Canada's top court agrees to hear Khadr's unfair treatment claim
Ottawa tried to block defence from presenting fresh evidence
Last Updated: Saturday, March 22, 2008 | 6:07 PM ET
CBC News
Related
The Supreme Court of Canada will hear arguments from Omar Khadr's lawyers about the legality of his detention and upcoming military trial at a U.S. naval base in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba.
Omar Khadr, seen in 2002, is being tried for numerous charges, including murder, in a military trial at Guantanamo Bay military prison.
(Canadian Press)
In a ruling released Friday, the court dealt a blow to government lawyers and allowed Khadr's legal team to present fresh evidence it says demonstrates U.S. authorities are violating international law in their treatment of Khadr.
Khadr was captured in Afghanistan in 2002 when he was 15 and has since been held at the U.S. military base at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba.
He is facing numerous charges, including murder, in connection with the killing of a U.S. army sergeant with a grenade during a firefight between U.S. forces and Taliban fighters, in which the Toronto-born teenager was also seriously wounded.
The top court will be forced to examine whether the involvement and behaviour of Canadian officials were in conflict with Canadian domestic law, as well as Canada's obligations to international law and treaties, said Dennis Edney, Khadr's Canadian lawyer.
"We're gratified that the Supreme Court has decided that a full, complete record is before it in order to make a fair determination," Edney told CBCNews.ca in an interview Thursday from Edmonton.
Case goes before court next week
The court case stems from an earlier federal court decision that ordered the Canadian government to release documents to Khadr's lawyers for use in his defence against the murder charge. Ottawa appealed the ruling and arguments will be heard in the top court on March 26.
But his lawyers also want to use the hearing to highlight the broader point that the Americans' handling of the case doesn't meet international standards of fairness.
"By being allowed to introduce fresh evidence, we will be showing that we have to talk about Guantanamo Bay," Edney said.
The federal Justice Department also filed a motion trying to quash that argument, saying a Canadian court is the wrong place to examine U.S. actions.
Among the issues expected to be raised before the court are Khadr's age at the time of his capture and the contradictory evidence emerging from U.S. authorities in recent weeks from his pre-trial hearing at Guantanamo.
Khadr deserves child soldier status: U.S. military lawyer
Khadr's U.S. military defence lawyer has repeatedly dismissed the military tribunals as illegal and unfair, and has also questioned whether Canada has done enough to advocate on Khadr's behalf to their American counterparts.
Lt.-Cmdr. Bill Kuebler has stated Khadr is clearly a child soldier and, under international obligations, should be released and helped to reintegrate into society.
The United States and Canada are signatories to a United Nations protocol that states fighters under age 18 are to be considered child soldiers.
In an affidavit released Tuesday, Khadr alleges U.S. military interrogators in Afghanistan threatened him with rape and treated him harshly, forcing him to make false and self-incriminating statements.
He also claims Canadian diplomats and intelligence officers who questioned him at Guantanamo refused to help, accused him of lying, and passed information from their interviews to U.S. officials.
Meanwhile, documents released by the Pentagon on Thursday include an account of the 2002 gun battle by a U.S. army officer who admits he nearly ordered Khadr's execution. The officer also confirms an earlier account that Khadr was not the only Taliban fighter alive when the grenade was thrown.
With files from the Canadian PressShare Tools
Top News Headlines
- Vancouver rioter sentenced to 17 months
- Ryan Dickinson has been sentenced to 17 months in jail for his part in the June 15, 2010, Vancouver riot. more »
- Former Expos catcher Gary Carter succumbs to brain cancer
- Hall of Fame catcher Gary Carter, who left an indelible mark on baseball in Canada during his 12 years with the Montreal Expos, died on Thursday. The man nicknamed "Kid" or "Kid Carter" for his ever-smiling face and cheerfulness is free from the inoperable brain cancer that sapped his energy and took his life at age 57. more »
- Dog kills newborn in Alberta community
- Officials in Airdrie are revealing few details about the fatal mauling of an infant by a family dog in the southern Alberta city. more »
- Underwear bomber sentenced to life in prison
- A Nigerian man who tried to blow up an international flight near Detroit on behalf of al-Qaida has been sentenced to life in prison without parole. more »
Latest World News Headlines
- UN backs resolution condemning Syrian regime
- The UN General Assembly has backed a non-binding Arab League-sponsored resolution calling on Syrian President Bashar al-Assad to step down and end his regime's violent crackdown on dissidents. more »
- Honduras prison fire is world's deadliest
- The prisoners who died in the Honduran prison fire had been locked inside an overcrowded penitentiary where most inmates had never been charged, let alone convicted, according to an internal Honduran government report obtained by The Associated Press. more »
- Man who killed sons kept from being buried near them
- A Washington man who killed his two sons will be buried in the same cemetery as them following a huge public firestorm, his brother-in-law said Thursday. more »
- Amnesty accuses Libyan militias of unbridled torture
- Armed militia groups in Libya have turned on one another and now rule most of the country, torturing their opponents with impunity, Amnesty International says. more »
Dispatches »
- A special court for post-trauma vets Feb. 16, 2012 5:14 PM In the U.S. there's special justice for post-trauma distressed war vets. For those who qualify, it's not easy time -- but it works better than jail. CBC's Jennifer Westaway met one vet who did nine tours in Iraq and Afghanistan. His 10th is stateside, as a civilian.
Connect Newsroom Blog
Toews vs. Twitter, Helping Syria & Misuse of Prescription Drugs Feb. 15, 2012 7:53 PM As violence continues in Syria, we're asking what should the world do about Syria?
- Dog kills newborn in Alberta community
- Degrassi's Wheels death announced, over 4 years later
- Refugee reforms include fingerprints, no appeals for some
- Montreal telemarketers in fraud case still making calls
- Bully victim's mother tells of 'suicide box'
- Honduras prison fire is world's deadliest
- Nortel collapse linked to Chinese hackers
- 2 small earthquakes rattle Vancouver Island
- Barefoot girl's icy trek not blamed on babysitter
Omar Khadr, seen in 2002, is being tried for numerous charges, including murder, in a military trial at Guantanamo Bay military prison.

