In Depth


Campbell commission: Spring of Fear

Last Updated January 10, 2007


The SARS commission chaired by Ontario Justice Archie Campbell was appointed by the province in 2003 to examine how its health system handled the crisis, which killed 44 people in the Toronto area and struck down more than 330 others with serious lung disease.

In his third and final report, released on Jan. 9, Campbell said the outbreaks were likely not preventable, but more could have been done to protect the safety of health-care workers. Campbell based his findings in the 1,204-page report, called Spring of Fear, on public hearings, government and hospital documents and confidential interviews with more than 600 people connected to the SARS outbreaks.

"If the commission has one single take-home message, it is the precautionary principle that safety comes first, that reasonable efforts to reduce risk need not await scientific proof. Ontario needs to enshrine this principle and to enforce it throughout our entire health system," the report concluded.

"When it comes to worker safety in hospitals, we should not be driven by the scientific dogma of yesterday or even the scientific dogma of today … Until this precautionary principle is fully recognized, mandated and enforced in Ontario hospitals, workers will continue to be at risk."

The lesson of SARS is that governments and health-care systems need to be ready for the unforeseen, according to the report.

Campbell found no scapegoats, but rather a system failure, including poor preparation for dealing with infectious disease, a decline of public health, and a failure to protect nurses and paramedics because of a lack of resources under provincial governments of all political stripes. He also said that citizens of Ontario failed themselves by not insisting that governments provide better protection.

"The only thing that saved us from a worse disaster was the courage and sacrifice and personal initiative of those who stepped up — the nurses, the doctors, the paramedics and all the others — sometimes at great personal risk, to get us through a crisis that should never have happened. Underlying all their work was the magnificent response of the public at large: patient, co-operative, supportive."

Systemic problems ran "like steel threads through all of SARS," the report said, through all hospitals and government agencies in the province. The problems identified in the report include:

  • Poor internal and external communications.
  • Problems with preparation and planning for an outbreak of a virulent disease.
  • Accountability issues: who is in charge and who does what.
  • Problems with worker and patient safety.
  • Infection control, surveillance and lack of independent safety inspections.
  • Resource problems including people, money, laboratories and infrastructure.
  • A lack of the application of the precautionary principle that action to reduce risk should not wait for scientific certainty.

Two nurses and a doctor died from SARS, and 72 per cent of those infected in Ontario contracted the virus in a health-care setting, the report said. It called hospitals dangerous workplaces, like mines and factories, that lack the basic safety culture and systems that are expected and accepted in other workplaces and in British Columbia's hospitals.

The workplace regulator moved more quickly in B.C. than in Ontario to inspect hospitals during the outbreak, to ensure workers were protected as required by law. British Columbia was spared the devastation that Ontario experienced, in part because B.C. showed a greater commitment to applying the precautionary principle, Campbell concluded.

Hospitals in Ontario also failed to apply the precautionary principle in using N95 respirators to protect nurses, the report said. "It is no wonder that health workers became alarmed when they saw their colleagues sicken and die. It is no wonder that they became angry when they saw such incidents recur again and again with no apparent improvement in their safety."

Campbell's first interim report, in April 2004, addressed problems of public health infrastructure in Ontario and recommended changes to improve safety. The second interim report, in April 2005, addressed deficiencies in the province's health protection and emergency response laws and suggested how to correct them.

Since then, the Ontario government has taken steps to improve protection from infectious diseases, such as improving hospital practices, disease surveillance and provincial public health and emergency legislation.

In response to the final report, Ontario Labour Minister Steve Peters said his ministry won't be shut out in a future health care crisis. Occupational health and safety committees in hospitals and other health-care facilities now bring nurses and managers together to recommend safety improvements. The pandemic advisory working groups also include labour representatives.

Health-care workers will also be trained on the use of N95 respirators, and more will be available in hospitals as Campbell recommended, Peters said.

Campbell's report suggests five of the commission's 25 recommendations over the last two years have been accepted, such as compensating people who are quarantined for lost wages.

The Testimony

The SARS commission held public hearings in Toronto in late 2003 as part of its inquiry into the outbreak in Ontario.

The following are highlights from that testimony. Full transcripts are online at the commission's website.

From September 29, 2003

The first day of testimony was marked by calls for the Ontario government to develop a plan for infectious disease control. The Ontario College of Family Physicians and Family Physicians Toronto called for a "general" to run future crises, saying there were too many lieutenants, and not one central commander.

SARS Barb Wahl

"Ontario is now no more prepared for the outbreak of an infectious disease like SARS than it was last March or June. In fact, in some ways, we are worse off. We're still not clear on what protocols need to be followed to prevent the spread of SARS and to protect front-line nurses when they care for infected patients. Tensions remain between those who know we must proactively advocate for safety and those who are content to sit back and react once illness reappears. Being proactive is crucial. A reactive approach costs lives."
- Barb Wahl, president of the Ontario Nurses' Association.

"Clearly we have become complacent. As we prepare for SARS III or whatever new and potentially devastating disease is around the corner, there's a feeling that nothing has changed. While a fair amount of work is being undertaken including preparation of new community guidelines behind the scenes, family doctors have been left to feel that there is no comprehensive plan for the next time; a plan that will allow us to be proactive and reactive. � If we continue to be complacent and we wait until a crisis is upon us, it will be too late. The time for action is now."
- Dr. Yoel Abells, chair of Family Physicians Toronto.

"We were frustrated by our limited involvement in the decision-making processes at an operational level during the SARS outbreak. � We recommend that in future any policy framework developed should involve those individuals or stakeholder groups with specific expertise in developing practical and workable policies and guidelines in their affected areas from the beginning of the process."
- Dr. Larry Erlick, president of the Ontario Medical Association, arguing that doctors needed more interaction and influence with decision makers.

September 30, 2003

"Many of the lessons learned from SARS are being implemented right now and we are better prepared to deal with SARS if it should happen again; better positioned to handle new infections or new permutations of existing diseases. We have already made significant changes based on the knowledge gained from SARS."
- Hugh MacLeod, assistant deputy minister, acute services division, Ontario Ministry of Health and Long-term Care.

"My concerns are, fundamentally, that we failed to take the measure of SARS. We failed to understand what it was about and we did that because we didn't put sufficient emphasis on data collection, data analysis and learning about the infection. Second of all, I'm concerned that we spent a lot of time on unnecessary, unhelpful and harmful intervention."
- Dr. Richard Schabas, chief of staff at York Central Hospital, formerly the chief medical officer of health for Ontario.

"It's a crisis, and in a crisis it's disordered. The idea of an emergency, in fact, is to return order to a situation that is not orderly. Crises are not happy times for people who like order in their lives."
- Dr. James Young, commissioner of public safety for Ontario.

October 1, 2003

"We were dealing with a disease that had no test, no diagnostic criteria for diagnosis, no idea of the clinic course and, at least at the outset, no treatment. The treatment that we had initially was found to be ineffective. No knowledge of disease transmission and no idea of the duration and infectivity. Pretty hard to develop any kind of coherent plan if we have that type of information."
- Dr. Brian Schwartz, of the Ontario SARS Scientific Advisory Committee.

"I assisted with the intubation of a patient with SARS and assisted with an intubation of another patient suspected to have SARS. It took phone calls to occupational health, infection control, our director, and human resources, and many more days of waiting before they would change their minds, recognize the reality of the situation and allow us to order the good masks."
- Keith Olimb, president of the College of Respiratory Therapists of Ontario.

November 17, 2003

"Why were health-care workers put at risk when we had information, we had processes in place indicating adequate protection needed to be taken and yet that information wasn't given to the nurses and other allied health professionals?"
- Barb Wahl, president of the ONA.

Go to the Top

Previous pages on SARS

Origin of the crisis

External Links

Spring of Fear, The SARS Commission

(Note: CBC does not endorse and is not responsible for the content of external sites - links will open in new window)

[an error occurred while processing this directive] [an error occurred while processing this directive]

World »

CBC Investigates Did the UN ignore warnings of ethnic cleansing of Rohingya in Myanmar? video
According to internal documents and sources consulted by CBC News, there are signs several UN figures and other international actors — including a key Canadian official — have been reticent to pressure Myanmar on the rights of Rohingya.
Analysis Nothing left to chance as 19th congress of Chinese Communist Party opens today
As the red curtain rises on this week's key meeting of China's rulers — the 19th Congress of the Communist Party — nothing is being left to chance. Large gatherings are banned and the internet is in virtual lockdown.
Kenya electoral head says fair election can't be guaranteed next week
The head of Kenya's election commission says he cannot guarantee next week's presidential election will be free and fair, citing interference from politicians and threats of violence against his colleagues.
more »

Canada »

'I should see your face, and you should see mine,' Quebec premier says of new religious neutrality law video
A new law that would effectively force Muslim women who wear a niqab or burka to uncover their faces to use public services is based on a principle "the vast majority of Canadians, and not just Quebecers" can agree on, Premier Philippe Couillard says.
Updated Volunteer Alberta crew member killed during Sask. firefighting efforts video
A volunteer firefighter who was helping fight wildfires that spread to Saskatchewan has been identified as the man who died Wednesday in a single-vehicle rollover near Burstall, Sask.
Live Gord Downie mourned in hometown of Kingston video
People in Kingston, Ont., are gathering Wednesday evening to remember Gord Downie, the hometown frontman of the Tragically Hip who died Tuesday night at the age of 53.
more »

Politics »

'We are less as a country': Politicians pay tribute to Gord Downie video
Politicians are paying tribute to Canadian icon Gord Downie following his death, praising him as a musical legend, loving man and strong advocate for reconciliation with Indigenous people.
Liberals continue tax change tour, narrow scope of passive-income measure video
Finance Minister Bill Morneau is continuing to pull and pluck away at his government’s controversial tax regime proposals, promising now to adjust the rules on passive income so only three per cent of the "most wealthy" privately owned corporations will have to pay higher taxes.
Jagmeet Singh hopeful Quebec's controversial Bill 62 will be overturned
Federal NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh says he’s “completely opposed” to Quebec’s new and controversial religious neutrality law that obliges citizens to uncover their faces while giving and receiving state service, but he’s confident the legislation will be challenged.
more »

Health »

Sorry - we can't find that page

Sorry, we can't find the page you requested.

  1. Please check the URL in the address bar, or ...
  2. Use the navigation links at left to explore our site, or ...
  3. Enter a term in the Quick Search box at top, or ...
  4. Visit our site map page

In a few moments, you will be taken to our site map page, which will help you find what you looking for.

more »

Arts & Entertainment»

Tragically Hip's Gord Downie dead at 53 video
Gord Downie, the Tragically Hip frontman who united a diverse array of music lovers with his commanding stage presence and Canadiana-laced lyrics, has died.
As It Happens That time Gord Downie sang Knockin' on Heaven's Door with a high school band in Fort Albany
When Braiden Metatawabin was 15 years old, he played lead guitar for Gord Downie in a high school gym in Fort Albany, Ont.
Quebec media star Eric Salvail on leave following sexual misconduct allegations
A popular Quebec media personality who is facing an array of sexual misconduct allegations took a leave from his professional activities Wednesday as employers and clients distanced themselves from him.
more »

Technology & Science »

Video Watch a human paraglide through a starling-filled sky video
Spanish paraglider Horacio Llorens flies with the 'Black Sun' - a biannual gathering of up to a million starlings that swoop together through the skies of Denmark.
Twitter vows to crack down on nude photos tweeted without consent
Twitter says it's making policy changes to crack down on sexual harassment, including 'creep shots' taken without consent. It will also target hate and tweets that glorify or condone violence.
Why seeing a star crash is a 'watershed moment in astrophysics'
Gravitational waves have led scientists to something they’ve never seen before — the collision of two exotic objects called neutron stars. Here are some amazing things about that discovery.
more »

Money »

Delta says it had no role in Airbus-Bombardier deal
Delta Air Lines Inc.'s chief executive says the carrier did not play a role in pushing an industry-changing deal between Airbus and Bombardier as a regulatory spat between the United States and Canada threatened the future of a Bombardier plane program.
CMHC stress tests show housing agency would withstand 'severe' shocks
The Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation has crunched numbers on the assumption that the economy could get rocked by any number of different calamities and come to the same conclusion: the corporation itself would be all right.
Dow Jones industrial average closes above 23,000 for 1st time
The Dow Jones industrial average closed above the 23,000 level for the first time on Wednesday, driven by a jump in IBM after the computing giant hinted at a return to revenue growth.
more »

Consumer Life »

Sorry - we can't find that page

Sorry, we can't find the page you requested.

  1. Please check the URL in the address bar, or ...
  2. Use the navigation links at left to explore our site, or ...
  3. Enter a term in the Quick Search box at top, or ...
  4. Visit our site map page

In a few moments, you will be taken to our site map page, which will help you find what you looking for.

more »

Sports »

[an error occurred while processing this directive]
Something familiar: Canadian athletes remember Gord Downie
As the country pays tribute to Gord Downie after his death, a few well-known Canadian athletes share their fond memories of the Tragically Hip frontman.
Video Gord Downie the hockey fan video
While Gord Downie will always be remembered as a musician, he also holds a special place in the hockey world. From the songs he wrote, to the games he attended, hockey was in Downie's DNA.
Video Remembering Gord Downie: Watch our Olympic montages set to Tragically Hip songs
As Canadians celebrate the late Gord Downie's life and accomplishments, here are CBC Sports' video montages from recent Olympic Games that were set to some of The Tragically Hip's most memorable songs.
more »

Diversions »

[an error occurred while processing this directive]
more »