German court sides with small pubs; smokers can puff again
Rule on smoking rooms favoured big establishments, judges rule
Last Updated: Wednesday, July 30, 2008 | 1:24 PM ET
CBC News
A guest enjoys a beer and a pipe in a Munich bar on Wednesday. Germany's highest court relaxed smoking rules for single-room establishments. (Diether Endlicher/Associated Press)German states can ban smoking in bars and restaurants, but not if they make exceptions for big establishments with smoking rooms, Germany's highest court ruled Wednesday.
The judges decided it was "unfair to the little guy" to put one-room bars and restaurants at a disadvantage, the German state broadcaster, Deutsche Welle, summed up.
The court upheld the constitutionality of smoking bans but struck down the way they were implemented in some of the country's 16 states. With one of Europe's highest smoking rates, Germany has a patchwork of smoking laws, most allowing establishments to cordon off separate rooms for smokers.
The court gave states until the end of 2009 to comply with the ruling, Deutsche Welle said. They must either pass blanket smoking bans for all restaurants and bars or rewrite laws to allow for smoking in corner bars.
Until laws are changed, one-room pubs will be exempt if they make it clear that smoke may be present and turn away people under 18, the legal age to buy cigarettes.
The ruling was hailed in some circles as a victory for German smokers, but anti-tobacco campaigners vowed to do their best to make it temporary.
Friedrich Wiebel, a spokesman for the German Smoke-Free Society, said the bar owners' legal success could backfire on the entire hospitality industry.
"We will fight hard over the next year and a half to push states to make laws that protect non-smokers by allowing absolutely no exceptions," he told the Associated Press.
With files from the Associated PressShare Tools
Top News Headlines
- Greek parliament set for crucial bailout vote
- Greek lawmakers are poised to begin debate on legislation introducing the severe austerity measures necessary for the country to secure a €130 billion bailout and stave off bankruptcy. more »
- Attawapiskat receives first modular home
- The first of 22 modular homes promised by the federal government to Attawapiskat has arrived to the remote northern Ontario First Nations community, the Aboriginal Affairs minister's office has confirmed. more »
- Head of Arab League's Syria observer mission quits
- The Sudanese head of the Arab League's observer mission to Syria has resigned, as the group was to consider a proposal to revive its suspended mission, officials said. more »
- Manitoba trailer fire kills 4
- Four people are dead after an early-morning fire quickly engulfed a residential trailer in Selkirk, Man. more »
Latest World News Headlines
- Head of Arab League's Syria observer mission quits
- The Sudanese head of the Arab League's observer mission to Syria has resigned, as the group was to consider a proposal to revive its suspended mission, officials said. more »
- Whitney Houston 'happy' in days before death
- Whitney Houston, pop music's queen until her voice was ravaged by drug use, spent her last days with family, friends and doing what she was best known for: singing. more »
- Tibet PM sees human-rights 'tragedy' unfolding
- In an exclusive interview Saturday on CBC Radio's The House, the prime minister of the Tibetan government-in-exile, Lobsang Sangay, sounded the alarm on the "tragedy" unfolding in Tibet and called on Canada to take action. more »
- Harper says human rights talk with China is paying off
- In an exclusive interview airing on CBC Radio's The House Saturday, Prime Minister Stephen Harper says raising the issue of human rights is paying off but warns the Chinese and "other governments" to help shape a positive future for Syria. more »
Dispatches »
- Inside Egyptian military's business web Feb. 10, 2012 1:51 PM When it got out of the business of war with Israel, Egypt's military got into the business of business. Over and under the table; on and off the books. Even using conscripts as cheap labour. CBC's Margaret Evans found shopkeeping generals rather reluctant to talk shop though.
Connect Newsroom Blog
Siege in Syria, Ship Rescue & The Pickton Inquiry Feb. 9, 2012 8:08 PM We'll talk to a Syrian-American doctor tonight about whether the Assad regime is using medicine as a weapon.
- Pop queen Whitney Houston dies at 48
- Whitney Houston 'happy' in days before death
- Whitney Houston's death sparks chorus of grief
- Quebec man charged with killing mother, 2 nieces
- Ultimate Tazer Ball combines shock and soccer
- Adults-only trade show cancelled in B.C. Bible belt
- Gadhafi Mexico plot riles SNC-Lavalin, insiders say
- Weed Man's sales tactics draw fire from consumer ministry
- Iran's Ahmadinejad promises 'big' nuclear news

