Neil Macdonald: The right to work for less
By Neil Macdonald, CBC News
Posted: Dec 11, 2012 5:07 AM ET
Last Updated: Dec 11, 2012 8:35 AM ET
Related
Related Stories
The citizens of Michigan will soon be given the right to work. They must be terribly grateful.
On his website, Gov. Rick Snyder declares that the "right to work" legislation headed for his signature as early as today "will improve the lives of countless Michigan families by restoring workplace fairness and equality for all workers."
In fact, calling Michigan's new labour law "right to work" legislation is like calling a bill that strips away hard-fought civil liberties "The Patriot Act," or denying gay Americans the right to wed by passing the "Defence of Marriage Act."
In the late-1940s, George Orwell invented the concept of newspeak to lampoon such oily official euphemisms. He could not have imagined how the skill would be perfected in America decades later.
Right-to-work laws are almost exclusively the efforts of Republican legislators in the American South and West and essentially mean the outlawing of almost any arrangement guaranteeing union security.
Michigan's law, actually two bills passed by the Republican-controlled state legislature on Tuesday, is merely the latest in a long train of these partisan victories. But its symbolic import is that it will likely deal a crippling blow to already weakened unions in the state where the American labour movement was born.
Once such laws take force, workers cannot be compelled to pay union dues, or in some cases to join the union where they work. Companies are freed from any obligation to deduct union dues from paycheques.
This is always framed as a matter of individual freedom, a law to liberate the worker from the tyranny of Big Labour, which may spend someone's hard-earned dues on causes that person doesn't support.
But in practice, right-to-work laws enfeeble unions, which is what they are meant to do.
Under these laws, companies can easily discourage new workers from voluntarily signing union cards. And a union forced to directly collect dues from workers who are under no obligation to pay them is not going to collect nearly as much.
Work for less
There are 23 "right to work" states in the U.S., right now, most of them in the deeply union-unfriendly Norma Rae South.
Workers in those states enjoy lower wages, roughly 10 per cent lower, and of course far fewer protections against arbitrary treatment at the hands of managers striving for efficiency bonuses.
Unionized workers in Michigan gather on the steps of the state legislature to protest against the new right-to-work law that is expected to pass on Tuesday. (Associated Press)Michigan's workforce can expect to follow suit.
As President Obama said during a visit to Michigan car plant on Monday, what the right to work laws ultimately confer is "the right to work for less money."
The laws have also been a robust factor in declining union membership. At their peak in the 1950s, American unions were headed toward representing half the national workforce.
At the end of the last decade, by some estimates, barely 10 per cent of U.S. workers were unionized.
Now, it is unarguably true the unions brought a lot of their misfortune upon themselves. The larger ones have often been corrupt and sometimes entangled with organized crime.
They have often stubbornly protected mediocrity, sometimes even opposing any entrenchment of the concept of merit, which has given rise to a public image of unions as the protectors of smug deadwood.
At a newspaper where I once worked, an entire shift of pressmen were paid full wages simply to be on standby every night. They didn't even have to show up. It was in their contract.
Terminate at will
Digging their own grave, some of the more ideological unions even remain committed to the concept of "worker control of the workplace," and have shown themselves utterly indifferent to the good of the employers — private- or public-sector — that their members serve.
Corporate managers have also been complicit in this death spiral, agreeing to pension terms that have hobbled corporations and, nowadays, threaten to bankrupt state and local governments across the U.S.
In this light, the politicians who push these right-to-work laws like to claim they have the general good of their state's economy in mind. And statistics tend to show higher growth in those places that have passed such legislation.
But one can argue that is largely because corporations migrate to jurisdictions that give workers the least power, just as credit card companies flock to states without anti-usury laws, like South Dakota and Delaware.
Of course, an even more attractive option for employers is the "employment-at-will" laws that certain states have enacted.
Virginia is one such state. To quote from its website: "The employer may terminate any employee at any time, for any reason, or for no reason."
Maryland, considered a more progressive jurisdiction, has rebuffed Republican attempts to join the right-to-work group, which primarily targets union activity.
But for those workers unfortunate enough not to be protected by a collective agreement or contract, Maryland expands the "at-will" concept to allow its employers to terminate for any reason, "whether fair or not."
To be clear: unfair labour practice is entrenched in Maryland law.
This entire trend represents some of the most significant victories achieved by the corporate interests behind many of today's hard-right political movements, conservative activists like the billionaire Koch Brothers, Dick DeVos, the Amway scion, and Richard J. Stephenson, the business tycoon who sits on the board of Freedom Works, the most prominent Tea Party organization in America.
Still, even those in the business of reducing the protections of ordinary workers seem to make sure they leave a few in place for themselves.
When former Freedom Works chairman Dick Armey parted ways with the organization a few weeks ago over an "ideological difference," it was reported, the former Republican politician was able to walk away with an $8 million severance deal.
After all, a fella needs some job security.
Share Tools
Top News Headlines
- How was the Mike Duffy report 'whitewashed?'
- Opposition parties pushed the government on Thursday to answer questions about the "whitewashed" Duffy report while the RCMP is also seeking more information from the Senate as part of its review of questionable expenses. more »
- 2nd suspect in Tim Bosma murder case to plead not guilty
- The lawyer for Mark Smich says the Oakville, Ont., resident will plead not guilty to first-degree murder in the death of Tim Bosma, the Hamilton man who disappeared earlier this month after taking two men on a test drive of his truck. more »
- SNC-Lavalin letter says Gadhafi son offered VP post: RCMP
- SNC-Lavalin's ties to Libya's former dictatorship ran so deep the company offered the son of Moammar Gadhafi a six-figure job as a vice president in 2008, according to a newly unsealed RCMP affidavit. more »
- Canada Post campaigns against 'no flyers' mailbox signs
- Canada Post has been mailing more than 900,000 letters across the country to people to try to convince them to remove "no flyer" signs from their mailboxes. more »
Must Watch
Latest World News Headlines
- Boy Scouts of America approve of gay youth members
- The Boy Scouts of America's National Council has voted to ease a long-standing ban and allow openly gay boys to be accepted as scouts. more »
- 2 more arrests linked to hacking death of British soldier
- WARNING: This story contains graphic content. Two more people have been arrested by officers investigating the hacking death of a U.K. soldier in London, say British police. more »
- Atlantic hurricane season forecast to be busy
- The U.S. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration is predicting is busier than average Atlantic hurricane season with up to 20 named storms, including as many as six major hurricanes. more »
- What happens when a virus becomes a commodity
- There are still conflicts over sharing viruses, an international law professor says. more »
The National
The Current
- Politics in the Classroom May. 23, 2013 5:06 PM We visit a place where the rhymes of Dr. Seuss are thought too politically shrill to be heard in a classroom in British Columbia.
- 2nd suspect in Tim Bosma murder case to plead not guilty
- Toronto Mayor Rob Ford fires chief of staff
- 2 more arrests linked to hacking death of British soldier
- How was the Mike Duffy report 'whitewashed?'
- Chained-teen's mom wants man who pleaded guilty 'to suffer'
- Vancouver man abandons Porsche on B.C. ferry
- Neil Macdonald: Harper no Obama when it comes to dealing with scandals
- B.C. teen saves pet dog in 'terrifying' cougar attack
- Mike Duffy's primary home not P.E.I., unedited Senate report says

