World Court orders U.S. to try to stop Texas from executing 5 Mexicans
Last Updated: Wednesday, July 16, 2008 | 1:12 PM ET
CBC News
Related
Internal Links
External Links
(Note: CBC does not endorse and is not responsible for the content of external sites - links will open in new window)
The United States must do everything possible to prevent Texas from executing five Mexican nationals on death row in the state while their cases are being considered by the International Court of Justice (ICJ), judges in the Netherlands-based tribunal ruled Wednesday.
Mexico contends that dozens of its citizens facing execution in U.S. jails have been denied their right to consular access after their arrests on capital crimes charges.
A series of ICJ rulings have gone in Mexico’s favour since 2004, when the court ordered the U.S. to review the cases of 51 Mexicans facing the death penalty in U.S. jails.
President George W. Bush complied with that order and asked Texas to postpone executions of Mexican convicts, but Texas got a U.S. Supreme Court ruling the following year that said Bush had overstepped his authority.
The state pressed ahead with plans to execute Jose Medellin and has set Aug. 5 as the date he will die by lethal injection.
Medellin was convicted of the rape and murder of two teenage girls in 1993. His lawyers say he was denied his right to see Mexican Embassy officials during his incarceration, but prosecutors said he didn't ask for that right until he had been sentenced to death.
Four other Mexican citizens face imminent execution in Texas.
ICJ has no jurisdiction, U.S. argues
Wednesday’s ICJ ruling says Bush and the U.S. government must try to stop the state from carrying out those death sentences.
"The court indicates that the United States of America shall take all measures necessary to ensure that five Mexican nationals are not executed, pending its final judgment," Judge Rosalyn Higgins said.
The ICJ exists to settle disputes between UN member states, and though its rulings are seen as binding, there is no enforcement mechanism.
U.S. State Department lawyer John Bellinger argued that the ICJ did not have jurisdiction because Bush agreed with Mexico and there was no dispute.
"It almost never happens that the federal government enters [into] state court proceedings," he said, calling the Bush's intervention "highly unusual."
Mexico's chief advocate, Juan Manuel Gomez-Robledo, told the court the U.S. was nonetheless "in breach of its international obligations." He said international law applies not only to nations, but to their component states. He asked the court to clarify its earlier ruling and in the meantime intercede with U.S. authorities to halt the schedule of executions.
Mexico abolished capital punishment in 2005 and objects in principle to the U.S. and other countries sentencing its citizens to die.
The ICJ acknowledged that the U.S. federal government "has been taking many diverse and insistent measures" to persuade Texas not to carry out executions of any of the Mexicans covered by the original 2004 ruling.
Bellinger said that the international court has limited powers over U.S. states or federal authorities in Washington.
"It does not have technical legal effect in the United States that would … have a direct impact either on the United States or on Texas itself," he said.
Federal authorities were still discussing the case "constructively" with Texas, Bellinger said, and "Texas does take this all very seriously."
Mexico's ambassador to the Netherlands, Jorge Lomonaco Tonda, said he was satisfied with Wednesday’s ruling and didn’t expect any executions to take place before a final court decision.
There has been no comment from the Texas authorities on the court order.
With files from the Associated PressShare Tools
Top News Headlines
- Greece passes new austerity deal amid rioting
- Greek lawmakers have approved harsh new austerity measures demanded by bailout creditors to save the debt-crippled nation from bankruptcy, after riots in Athens and other cities left stores looted and burned and more than 120 people hurt. more »
- Quebec town 'heartbroken' after killing of woman, sisters
- A small Quebec town is in mourning Sunday after a Quebec man was charged with killing his nieces and his mother, who were found dead in their family home. more »
- Whitney Houston's body set for autopsy
- Whitney Houston was found in a hotel bathtub but it'll take weeks to determine precisely how she died, a Los Angeles coroner's official says. more »
- Musicians who died before their time
- The growing list of musicians who have died young. more »
Latest World News Headlines
- Greece passes new austerity deal amid rioting
- Greek lawmakers have approved harsh new austerity measures demanded by bailout creditors to save the debt-crippled nation from bankruptcy, after riots in Athens and other cities left stores looted and burned and more than 120 people hurt. more »
- Child rescued from Kosovo avalanche that killed 9
- Rescuers have pulled a child alive from the rubble of a house flattened by a massive avalanche that killed both her parents and at least seven of her relatives in a remote mountain village in southern Kosovo. more »
- Italy cruise ship fuel being pumped out
- Underwater pumping operations began Sunday to remove some of the 1.9 million litres of fuel aboard the Costa Concordia, officials said, nearly a month after the cruise ship ran aground off the Italy's Tuscan coast. more »
- Syria observer mission head steps down
- The Sudanese head of the Arab League's observer mission to Syria has resigned, as the group was to consider a proposal to revive its suspended mission, officials said. more »
Dispatches »
- Inside Egyptian military's business web Feb. 10, 2012 1:51 PM When it got out of the business of war with Israel, Egypt's military got into the business of business. Over and under the table; on and off the books. Even using conscripts as cheap labour. CBC's Margaret Evans found shopkeeping generals rather reluctant to talk shop though.
Connect Newsroom Blog
Siege in Syria, Ship Rescue & The Pickton Inquiry Feb. 9, 2012 8:08 PM We'll talk to a Syrian-American doctor tonight about whether the Assad regime is using medicine as a weapon.
- Pop queen Whitney Houston dies at 48
- Whitney Houston's body set for autopsy
- Greece passes new austerity deal amid rioting
- Carleton University confirms death of student
- Quebec town 'heartbroken' after killing of woman, sisters
- Ultimate Tazer Ball combines shock and soccer
- Adele, Kanye West each take 3 Grammys
- Adults-only trade show cancelled in B.C. Bible belt
- Manitoba man dies after falling off moving SUV

