An Egyptian-Canadian journalist imprisoned in Cairo is weighing whether he will appeal his conviction and go through the "circus" of a retrial.
Mohamed Fahmy has already been in prison for seven months, but is facing the prospect of seven years after he was found guilty on terrorism-related charges along with two Al-Jazeera English colleagues.
His Australian colleague, Peter Greste, is appealing, but Fahmy writes from behind bars that he is "conversing with many lawyers and still assessing options."
"If an appeal is accepted months from now, we will be paraded in whites again in the circus of a retrial," Fahmy wrote in a letter sent through his fiancee to Canadian Journalists for FreeExpression.
"I still believe in the back-room unannounced diplomatic efforts ongoing with the Egyptian government that even took place during the recent Gaza ceasefire talks, held in Cairo by prominent diplomats."
- 'Mr. Big' stings get stricter rules from Supreme Court
Fahmy was working in Cairo as a bureau chief for Al-Jazeera English when he and his two colleagues — Greste and Egyptian producer Baher Mohammed — were arrested last December. They were accused of supporting the outlawed Muslim Brotherhood and fabricating footage to undermine Egypt's national security --allegations the journalists have denied, saying they were just doing their jobs. As the bureau chief his legal situation is more severe than his two coworkers, with Fahmy being charged with “master-minding” a "terror operation."
Their trial was denounced as a sham by a number of international observers. The judge's sentencing reasons say the three journalists were brought together "by the devil" to destabilize the country.
In several pages of the reasoning, the judge lay out a detailed account of the evidence cited by investigators.
Largely the evidence appears to describe typical reporting, including footage produced by the journalists that included voices critical of the government and showed the turmoil in Egypt after the overthrow of Islamist President Mohammed Morsi last summer, as well as interviews with families of those killed in the crackdown on Morsi supporters.
Tom Henheffer, the executive director of Canadian Journalists for Free Expression, said the letter is part of Fahmy's strategy to build awareness internationally and show people the Egyptian court system is corrupt.
'He's a very tenacious individual and he's going to fight for this until he's free.' - Tom Henheffer, Canadian Journalists for Free Expression
"I don't think anyone should take this letter as an indication that he won't be appealing or that he's lost hope," Henheffer said. "He's a very tenacious individual and he's going to fight for this until he's free. There's no doubt of that."
Henheffer said the CJFE fully supports whatever course of action Fahmy chooses, but he noted that filing an appeal could help diplomatic efforts, by showing that he is taking every effort to prove he is not guilty.
Foreign Affairs Minister John Baird has said "bullhorn diplomacy" won't win Fahmy's release, but that Canada is pursuing all legal avenues to secure the journalist's freedom.
An excerpt from Fahmy's letter
"On paper, my situation is different than where Baher and Peter stand regardless of the sentences. The judgment indicated that I am convicted of master-minding the "terror operation" only because in reality I was the Al Jazeera Bureau Chief, and the makeshift office and suite rooms in the Marriott were under my name including all its content, staff computers, cameras, and hard-disks. Hundreds of so-called incriminating videos are listed against me although my defense never got access to them and none of these so-called fabricated videos were presented in court. Where in the world does prosecution ask for $170,000 to copy 5 CD's containing evidence in order for the defense to view them? When our defense did not pay, the court announced that "All the evidence was broadcast in the courtroom." That alone is a farce."
The whole letter is available on the CJFE website.