What will Pope Benedict's retirement look like?
Vatican in 'uncharted waters' following Benedict's resignation
By Daniel Schwartz, CBC News
Posted: Feb 13, 2013 5:06 AM ET
Last Updated: Feb 26, 2013 11:26 AM ET
It has been more than seven centuries since a pope freely left the papacy, as Pope Benedict XVI has announced he will do on Feb. 28.
The Catholic Church sees itself as historically rooted, and while there are protocols for how the new pope will be chosen in a few weeks, history offers little guide in the case of a pope who decides to resign.
Pope Celestine V's abdication in 1294 was "the only one in papal history," writes John Julius Norwich in 2011 in Absolute Monarchs: A History of the Papacy.
Other historians may disagree but Celestine's biographer, Jon Sweeney, concurs.
"The only case in history is Celestine V in 1294, where a pope willingly and on his own accord resigned the papacy," the author of The Pope Who Quit: A True Medieval Tale of Mystery, Death, and Salvation, told CBC News by telephone from Evanston, Ill.
The resignation of Gregory XII in 1415 is often cited as the last abdication by a pope, but this is misleading and does not apply as a precedent for Benedict.
Gregory was one of three competing popes in the last years of the four decades-long leadership dispute within the church hierarchy known as the Western Schism. To end the split, the Council of Constance ordered the resignations of all three. Both Gregory and John XXIII agreed to resign, but another Pope Benedict, the thirteenth, refused and was then excommunicated.
(More than five centuries later, Angelo Giuseppe Roncalli also took the name John XXIII when he became pope in 1958.)
According to canon law
Sweeney says that the current Pope Benedict "resigned exactly in the way canon says you are supposed to do it." That canon law has its origins in Celestine's resignation.Pope Benedict told the cardinals he no longer has the strength to fulfil the duties of his office. (L'Osservatore Romano/Reuters)
"Because of the Pope's position as the supreme authority in the Church, Celestine declared that the Pope could freely resign, that it was permissible and that, because, as supreme authority, it did not have to be accepted by anyone," historian Donald Prudlo said in an interview with Vatican Radio.
"It just had to be freely manifested," he added, using the language of the current Code of Canon Law. That's what Benedict did before the cardinals on Monday.
Sweeney notes that the way Benedict resigned was "shockingly similar" to how Celestine resigned. They both read a statement to a gathering of cardinals and others, although Celestine was in Naples at the time. "It was a very similar statement," Sweeney adds.
In his resignation statement, Benedict only said that "With regard to myself, I wish to also devotedly serve the Holy Church of God in the future through a life dedicated to prayer."Vatican spokesman Father Federico Lombardi told reporters on Monday that when Pope Benedict's resignation becomes effective, he will move to Castel Gandolfo, a papal summer home, and after renovations, will reside at a monastery inside the Vatican. (Alessandro Bianchi/Reuters)
Vatican sources have offered tidbits of information about that future. Vatican spokesperson Federico Lombardi said that Benedict "will move to the Papal residence in Castel Gandolfo [24 kilometres south of Rome] when his resignation shall become effective." Once renovations to the monastery of cloistered nuns inside the Vatican are completed, Benedict will live there.
That will be quite different to what happened to Celestine after he resigned. Celestine's successor, Boniface VIII, who had both advocated for and manipulated Celestine to resign, "immediately realized that it's not in his interest to have another pope still alive and walking around, so he had him hunted down and imprisoned in a castle, where he died two years later," Sweeney says.
Celestine's desire had been to return to his earlier life as a hermit.
Since Celestine did not get the chance to have a public life after stepping down, there's little precedent there to guide the Vatican today. Lombardi did say that Benedict will not join the cardinals in choosing the next pope, most of whom he appointed. The rules state that a cardinal has to be under 80 years old to take part in the conclave, and Benedict is 85.
The Vatican announced on Feb. 26 that Benedict will be known as "emeritus pope" and also keep the title of "His Holiness," a decision Benedict himself made.
Before becoming Pope, Benedict was Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger. Since his resignation, Vatican-watchers wondered whether he would return to that name or retain the title of "Pope" in some form.
It was also announced that Benedict will continue to wear his white cassock. Since the announcement of his plan to resign, many Vatican officials ventured to guess that in order to avoid confusion with the future pontiff, Benedict would wear the more traditional black robes of a cleric and use the title "emeritus bishop of Rome."Author Jon Sweeney says that after Pope Benedict resigns, he 'can't imagine we will see any more of him.'
"We lack a law, so far, on the status of a former pope, of someone who resigned the papacy," Msgr. David-Maria Jaeger, a professor of canon law at Rome’s Pontifical University Antonianum, told Vatican Radio.
"It is possible either Benedict XVI in the next few days, or his successor, will make such a law," Jaeger added, noting that "we are in uncharted waters."
Yiftach Fehige, an associate professor at St. Michael's College at the University of Toronto, tells CBC News that Benedict, "remains a retired archbishop with the title of cardinal, and will live a life accordingly."
After Benedict's successor is chosen, Sweeney expects "we will never hear from him again."
"I think he's going to retire to Bavaria or to a monastery, and he's going to be just very quietly out of the way, and I can't imagine we will see any more of him. Otherwise, it will get very confusing and I would imagine it will become troublesome."
However, Benedict has chosen not to leave the Vatican. He will still very much be a presence in the city state, with his new home right beside Vatican Radio.
While the Vatican monastery that will become his place of residence undergoes renovations, Benedict will live at Castel Gandolfo — the papal summer home, located 24 kilometres south of Rome.
A surprise and not a surprise
Benedict's announcement took the world by surprise, but a year ago this week, Sweeney wrote a column for The Huffington Post under the headline, "Would Pope Benedict XVI Ever Quit?"
When asked by CBC News, Sweeney said the column was merely a product of what he was seeing and hearing at the time.
As John Paul II 's right-hand man, Benedict has witnessed up-close the physical decline of John Paul II in his last years as pontiff. After he took over the papacy, Benedict had clearly stated, in 2010, that a pope could resign if he "clearly realizes that he is no longer physically, psychologically, and spiritually capable of handling the duties of his office."
In his resignation letter, Benedict says that to be pope, "both strength of mind and body are necessary, strength which in the last few months, has deteriorated in me to the extent that I have had to recognize my incapacity to adequately fulfill the ministry entrusted to me."
Brian Flanagan, an American theology professor, argues in his blog that the precedent that Benedict has now set "may well be his greatest gift to the church." It opens the door to future papal resignations before physical incapacity sets in, and he also says "it helps restore our understanding of the papacy to that of an office rather than a personal possession."After he took over the papacy, Benedict stated that a pope could resign if he "clearly realizes that he is no longer physically, psychologically, and spiritually capable of handling the duties of his office." (L'Osservatore Romano/Reuters )
In The Pope Who Quit, Sweeney writes about how in 2009, Benedict had aligned himself with Celestine's "memory and legacy." During a visit to L'Aquila, Italy, following the devastating earthquake that had hit the area, "Without explanation the pope paused for several minutes, removed the pallium from around his shoulders and laid it gently on Celestine's glass-encased tomb," Sweeney writes.
The Y-shaped pallium is a symbol of the pope's authority.
Both Celestine and Benedict had professed reluctance to become pope. Sweeney says Celestine's papacy "was a disaster and it was a mess, so it made perfect sense that he stepped down."
It's too soon to say what Benedict's legacy will be, but Sweeney notes that he really just continued John Paul's papacy.
"History books will look at the two of them in tandem."
Top News Headlines
- Sopranos star James Gandolfini dies in Italy
- Canada buys rare War of 1812 collection for $573K
- Caregiving dads pay steep penalties at work, study says
- Dozens of children seized from Manitoba Mennonite community
Latest World News Headlines
- U.S. tries to allay Karzai anger over Taliban peace talks
- Hopes dimmed for talks aimed at ending the Afghan war when an angry President Hamid Karzai suspended security negotiations with the U.S. and scuttled a peace delegation to the Taliban, sending American officials scrambling to preserve the possibility of dialogue with the militants. . more »
- Few options for Brazil leader in face of protests
- With massive protests by middle-class Brazilians demanding wholesale government reforms, people all over this continent-sized country have reached a verdict on the streets and online: "The giant has awakened." more »
- Obama renews call to cut nuclear stockpiles
- Summoning the harsh history of this once-divided city, President Barack Obama on Wednesday cautioned the U.S. and Europe against "complacency" brought on by peace, pledging to cut America's deployed nuclear weapons by one-third if Cold War foe Russia does the same. more »
- Neil Macdonald: Washington's obsession with leakers
- Julian Assange and Edward Snowden are just the most prominent targets in an all-out legal and propaganda campaign that America's security apparatus is mounting against leakers everywhere, Neil Macdonald writes. more »
- Why Canadians get sick from tap water Jun. 19, 2013 5:11 PM Author Chris Wood believes one of the greatest threats to the health of Canadians dribbles into their homes every day from the kitchen faucet.
- Bob Rae quits as MP in 'very emotional' decision
- Wearing a mask at a riot is now a crime
- 2 men jailed in Dominican wedding fight back in Canada
- B.C. teacher duct-taped students' mouths
- Sopranos star James Gandolfini dies in Italy
- Obesity now recognized as a disease
- Dozens of children seized from Manitoba Mennonite community
- Half of First Nations children live in poverty
- Huge ancient city at Angkor Wat revealed by lasers