What if girls had always had an equal shot at the throne?
By Janet Davison, CBC News
Posted: Oct 28, 2011 6:43 PM ET
Last Updated: Oct 28, 2011 11:53 PM ET
Changes to British law will allow any elder daughter of Prince William and Kate, the Duchess of Cambridge, to inherit the throne rather than have the succession pass to a younger brother. (Alastair Grant/Associated Press)
Related
When the future King Edward VII found out as a seven-year-old that he had to study hard because he was destined for the throne, it surprised him.
After all, he had an older sister, and everyone always made a fuss over her. Plus his mother, Queen Victoria, was doing a fine job running the royal show.
Victoria, eldest daughter of Queen Victoria, married Prince Frederick of Prussia, and their eldest son became Kaiser Wilhelm the Second of Germany. W. & D. Downey/Getty Images"As a kid, he'd always just assumed his older sister was going to be Victoria the Second," says Carolyn Harris, a teaching fellow at Queen's University in Kingston, Ont., and an expert on British royalty.
"It had to be explained to this little boy a few times that it's you and all your brothers before it's your sisters."
Not anymore.
Changes approved by Commonwealth leaders clear the way for women to inherit the throne on the same basis as men. No longer will a male heir take precedence over an older sister.
All that raises an intriguing question: What if it had always been that way?
"There's a lot of interesting what-ifs," Harris says.
Among them, would Henry VIII have even come to power (sparing a few wives their grief) and who would have been on the British and German thrones during the First World War.
As History Today editor Paul Lay wrote in the Guardian newspaper recently, Queen Victoria's daughter "also happened to be the Empress of Germany and Queen of Prussia and would have united the crowns of the greatest military and industrial powers of the age."
"Her son, Kaiser Wilhelm II, would have been King William V, the first and second world wars would never have happened and we would all be driving top-of-the-range Audis and embracing low levels of personal debt."
A different First World War?
Most intriguing of the what ifs, Harris suggests, and most recent is the case of Queen Victoria, who was on the throne from 1837 until 1901. Victoria's first child was her namesake daughter, and her second was the aforementioned Edward. The younger Victoria married Prince Frederick of Prussia, and their eldest son became Kaiser Wilhelm the Second of Germany.
Had he ended up on the throne of England and Germany, "one can assume World War I wouldn’t have happened the way it did," Harris says.
Mind you, she doubts it would have come to that.
"If Victoria had been the heir to the English throne, realistically they would have found her a different husband," says Harris, and not one who was the heir to another dynasty.
Dynastic marriage had been the way of the royal world for a while, but it was falling out of favour by that time.
"Dynastic marriage ceased to be as politically important with the end of the Napoleonic wars and the beginning of the 19th century," says Harris. "But throughout the 19th century until about the 1920s, there were only so many people that a member of a royal house could marry who were also royal."
If girls had equally inherited the throne, other intriguing possibilities emerge in the line of succession. Margaret Tudor might have followed her father, Henry VII, meaning her younger brother might not have become Henry VIII.
'No prohibitions'
King Henry VIII sits with his daughter Princess Mary and William Somers, the jester, in a portrait by Hans Holbein the Younger. Spencer Arnold/Getty Images"Henry the VIII did have an older sister who was born between his eldest brother, who died, and him, and she became Queen of Scotland so one assumes Scotland and England would have been unified a few generations earlier," says Harris.
Or Henry VIII, who reigned from 1509 to 1547, might not have been so concerned about having a male heir — to the peril of a few wives.
"At the time Henry was reigning, there were no prohibitions against women ruling, but there also had never been a woman successfully take the throne and rule," Harris says.
"One of William the Conqueror’s granddaughters had tried and ended up in a 20-year civil war with her male cousin back in the 1100s."
Charles I, who reigned from 1625 to 1649 and ended up beheaded after being charged with treason, also had an older sister.
The succession changes in British legislation that goes back to 1689 will apply only to descendants of Prince Charles, current heir to the throne, and do not affect the existing line.
If the changes were retroactive, it would cause considerable juggling: for example, Princess Anne, who is older than her brothers Prince Andrew and Prince Edward but below them in the line of succession, would rise from her current position at No. 10 to No. 4, after Charles and Princes William and Harry.
Share Tools
Top News Headlines
- Canadian Pacific strikers face back-to-work legislation
- Labour Minister Lisa Raitt is prepared to end the Canadian Pacific Railway strike if necessary, after both CP and the union rejected a proposal for voluntary arbitration by the government-appointed negotiator on Sunday. Raitt says she is "extremely disappointed."
more »
- Quebec students and province to resume talks
- Quebec's university student federation has confirmed negotiations between student leaders and the provincial government will resume Monday afternoon. more »
- Syrian regime denies role in Houla massacre
- The UN Security Council condemned the Syrian regime at an emergency meeting Sunday, holding president Bashar al-Assad's military responsible for the massacre of more than 100 people, dozens of whom were children younger than 10 years old. more »
- Ryder Hesjedal wins prestigious Giro d'Italia
- Victoria native Ryder Hesjedal has become the first Canadian to win one of the cycling world's three Grand Tour events, wrapping up the 2012 Giro d'Italia with an excellent performance in the final stage in Milan. more »
- Neighbour may have helped find missing kids in Mexico
- Two Winnipeg children who had been missing for nearly four years were found in Mexico after a man raised concerns about his neighbour, according to a private investigator. more »
Latest World News Headlines
- Egypt presidential candidates allege vote fraud
- Three top candidates in Egypt's presidential race have filed appeals to the election commission, alleging violations in the first round vote that they say could change the outcome. more »
- Ryder Hesjedal wins prestigious Giro d'Italia
- Victoria native Ryder Hesjedal has become the first Canadian to win one of the cycling world's three Grand Tour events, wrapping up the 2012 Giro d'Italia with an excellent performance in the final stage in Milan. more »
- IMF chief blasted for chastising Greeks on tax evasion
- International Monetary Fund chief Christine Lagarde is backtracking from recent remarks that she has more sympathy for poor African children than Greeks suffering under the country's economic problems and austerity measures. more »
- Nepal PM calls new elections after constitution failure
- Nepal's prime minister called new elections for November after the term of the Constituent Assembly expired at midnight Sunday without political leaders completing the task of writing a new constitution. more »
Dispatches »
- Foreign slaves serving the U.S. military machine May. 24, 2012 3:33 PM How does a hairdresser recruited for work in Dubai, wind up slaving for the U.S. military in a war zone in Iraq? There are tens of thousands serving in what's come to be known as America's "Invisible Army."
Connect Newsroom Blog
Etan Patz, Brian Banks & 50 Shades of Grey May. 25, 2012 8:56 PM On his first full day of his new life, former football star Brian Banks joins us live.
- Seniors float above Montreal's Quartier Latin
- Accused in blast that killed Alberta mom handled her funds
- Remains found in bag on Cape Breton river ID'd
- Neighbour may have helped find missing kids in Mexico
- Quebec students and province to resume talks
- Lip-dub marriage proposal an internet hit
- Syrian regime denies role in Houla massacre
- B.C. NDP calls for unity in fighting coast guard closure
- Canadian Pacific strikers face back-to-work legislation

