
- The Simpsons exec teases upcoming death on show
- Power couple Jay Z and Beyoncé to tour together
- Deadmau5, king of Twitter beefs, takes on Arcade Fire
- Mrs. Doubtfire sequel in the works
- Pierce Brosnan says he 'was never good enough' at James Bond
- Game of Thrones: 7 anticipated match-ups and reunions in Season 4
- March (6)
- Oscars producers enlist celebs and pop stars to build buzz
- Gotcha! Jimmy Kimmel behind hoax Olympics wolf video
- Guardians of the Galaxy trailer unveils Marvel's misfit superhero team
- Olympic throwback: the history of art medals at the Games
- Lea Michele unveils Cory Monteith tribute song You're Mine
- Indie cyberpunk adventure game Jazzpunk debuts
- Remembering Philip Seymour Hoffman
- January (5)