Nuclear-armed subs collide at sea, but no radiation released: officials
British, French vessels suffer damage described as minor
Last Updated: Monday, February 16, 2009 | 7:03 AM ET
CBC News
Related
Video
- Adrienne Arsenault reports: Nuclear-armed subs collide at sea, but no radiation released: officials (Runs: 2:40)
- Play: Real Media »
- Play: QuickTime »
This Oct. 25, 1992, photo shows sailors aboard HMS Vanguard, in Holy Loch, Scotland. Nuclear-armed submarines from Britain and France collided in the Atlantic Ocean this month, damaging both vessels but releasing no radioactivity, a British official says. (Chris Bacon/PA/Associated Press)Two nuclear-armed submarines from Britain and France collided deep under the Atlantic Ocean earlier this month, causing damage but releasing no radioactivity, officials in London and Paris said Monday.
HMS Vanguard, the oldest vessel in Britain's fleet of nuclear-armed submarines, and France's Le Triomphant sub, which was also carrying nuclear missiles, both suffered damage described as minor in the underwater crash.
No crew members were reported injured in the incident, first reported by the British tabloid newspaper, the Sun, on Monday morning.
Britain's most senior sailor, First Sea Lord Adm. Jonathon Band, said the crash posed no risk to the safety of the submarines' nuclear reactors and nuclear missiles. But he offered no explanation of how the rare incident might have occurred.
"The two submarines came into contact at very low speed," Band said in a statement. "Both submarines remained safe."
France's Defence Ministry said the ballistic missile submarines had been carrying out routine patrols when they collided.
"They briefly came into contact at a very low speed while submerged. There were no injuries. Neither their nuclear deterrence missions nor their safety were affected," the ministry said Monday.
Neither Britain nor France would say when the collision occurred.
Damage visible, BBC reports
After the accident, the French submarine returned to its base on L'Ile Longue on France's western tip under its own power, escorted as usual by a frigate, the ministry said.
The BBC reported that HMS Vanguard had to be towed back to a submarine base in Scotland and dents were visible in its hull.
Naval warfare experts said the collision was an astounding event.
"This really shouldn't have happened at all," said Stephen Saunders, a retired British Royal Navy commodore and the editor of Jane's Fighting Ships, "It's a very serious incident and I find it quite extraordinary."
Saunders said Britain and France would probably have let each other know that their submarines were in the same general area, but without giving specific co-ordinates of their vessels.
"The whole point is to go and hide in a big chunk of ocean and not be found. They tend to go around very slowly and not make much noise," he said.
As part of each country's independent nuclear deterrent, submarines stay at sea awaiting orders to fire their atomic weapons in the event of a war.
Politicians, activists demand answers
CBC's Nancy Durham in London says the collision is hugely embarrassing to both countries, which try to maintain tight secrecy about their nuclear weapons.
"This is just the kind of thing we would never have heard of," Durham says, "Britain's Ministry of Defence would have never made an announcement like this but once it got out there in the press this morning, they were forced to comment."
The incident sparked concern among nuclear activists, who have long warned that nuclear-armed submarines pose risks of radioactive leaks into the world's waters.
"This is a nuclear nightmare of the highest order," said Kate Hudson, chairwoman of Britain's Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament.
"The collision of two submarines, both with nuclear reactors and nuclear weapons onboard, could have released vast amounts of radiation and scattered scores of nuclear warheads across the seabed."
She called on British Prime Minister Gordon Brown to end such patrols, which she said have at least one British nuclear sub in the Atlantic at all times.
Opposition political leaders also demanded a full explanation from the government.
Brown "needs to explain how it is possible for a submarine carrying weapons of mass destruction to collide with another submarine carrying weapons of mass destruction in the middle of the world's second-largest ocean," said Angus Robertson of Scotland's pro-independence Scottish National Party.
With files from the Associated PressShare Tools
Top News Headlines
- Air Canada confident it can reach deal with pilots
- Travellers flying Air Canada can keep booking their flights as negotiations continue with a new federally appointed mediator to help resolve an ongoing contract dispute between the airline and its pilots. more »
- Legalize pot, say former B.C. attorneys general
- Four former B.C. attorneys general are joining a coalition of health and justice experts calling for the legalization of marijuana. more »
- Whitney Houston's funeral to be held Saturday
- Pop star Whitney Houston's funeral service will be held Saturday in the New Jersey church where she first showcased her singing talents as a child. more »
- CN blamed for fatal train derailment in Illinois
- CN is being blamed for a 2009 train derailment in Illinois, in which several cars went off the tracks and caught fire, killing one person and injuring seven others. more »
Latest World News Headlines
- Eurozone meeting on Greek bailout cancelled
- A meeting of the finance chiefs of the 17 euro countries to discuss Greece's second multibillion bailout planned for Wednesday was called off after Athens failed to deliver on several demands made by its partners in the currency union. more »
- CN blamed for fatal train derailment in Illinois
- CN is being blamed for a 2009 train derailment in Illinois, in which several cars went off the tracks and caught fire, killing one person and injuring seven others. more »
- U.S. weighs steep nuclear arms cuts
- The Obama administration is weighing options for sharp new cuts to the U.S. nuclear force, including a reduction of up to 80 per cent in the number of deployed weapons, The Associated Press has learned. more »
- World feels the Valentine's Day love
- People around the globe celebrate Cupid's day, from Beijing to New York. more »
Dispatches »
- Syrian refugees' defiance and division Feb. 14, 2012 4:48 PM With the deadly game in Syria changing almost daily, CBC's Derek Stoffel in Turkey met militant refugees who reflect the division in the rebel forces about whether to go it alone or wait for the international community to back them against the current regime.
Connect Newsroom Blog
Second Chances, Lin-sanity & Nanaimo Love Feb. 14, 2012 5:55 PM Jeremy Lin and the New York Knicks are in Toronto tonight and we're going to find out what all the fuss is about.
- Online surveillance critics accused of supporting child porn
- Whitney Houston's funeral to be held Saturday
- HMCS Corner Brook collision damage extensive
- Online surveillance bill targets child porn: Toews
- Mooning Queen proves costly for Australian man
- Legalize pot, say former B.C. attorneys general
- MacKay says submarine fleet has 'spotty' history
- Man kidnapped at Greyhound station escapes captors
- Stanley Cup rioter seen in brick attack on cop

