Boycott Barilla, Dump Stoli: the value of hashtag-driven boycotts
The #dumpstoli campaign is one of the latest social media-spread boycotts. (Getty Images)
If you were among those who recently rejected Stolichnaya in favour of a non-Russian brand (say Crystal Head, distilled in Canada no less) to draw international attention to Russia's anti-gay legislation, you might want to think twice.
The campaign to "dump Russian vodka" seems, at first blush (possibly induced by a frozen shot) to be a catchy way of taking a stand. But ever since sex-and-relationships columnist Dan Savage began his #dumpstoli efforts on July 24, the campaign has been shaken and stirred by conflicting responses.
First, there is confusion over the provenance of Stolichnaya vodka. According to the New York Times, Stoli bottles are from Poland and Estonia, the caps from Italy, while blending and filtering takes place in Latvia. On the other hand, the alcohol is distilled from Russian grain and Yury Shefler, owner of the Riga factory that manufactures the stuff, is a wealthy Russian (One who reportedly risks arrest in Russia because he was accused of "stealing the Stolichnaya name").
That hasn't entirely stopped the #dumpstoli social media train though. Last week, producers of the critically acclaimed New York production of Russian-themed musical Natasha, Pierre and the Great Comet of 1812 nixed serving vodkas with "ties to Russia."
And while the famously frank singer Cher did not get on the #dumpstoli tweetwagon, she publicly turned down what she said was an invitation to perform and be "an ambassador" at the opening ceremony of the 2014 Olympic Winter Games in Sochi.
Then, along came Barilla Pastagate, kicked off when the chairman of the biggest pasta company in the world said his company wouldn't make a commercial featuring a homosexual couple. Next thing you know, #BoycottBarilla was trending. Celebrities took up the cause, with Mia Farrow going after both the issue and the pasta in one pithy #BoycottBarilla tweet
Now that we know pasta CEO G. Barilla is homophobic, it's a good day to say De Cecco is far better anyway #boycottbarilla— mia farrow (@MiaFarrow) September 27, 2013
But are these boycotts effective?
In terms of impact on Russia's treatment of its lesbian and gay community, one Russian politics scholar thinks choosing a non-Russian brand of vodka instead of Stoli is about as meaningful as changing one's profile picture on Facebook or sharing a YouTube video (Not to mention that it gives President Vladimir Putin a way to "portray the American boogeyman as intent on violating Russian sovereignty"). So far, Putin is apparently utterly unmoved by the #dumpstoli campaign.
However, on the other hand, just a day into #BoycottBarilla, the company chairman issued a kinda sorta apology.
You might draw the conclusion that these hashtag-driven boycotts can be as unpredictable as any form of hashtag publicity. (Remember Britain's Got Talent singer Susan Boyle's #susanalbumparty fiasco?) But the problem isn't the medium or the message. Whether or not a boycott works depends, in large part, on the recipient of the boycott.
"Activists seeking to create corporate change are partly dependent on the conditions of the company they're targeting," says the author of a study by Northwestern University's Kellogg School of Management .
"It has to be vulnerable to change to have any transformative effect...Companies with poor reputations to begin with are less vulnerable to boycotts because they have less to lose."
The same could be said to be true of countries. And Russia, it seems, doesn't feel it has a lot to lose.
-- by Li Robbins
More entries for category: Social Media
About the Author
Other The Buzz Entries
About the Authors
- 2013 (132)
- October (1)
- Boycott Barilla, Dump Stoli: the value of hashtag-driven boycotts
- Bidding farewell to Breaking Bad
- Music marathons: artistic endurance tests for the fleet-fingered
- Justin Bieber on Between Two Ferns
- Emmys 2013: the winners and losers
- FILM REVIEW: Enough Said
- Cory Monteith's Emmy tribute: is it deserved?
- TIFF 2013 favourites from Eli Glasner
- Miley Cyrus's Wrecking Ball: what do you make of it?
- Ylvis asks, 'What does the fox say?' in surprise viral video hit
- James Spader to play Ultron in Avengers sequel
- Céline Dion teases new single online
- TIFF films with the biggest buzz
- Kristin Chenoweth fan steals the show in impromptu duet
- Video game heroines reinterpreted by fashion illustrator
- Papers, Please is a nerve-racking game about a desk job
- Darren Young becomes WWE's first openly gay wrestler
- Canadians rock Oslo's Øya Fest
- FILM REVIEW: Blue Jasmine
- First look: David O. Russell's American Hustle trailer
- Al Pacino, as himself, for One Night Only
- FILM REVIEW: The Wolverine
- FILM REVIEW: Fruitvale Station
- ROM Game Jam to breathe new digital life into ancient cultures
- FILM REVIEW: Byzantium
- FILM REVIEW: The Hunt
- FILM REVIEW: Grown Ups 2
- FILM REVIEW: Pacific Rim
- FILM REVIEW: 20 Feet From Stardom
- FILM REVIEW: I'm So Excited
- FILM REVIEW: The Heat
- FILM REVIEW: World War Z
- An essential summertime song list
- FILM REVIEW: Frances Ha
- Beyond Tony Soprano: Remembering James Gandolfini
- Summer reading: top book choices from CBC Arts
- Jedward on the MMVA red carpet
- Film, TV tourism spikes with Game of Thrones, The Hobbit
- NXNE: a primer to the best of the Canadian music festival
- FILM REVIEW: Man of Steel
- FILM REVIEW: After Earth
- FILM REVIEW: Now You See Me
- Strombo chats up Craig Ferguson
- Khaled Hosseini's latest inspires digital Echo experience
- FILM REVIEWS: Fast and Furious 6, Epic and Picture Day
- FILM REVIEW: The Hangover Part 3
- Blake Shelton, Toby Keith boost benefits for Oklahoma
- Pushing Chinese stars beyond gimmicky roles
- Horror tale Haunting Melissa targets app audiences
- FILM REVIEW: Star Trek Into Darkness
- The return of Harmony Korine
- Michael Bublé gives surprise gig in NY subway
- Hot Docs: Pussy Riot: A Punk Prayer, High Five: An Adoption Saga
- Snoop Lion's Reincarnated wins over a skeptic
- At Coachella with Divine Fits' Dan Boeckner
- Can hip hop be a sustainable career for Canadian rappers?
- FILM REVIEW: Oblivion
- FILM REVIEW: My Awkward Sexual Adventure
- Buzz-worthy trailer for Man of Steel
- Hunger Games fans get a taste of Catching Fire
- FILM REVIEW: Emperor
- FILM REVIEW: G.I. Joe: Retaliation
- Canadian bands provide the warmth as CMW ends
- Jim Carrey skewers gun lobby with Cold Dead Hand
- Canadian Music Week: The unpretentious, the unenchanting and the unforgettable
- FILM REVIEW: The Croods
- Jay Leno's job on the line as late night TV wars resume
- Sam Roberts, Sarah Slean in NY Sandy fundraiser
- Justin Timberlake returns too late, the thrill is gone
- Selena Gomez's misstep on the Bieber file
- Canada's Stella Sisters sing a birthday tribute to the Man in Black
- Oscar swag the ultimate consolation prize
- Oscar predictions: the shoo-ins and the should-have-beens
- Authors bare all for PEN Canada
- Anoushka Shankar and the One Billion Rising campaign
- Beyoncé's Life Is But a Dream a curated peek behind the curtain
- Drake gets wild in the street over Grammy win
- 25 billion songs downloaded on iTunes, and counting
- CBC Music's Searchlight seeks best new artist
- 6 bone-crushing football films
- FILM REVIEW: Warm Bodies
- Justin Timberlake's musical comeback
- Argo moves to the fore in Oscar best picture race
- FILM REVIEW: Hansel & Gretel: Witch Hunters
- FILM REVIEW: Knife Fight
- FILM REVIEW: Parker
- Kroll Show parodies Degrassi with "Wheels, Ontario"
- FILM REVIEW: The Last Stand
- FILM REVIEW: Gangster Squad