CBC Analysis
LARRY ZOLF:
Shot straight through the heart
CBC News Viewpoint | August 22, 2002 | More from Larry Zolf

Larry Zolf

The heart is Jean Chrétien's favourite organ. Indeed, the heart is his political metaphor. When he lost the party leadership race to John Turner in 1984, Liberal party president Iona Campagnolo introduced Chrétien as: "second in the Liberal race, but first in our hearts." Chrétien's best-selling memoir is called Straight from the Heart.

  • INDEPTH: Jean Chrétien, le p'tit gars de Shawinigan

    The present chaos in the Liberal party means that Chrétien is no longer first in the hearts of the party. Indeed, many Liberals say Jean Chrétien has shot himself straight through the heart.

    Chrétien's departure has not been a graceful one. There are more than hints in the air that he’ll be spending the next 18 months planning his revenge on Paul Martin and the Martinites. In the same 18 months, Chrétien will be exalting his chosen favourites, like John Manley. Manley will be given 10 portfolios and perhaps a seat on the Supreme Court, all at the same time, just to make sure.

    Of course, the prime minister will make certain that he leaves his successor with a Senate completely packed with his own loyal slavish admirers. The entire population of Shawinigan will be inducted into the Senate in the next 18 months.

    Inside Zolf has always liked Jean Chrétien, le petit gars de Shawinigan. Demagogues and bullyboys, tough guys who always make a quick decision, were this reporter's role models in politics. Chrétien was among them.

    Chrétien was a populist like Réal Caouette. Indeed, Chrétien beat a Creditiste to get into the House of Commons. Chrétien built his whole career on the trust of little people, small town people, simple people.

    In this, Chrétien resembled John Diefenbaker. Like Diefenbaker, Chrétien believed he was the little people, the small town people incarnate. It was not so much that Chrétien did anything for them, it was enough that he spoke for them, that his presence was a lamp and a symbol unto them.

    Chrétien's populism was a vital element in the Liberal party. That party was mostly full of the country's swells, the Beautiful People. Pearson and Trudeau, both academics, spoke for the affluent and chattering classes in the Liberal party. Chrétien was remarkable in that he managed to hang on to his populist base without completely turning off the well-off in his party.

    Diefenbaker had similar problems, but in the end, the Tory well-off sent him packing. Still, Dief remained a populist until he died. Unlike Dief, Chrétien became more and more preoccupied with being the darling of the upwardly mobile in the Liberal party. Chrétien's daughter married the heir of Power Corporation, Canada's business mammoth. Chrétien began boasting that he had become a self-made millionaire.

    Day by day, Chrétien's populist juices began to dry up. Day by day, populist Chrétien became corporate man, a corporate man like Brian Mulroney. Now, no longer a populist, Chrétien was a big boy playing poker with the big boys. He was now playing on a turf in which his deadly rival Paul Martin was more sure-footed and agile. Chrétien lost the rustics and then the ethnic groups who had once loved him.

    In Quebec, the little people began to rally to Paul Martin as early as Election 2000. The Quebec professionals, the Outremont crowd, were already for Martin.

    Out west, the common people were for the Alliance, the elites for Paul Martin. Even in rural Newfoundland and across the Maritimes, Chrétien was losing his populist grip.

    It could be argued that Chrétien's abandonment of the little people in favour of the fat cats sealed his fate years ago. What is certain, as was certain with Diefenbaker, is that populist politics is a dangerous game with a basically urban, well-educated electorate. Chrétien's populism caused him the loss of the Liberal party shakers and movers. It ultimately caused Chrétien his present shove and push denouement.

    The toppling of Chrétien will remain one of Canadian history's most dramatic moments. It may even write finis to Canadian populism for a long, long time to come, but life goes on. The country wanted political resolution and it got it from Chrétien. Now it wants peace and quiet from the Liberal party. The leadership review will be shelved; the first Liberal who says he wants to go on with it will be tarred and feathered.

    A kind of dance will ensue in Ottawa. Chrétien will soon be seen cheered to the rafters in the House of Commons by the entire Liberal caucus. The words "Kim Campbell" will never be heard on any Liberal lips again.

    Chrétien's sudden departure has made history. No other prime minister has been forced to shoot himself straight through the heart.






    ^TOP

  • MENU
    ANALYSIS & VIEWPOINT MAIN PAGE » REPORTS FROM ABROAD
    CBC CONTRIBUTORS: Editor's Notes
    Mary Sheppard
    Global View: Ghana
    Colleen Ross
    Health
    Maureen Taylor
    Minority Report
    Natasha Fatah
    The National
    Rex Murphy
    On the Money
    Tom McFeat
    Postcard from America
    Rosa Hwang
    Schlesinger's View
    Joe Schlesinger
    Army Reservist
    Mike Vernon

    FREELANCE CONTRIBUTORS: Cafe Chat
    June Chua
    Disability Matters
    Living with a disability
    Global View: Asia
    Ashifa Kassam
    Global View: China
    Kirk Kenny
    Global View: China
    Trevor Metz
    Global View: China
    Sylvia Yu Chao
    Global View: Denmark
    Jessica Grant Jørgensen
    Global View: India
    Siva Swaminathan
    Global View: Ireland
    Clare Byrne
    Global View:Japan
    Dan Hilton
    Global View: Middle East
    Jim Reed
    Global View: South Korea
    Yoav Cerralbo
    Global View: Uganda
    Jonathan Woodward
    Global View: Zambia
    Mike Quinn
    Inside Medicine
    Sandra Donaldson
    Inside Ottawa
    Chris Waddell
    Legal Affairs
    Michelle Mann
    Maritime Log
    Vicki Robertson
    Media Watch
    Ira Basen
    Modern Living
    Georgie Binks
    Observations
    Martin O'Malley
    On the other hand
    Anthony Westell
    Politics
    Larry Zolf
    Schooling
    Mary-Ellen Lang
    Science Decoded
    Sumitra Rajagopalan
    Science Friction
    Stephen Strauss
    A Soldier's Story
    Sgt. Russell D. Storring
    A Soldier's Diary from Afghanistan
    Cpl. Brian Sanders
    Stand on Guard
    Heather Mallick
    West Coast Living
    Gloria Chang
    Western View
    Terilyn S. Paulgaard

    » PAST CONTRIBUTORS

    ABOUT VIEWPOINT:
    Viewpoint is CBC.ca's place for informed opinion and commentary. Our goal is to provide a range of informed perspectives from around the world and here at home on issues of interest to Canadians. All material published in the Viewpoint section is subject to CBC’s journalistic policy, standards and practices.

    Writing for Viewpoint
    We accept queries from people with significant expertise in their field and previous writing experience. We are interested in domestic and international contributions. We do not accept unsolicited finished pieces.

    If you want to contribute to Viewpoint, please send your query to letters@cbc.ca with VIEWPOINT in the subject line and please include three samples of your published work. Columns are typically 800 words in length and focus on timely issues, events or personal stories with wide appeal. Please familiarize yourself with our content before submitting your ideas. Only those accepted will be contacted.
    FEEDBACK:
    Questions or comments? Email us!
    BIOGRAPHY:
    LARRY ZOLF
    POLITICAL COMMENTATOR

    Veteran journalist and Canadian political expert Larry Zolf is a regular contributor to CBC News Online. Larry has been a critic, reporter, producer and consultant for CBC news and current affairs since he joined the CBC in 1962. Born and raised in North End Winnipeg, the hotbed of general strikes and socialism, Larry has covered stories such as integration in Mississippi and the October Crisis in Quebec. He was one of the hosts of the CBC's flagship current affairs television show "This Hour Has 7 Days." He is now retired.

    MORE:
    Print this page